Private education and school debts · Page 1 of 2

Selected findings from library records with scoped primary-source review.

Research reference · Consumer guides and topic map

Plain-English guides on this topic

ITT corporate CFPB judgment public payment implementation and source limits

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

E162Y already establishes the judgment and its required $0 estate claim. This review adds only public implementation evidence and attribution. No cash award is inferred from the face amount or from unrelated CUSO, PEAKS, Department of Education, or student-class proceedings. The no-match observation is confined to the identified returned directory and allocation windows and specified fiscal-year summaries or tables. It is neither a full historical audit of all Bureau funds nor a legal determination that payments could never occur. No ITT-specific direct payment notice, administrator, fund allocation, amendment, estate closure or payment record was verified. The February 2022 bankruptcy order was publicly posted by class counsel and is preserved as delivered, with the court filing header bound to the exact web-tool lines. It authorizes a separate distribution and does not establish actual implementation, total disbursed, current claim status, individual outcome or source of every estate dollar. The publisher copy has copy restrictions, and no access or copy restriction was altered. No contact or private account or case investigation occurred. No matching CFPB distribution appears within the November 3, 2026 directory edition and the exact reviewed allocation and fiscal report windows. Absence in those records does not determine whether distribution occurred elsewhere or could occur later. Visually verified both pages of class-counsel-posted Doc 4636, including Judge Carr signature, February 23, 2022 filing stamp and authorization to commence the separate student-class distribution with American Legal Claims Services. No actual disbursement, account outcome, later filing, estate closure or filed proof-of-claim amendment is verified.

Strategic Financial Solutions debt relief fees and preliminary enforcement

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The dollar figure and sales descriptions are allegations in the specified historical public filing and agency summary. The complete second amended pleading was outside the recorded reads. March 2024 decisions and the cited appeal activity are interlocutory. The September 2026 published decision resolves the identified dismissal motions; a final merits judgment, settlement, consumer distribution and subsequent procedural status were outside the verified source set. Individual entitlement, account status, refund or redress amount, and effect of other receivership directives remain unverified. No individual investigation or docket expansion. The Doc. 183 readable pins derive from the receiver-posted rendition; the separately preserved GovInfo PDF and metadata identify the same entered court decision and have independent provenance. The amended complaint alleges fees and marketing conduct. The TRO, preliminary injunction and appellate and dismissal rulings establish their procedural scope only. No final merits determination or consumer relief is inferred.

  • The CFPB and the attorneys general of New York, Colorado, Delaware, Illinois, Minnesota, North Carolina and Wisconsin filed on January 10, 2024. The CFPB summary describes allegations that a consolidation-loan offer led to a debt-relief service pitch and that predetermined fees were debited from consumer escrow accounts before settlements. The March 27, 2024 first amended complaint alleged at least $100 million in fees since January 2016 before consumers’ debts had been altered and alleged that consumers’ outstanding debts continued to accrue interest despite the “0% interest option” pitch.

    cfpb_first-amended-complaint-strat · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb_semi-annual-report_spring-202 · files.consumerfinance.gov stratfs-llc-fka-strategic-financia · www.consumerfinance.gov

  • On January 11, 2024, the district court entered a temporary restraint covering fee requests and receipts in connection with attempted or actual debt resolution for the specified persons and entities, including persons acting in concert with actual notice. Section I addressed fees paid by consumers and consumer-derived fees paid through third parties. It required alteration of at least one debt under a valid agreement executed by the consumer and at least one consumer payment under that agreement.

    cfpb_semi-annual-report_spring-202 · files.consumerfinance.gov stratfs-entered-tro.pdf · zh.ag.ny.gov

  • The March 4, 2024 entered preliminary injunction, Doc. 184 § I, separately restrained its specified covered persons from requesting or receiving debt-relief fees from consumers, or fees from third parties derived from consumer fees, until at least one debt was altered under a valid agreement executed by the consumer and the consumer made at least one payment under that agreement. For individually resolved debts, § I.B required a fee proportional to the individual debt’s share of the total enrolled debt, or a percentage of savings measured against the enrolled amount and what was actually paid to satisfy that debt.

    consumer-financial-protection-bure · regulatoryresolutions.com Preliminary-Injunction-Mar.-4-2024 · regulatoryresolutions.com

  • The March 4 decision granting preliminary relief concluded that the defendants were unlikely to establish the Telemarketing Sales Rule face-to-face exemption. At that stage, the court reasoned that the notaries conducting the meetings were unlikely to qualify as the sellers of the debt-relief services and that the presentations were independently unlikely to qualify as sales presentations. This is the court’s preliminary analysis of the specific record.

    Decision-and-Order-Mar.-4-2024.pdf · regulatoryresolutions.com USCOURTS-nywd-1_24-cv-00040-0 · www.govinfo.gov

  • The CFPB reports that the Second Circuit affirmed issuance of the preliminary injunction and related relief on June 2, 2025, dismissed three appeals concerning application of the TRO and injunction to certain receivership defendants on January 29, 2026, and dismissed a remaining relief-defendant appeal on March 2, 2026. In the subsequent entered September 15, 2026 decision, Doc. 922, the district court overruled specified objections, adopted two reports and recommendations, and denied the listed motions to dismiss. These are interim and pleading-stage dispositions.

    cfpb_semi-annual-report_spring-202 · files.consumerfinance.gov USCOURTS-nywd-1_24-cv-00040-8.pdf · www.govinfo.gov

FTC ACRO Services entered orders, fee conduct and refund implementation

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Entity components total 30226160.44. The first component overlaps with individual judgments and is counted once; the second is entity-only. Individual suspension depends on transfers and can be lifted only on the stated motion and finding. FTC reports first-round refunds realized and second-round checks sent or being sent, with no verified second-round realized total or exact BlueSnap contribution.

  • In its ACRO complaint the FTC alleged that telemarketers sold a credit-card debt-relief program using upfront enrollment charges of several thousand dollars, with one instance up to $18,000, usually charged to a card enrolled in the program. The FTC alleged additional monthly charges of $20–$35, often attributed to credit monitoring, and representations that the upfront fee would be eliminated as part of the debt. These amounts and representations are complaint allegations.

    Complaint-Unsealed.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee entered its August 9, 2023 default final order in FTC v. ACRO Services LLC, ECF 101, against eight entity defendants. The order names ACRO Services, American Consumer Rights Organization, First Call Processing, Music City Ventures, Nashville Tennessee Ventures, Reliance Solutions, Thacker & Associates Int’l, and Consumer Protection Resources. In default the court took the allegations as true against those entities and found that they operated as a common enterprise. Finding 18 determined that the entities violated the TSR by requesting or taking fees before altering at least one debt under the specified agreement executed by the consumer and before the consumer made at least one payment under that agreement.

    Doc101OrdergrantingDefaultJudgment · search.ftc.gov

  • Sections I and II of ECF 101 permanently bar the eight entities from advertising, marketing, promoting, offering or selling debt-relief products or services, including assisting others in that activity, and from telemarketing, directly or through an intermediary. The separately entered April 28, 2023 stipulated orders ECF 82 for Sean Austin, ECF 83 for John Preston Thompson, and ECF 84 for John Steven Huffman impose analogous bans on each. Each individual order records no general admission of the complaint allegations, apart from the stated jurisdictional facts and specific order provisions.

    Doc101OrdergrantingDefaultJudgment · search.ftc.gov Doc-82-Stipulated-Order-for-Perman · www.ftc.gov Doc-83-Stipulated-Order-for-Perman · www.ftc.gov Doc-84-Stipulated-Order-for-Perman · www.ftc.gov

  • ECF 101 §VI(A) enters $17,486,080.85 jointly and severally against the eight entities and overlaps with the three separately entered individual judgments. Section VI(B) enters an additional $12,740,079.59 jointly and severally among the entities only, with no joint and several overlap with another judgment in the matter as of entry. The two components equal $30,226,160.44, the amount the court found supported by competent evidence for injury from November 7, 2019 through entry. The court separately directs liquidation of receivership assets, with stated exceptions and court-approved expenses, and authorizes deposit of receipts into a consumer relief fund.

    Doc101OrdergrantingDefaultJudgment · search.ftc.gov

  • Each of the three individual stipulated orders enters $17,486,080.85, jointly and severally to the extent of qualifying other judgments, directs transfers in partial satisfaction, and suspends the remainder upon completion of required transfers. Upon an FTC motion and requisite court finding of a material financial misstatement or omission, suspension is lifted and the ordered amount becomes due less prior payments plus interest from entry. The individual orders specify their own required transfers and financial representations. These ordered and conditionally suspended amounts describe liability and conditions.

    Doc-82-Stipulated-Order-for-Perman · www.ftc.gov Doc-83-Stipulated-Order-for-Perman · www.ftc.gov Doc-84-Stipulated-Order-for-Perman · www.ftc.gov

  • The January 2025 FTC announcement described more than $5 million being sent by check to 7,687 consumers, with funding also from the separate BlueSnap enforcement case. The FTC’s May 2026 program page reports that the January payments resulted in more than $3.8 million in refunds and announced a second mailing of 5,685 checks totaling more than $6.2 million to consumers who accepted their first payment, with a 90-day check-cashing instruction. The later FTC Protecting Older Consumers report confirms the first-round result and says the second mailing began in May. Each figure retains its publication’s distinction between checks sent or being sent and refunds that resulted.

    2026-older-adults-report-10192026. · search.ftc.gov acro-services-refunds · www.ftc.gov ftc-sends-more-5-million-refunds-c · www.ftc.gov

  • The entered BlueSnap order separately entered $10 million against its corporate defendants and $5 million against its individual defendants, with the latter overlapping jointly and severally with the corporate judgment. The corporate defendants were ordered to pay $5 million within seven days and $5 million within two years of entry. The FTC specifically attributed some funding for the January 2025 ACRO distribution to the BlueSnap case. The exact amount contributed to each ACRO round remains unverified.

    ftc-sends-more-5-million-refunds-c · www.ftc.gov 2223008bluesnapordersigned.pdf · www.ftc.gov

DebtPro 123 debt relief enforcement, fee allegations and relief scope

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

FTC action page labels all four publicly hosted stipulation PDFs proposed. Its banned-provider list links to those same versions. The June 2016 report independently records individual order entry. Judicially signed PDFs and exact changes, if any, remain unverified. The FTC report records the corporate default judgment as entered May 4, 2016. A public mirror locator described document 91 as filed May 2 and identified Texas Allstar. The linked document body did not return. Exact date relationship, defendant qualifier, entered monetary amount and operative injunction remain unverified. The FTC general refund page links to a public case dashboard. The link resolved to the general Tableau profile in the captured response, and reviewed public sources yielded no verified case-specific FTC distribution. Actual payments, collection of judgment, beneficiary scope and individual application remain held. The Oregon instrument orders a limited refund and specifies proof of performance. Actual refund, registration, later penalty waiver or enforcement are outside the verified return. Direct PDF download attempts produced HTTP 403 for the FTC and corporate-order URLs and HTTP 404 for the Oregon URL. Preserved evidence consists of exact numbered public tool returns, with PDF binary absence recorded. The FTC June 2016 report establishes October 14, 2015 stipulated entries and the named corporate default. Published proposed stipulations support proposed terms only. Preserve the report unqualified Allstar name. The signed December 27, 2011 Oregon consent order is distinct and its refund provision concerns the identified consumer only. Actual Oregon compliance and federal payout remain unverified.

  • In the May 2, 2014 DebtPro 123 complaint, the FTC alleged that defendants misrepresented settlement results, legal assistance and credit repair. The FTC also alleged that defendants charged debt-relief fees before a qualifying alteration and consumer payment, misallocated fees for individually resolved debts, and failed one or more dedicated-account conditions involving ownership, interest, withdrawal, or return of remaining funds. The agency separately reported that advertised refunds to unsatisfied customers were rarely paid, according to the complaint.

    ftc-charges-operation-selling-bogu · www.ftc.gov 140603debtprocmpt.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC’s June 2016 litigation report records entry of stipulated permanent injunctions and monetary judgments against Bryan Taylor, Ryan Foland, Stacey Frion and Kara Taylor on October 14, 2015. The agency’s earlier announcement described the proposed debt-relief sales bans for the same four people. Section I of the published proposed Bryan Taylor text reaches secured and unsecured debt-relief products or services, both direct or indirect marketing or sales and assisting others in those activities. Its § II also addresses unsubstantiated claims about product or service benefits, performance or efficacy.

    debt-relief-scammer-settles-ftc-ch · www.ftc.gov 2016_06_quarterly_litigation_repor · www.ftc.gov debt_pro_b._taylor_stip.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC’s published proposed stipulations each specify an equitable monetary judgment of $7,951,211. The published Bryan Taylor text states the judgment against him without the conditional suspension described in the other proposals. The Foland text reduces the judgment by funds turned over and suspends the remainder upon specified asset transfers. The Frion and Kara Wilbur Taylor texts suspend the judgments, subject to reinstatement for material financial misstatements or omissions and the stated prior-payment and interest terms. These are terms of the published proposals, with order entry verified separately by the FTC report.

    debt-relief-scammer-settles-ftc-ch · www.ftc.gov 2016_06_quarterly_litigation_repor · www.ftc.gov debt_pro_b._taylor_stip.pdf · www.ftc.gov debt_pro_k._taylor_stip.pdf · www.ftc.gov debt_pro_r._foland_stip_0.pdf · www.ftc.gov debt_pro_s._frion_stip.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC June 2016 report also records a separate default judgment and final permanent-injunction and monetary order against five named corporate defendants: Allstar Debt Relief LLC, DebtPro 123 LLC, Allstar Processing Corp., BET Companies, Inc. and Redwave Management Group, Inc. The complaint roster separately listed Texas and California Allstar Debt Relief entities. The report’s default entry names Allstar without a state qualifier, so the disposition is limited to the names in the report.

    132-3112-debtpro-123-llc · www.ftc.gov 2016_06_quarterly_litigation_repor · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC-published proposed Bryan Taylor stipulation permits money actually paid to go to an FTC-administered or designated fund for equitable relief, including consumer redress and administration expenses. Where direct redress is impracticable or leaves money remaining, it permits other specified equitable relief, with funds unused for equitable relief sent to the U.S. Treasury. The reviewed FTC sources establish this proposed fund authority and the general refund data route. A DebtPro-specific distribution, amount paid and recipient eligibility remain unverified.

    data-refunds-consumers · www.ftc.gov debt_pro_b._taylor_stip.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • In a separate December 27, 2011 consent order, the Oregon Department of Consumer and Business Services directed DebtPro 123 LLC and specified related parties to cease violating Oregon debt-management law. The Director assessed $50,000 for registration, bond and excess-fee violations and conditioned suspension on compliance, including a refund limited to the single consumer identified by the order, less sums paid to that consumer’s creditors and including amounts held on deposit, with proof to the agency within the 10-day refund provision. The order also required a halt to collection of debt-management interest, fees and charges from Oregon consumers, and registration or an Oregon-unavailability disclaimer within 10 days. It provided for waiver of the suspended penalty after three years of specified compliance and reserved the Director’s right to impose the penalty on violation.

    DM-11-0120.pdf · dfr.oregon.gov

FTC v. Mortgage Relief Advocates, LLC, distinct alternate enforcement authority

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

FTC File 142 3067 and matched public Doc. 73 reproduction concern Mortgage Relief Advocates LLC dba The MRA Group. Exact-name Debt Relief Advocates LLC remains held. The FTC independently attests to entry and rounded monetary relief. Exact monetary and remedy terms are attributed to the matched reproduction; payment, distribution and individual eligibility remain unverified.

  • FTC File 142 3067 identifies FTC v. Mortgage Relief Advocates, LLC, also doing business as The MRA Group, No. 2:14-cv-05434-MWF-AGR in the Central District of California. The FTC names four corporate and two individual defendants, reports its summary judgment motion was granted July 1, 2015 and final judgment entered July 23, 2015, and attributes liability to FTC Act §5 and the Mortgage Assistance Relief Services rule, Regulation O. Publicly reproduced Doc. 73 matches district, case number, parties, posture and judgment date. The FTC ban register marks the order unavailable from that listing. Debt Relief Advocates LLC is outside this case’s verified defendant roster.

    0.pdf · cases.justia.com litigation_report_september_2015.p · search.ftc.gov 160606cfpbrpttila.pdf · search.ftc.gov 142-3067-mortgage-relief-advocates · www.ftc.gov list · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC’s July 2014 complaint alleges unsolicited outbound calls and inbound calls originating from websites. It alleges representations that an upfront payment would likely produce lender modifications or concessions in four to six months, and charges frequently from $1,000 to $3,200 for forensic loan audits or negotiation. The complaint alleges fees collected before services and before consumers executed written agreements incorporating a lender or servicer offer, and pleads the advance-payment violation under the MARS rule and Regulation O.

    140723mortgagereliefcmpt.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • Section I of the reproduced final judgment permanently enjoins the defendants from advertising, marketing, promoting, offering or selling the defined secured or unsecured debt-relief products or services and from assisting others in those activities. The definition covers the specified alteration of loan or debt terms, foreclosure and forbearance help, claimed assistance such as reviewing an application, and products represented as repaying or combining unsecured obligations. The complaint supplies evidence for telemarketing allegations.

    0.pdf · cases.justia.com 140723mortgagereliefcmpt.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • Sections II and III of the reproduced judgment bind defendants and specified persons who receive actual notice, in the defined marketing or sales activities. Section II prohibits material misrepresentations about financial products, including loan or credit terms, savings and claimed ability to affect credit. Section III covers any product or service and includes material facts about refund or cancellation, affiliation, testimonials, total cost and restrictions.

    0.pdf · cases.justia.com

  • Section IV of the reproduced judgment enters $1,834,744.59 against the individual and corporate defendants jointly and severally and orders electronic payment to the FTC within 14 days of entry. Section V permits deposited money to support equitable relief including consumer redress and associated administration, provides for related equitable relief when direct redress is impracticable or money remains, and directs other money to Treasury. The FTC’s reporting independently confirms rounded $1.8 million in ordered monetary relief.

    0.pdf · cases.justia.com 160606cfpbrpttila.pdf · search.ftc.gov

Mission Hills Federal student-debt relief judgment and refund rounds

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Doc. 184 is the FTC-published July 17 signed original. The FTC appellate brief authenticates the July 24 amendment’s existence. The mirrored amended-order body was returned only under a rewritten source identity and its PDF download failed, so the exact amended text and changes are not adopted here. The appellate removal instruction is authenticated; the district court’s post-remand amended instrument was not retrieved. The judgment, amounts the agency sent, realized refunds it later reported, and the announcement of the second round are separate metrics. Exact post-announcement second-round cashing or totals, closure, actual payment to a specific recipient and individual loan balances or forgiveness are not established. No inference of liability or payout for a separately named payment processor, other litigation or other student-loan relief programs. The second-round criterion is limited to the named FTC distribution and does not establish an open claims process. The original Ninth Circuit PDF was saved. FTC binary and mirrored amendment PDF attempts returned HTTP 403. Exact numbered public returns and the native retrieval and download receipts preserve the evidence limits. The signed July 17 original and June 2022 appellate memorandum establish their respective terms. The FTC brief identifies the July 24 amendment, whose exact body remains held, as does any post-remand implementation. Preserve the distinction between checks sent, first-round refunds realized, and the announced second-round cohort and check value.

  • In the federal FTC case against the Mission Hills Federal operation, the July 17, 2020 judgment defined the corporate defendants as Elegant Solutions (Federal Direct Group), Trend Capital (Mission Hills Federal), Dark Island Industries (Federal Direct Group and Cosmopolitan Funding), Heritage Asset Management (National Secure Processing) and Tribune Management (The Student Loan Group), with the stated related entities. It also defined four individual defendants: Mazen Radwan, Rima Radwan, Labiba Velazquez, and Dean Robbins. The Ninth Circuit upheld the common-enterprise finding and the four individuals’ liability for injunctive and monetary relief.

    20-55766.pdf · cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov 192-3105-elegant-solutions-inc-mis · www.ftc.gov 184._final_judgment__0.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The Ninth Circuit’s June 9, 2022 memorandum upheld summary judgment on all three FTC counts. The court identified material misrepresentations about repayment-plan enrollment, payments toward loans and assumption of loan servicing. It also upheld the advance-fee violation under 16 CFR §310.4(a)(5) and recorded that the trust account failed the TSR’s escrow-account requirements. The customers’ written agreements did not cure the telemarketing misrepresentations in this case.

    20-55766.pdf · cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov

  • Sections I and II of the July 17 signed judgment permanently enjoin the defendants from marketing or selling, or helping others market or sell, secured or unsecured debt-relief products and services, and from participating or assisting in telemarketing directly or through an intermediary. The order also prohibits covered misrepresentations about financial products or services, material refund and cancellation terms and affiliation, and prohibits certain unsubstantiated claims. The Ninth Circuit upheld the grant of permanent injunctive relief, with its separate instruction on unused funds.

    20-55766.pdf · cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov 184._final_judgment__0.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • Section VI.A of the original signed judgment enters $27,584,969 in equitable monetary relief against the defendants jointly and severally. Section VI.C directs specified holders to deliver receivership entity assets to the receiver, while VI.D directs specified individual assets to the FTC or its agent in partial satisfaction. The FTC’s appellate brief reports a July 24, 2020 amended final judgment after the July 17 original. The original judgment amount is a liability measure and does not establish the amount collected or paid to consumers.

    184._final_judgment__0.pdf · www.ftc.gov ftc_v._elegant_solutions_ftc_brief · www.ftc.gov

  • The Ninth Circuit upheld the award based on consumer loss under FTC Act §19 for the TSR violations, while recognizing that AMG barred monetary relief under §13(b). Its June 9, 2022 memorandum affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded with instructions to remove the clause sending leftover funds to the Treasury as disgorgement. The July 17 order had authorized money paid to fund consumer redress and related administrative costs. The original Treasury sentence is historical in light of the appellate instruction.

    20-55766.pdf · cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov 184._final_judgment__0.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC’s 2024 annual report lists a first distribution on March 13, 2024 with $4,150,896.78 sent, 27,584 eligible consumers, and 18,251 cashing a payment to date in that report (66.2%). The FTC’s February 2026 case notice separately reports that the first round resulted in more than $3.4 million in refunds and announces a second round of 10,138 checks totaling more than $627,000. The stated second-round cohort cashed the first check and paid defendants more than $430. The notice gives recipients 90 days to cash the second check. These are separate sent and returned metrics and a dated second-round announcement.

    mission-hills-federal-refunds · www.ftc.gov ftc-refunds-consumers-2024.pdf · www.ftc.gov

Texas OCCC Elite Financial Services Inc. debt management reporting enforcement

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Both orders match master file 1400000119 and registration 211083. Connecticut Elite Financial Solutions is distinct. Preserve order-date hearing wording and statutory service trigger separately. Filing duties and government penalty establish no consumer fee violation, redress, actual service or subsequent adjudication.

  • Texas OCCC’s L22-00049 and L23-00055 instruments both name Elite Financial Services Inc. d/b/a Massachusetts Elite Financial Services, Inc. and identify the Beverly, Massachusetts respondent as a Chapter 394 debt management services provider with master file 1400000119, one location and registration 211083. Connecticut’s similarly named Elite Financial Solutions Inc. a/k/a E. F. Solutions Inc. is identified in its own government bulletin as a Florida respondent. Its action is outside the Texas identity and order scope.

    l23-00055_finalorder.pdf · occc.texas.gov l22-00049_finalorder.pdf · occc.texas.gov Bulletin-2560--March-15-2013 · portal.ct.gov

  • In L22-00049, signed April 6, 2022, the Commissioner recites failure to file the 2021 annual report and required documents by January 31, 2022 and states reasonable cause to believe Chapter 394 was violated. The historical list includes blank agreements and counseling information, bond or insurance evidence, owners and changes, and counselor staffing and accreditation information. The order requires the respondent to comply and cease reporting violations, file the missing materials within 30 days of the order if not already filed, and submit complete accurate future reports and documents timely. It states that violations may attract up to $1,000 per day.

    l22-00049_finalorder.pdf · occc.texas.gov

  • In L23-00055, signed May 23, 2023, the Commissioner states that the 2022 annual report and required documents were not filed by the extended February 15, 2023 deadline, violating Chapter 394 and the earlier order. The specified documents are blank agreements and credit counseling materials and bond or insurance evidence. The order imposes a $500 administrative penalty for the one location, payable within 30 days of the order date, and requires filing the missing 2022 report and documents within that period if not already filed.

    l23-00055_finalorder.pdf · occc.texas.gov l23-00055_finalorder.pdf · occc.texas.gov

  • Both instruments provide a written hearing request within 30 days after the date of the order and say absent a timely request the order is final and enforceable. Their certificates recite sending each instrument on its respective signature date. Section 14.208(b) states 30 days after service of the order and refers to Texas Government Code Chapter 2001; subsection (c) describes finality absent a timely request and authorizes an administrative penalty up to $1,000 per day after notice for violating a cease-and-desist order. An actual service date, hearing or adjudication is outside the saved proof.

    l23-00055_finalorder.pdf · occc.texas.gov l22-00049_finalorder.pdf · occc.texas.gov FI.14.htm · tcss.legis.texas.gov

  • Texas Finance Code §394.205 requires a report with registration renewal including number of plans initiated and total and average fees charged, including voluntary contributions, along with the stated verification and blank-document filings. Section 394.206 addresses bond or insurance filings at initial or renewal application. These reporting requirements provide context for the Texas orders. The agency’s currently posted industry guidance gives February 1 and ALECS for annual reports, while the signed orders record their own dated deadlines. The orders establish filing violations, filing relief and the government penalty.

    debt-management-settlement-provide · occc.texas.gov l23-00055_finalorder.pdf · occc.texas.gov l22-00049_finalorder.pdf · occc.texas.gov FI.394.htm · tcss.legis.texas.gov

Premier Student Loan Center enforcement orders and closed consumer redress

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The district court’s Doc. 311 filing header and CFPB enforcement chronology date the CAC order July 14, 2021. The separate compensation page’s narrative says July 15. The operative court date is used and both sources are retained. The complaint and docket description concern the named CFPB and states matter, distinct from FTC Mission Hills Federal E163S. Other related defendants and relief-defendant terms are only bounded by the cited chronology and not individually analyzed. Judgment figures, the estate claim, defendant collections, the initial compensation announcement, amounts mailed and amounts cashed are separate measures. Fiscal-year check totals do not independently establish unique recipients or an exact dollar amount actually cashed. No household eligibility, current loan balance, forgiveness, personal award or private account fact was investigated. Doc. 311 filing header and enforcement chronology control July 14, 2021; compensation narrative says July 15. Distinguish judgments, overlapping liability, estate claim, collections, mailed checks, and rounded claimed or cashed percentages. The two FY2024 streams closed in Q3, with no exact realized cash total or unique recipient count inferred. S4 duplicate native return resolved using sealed exact pin digest.

Student Debt Doctor FTC injunctions, judgment and refund rounds

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Distinct FTC Student Debt Doctor matter and defendants. The settlement release also covers American Student Loan Consolidators, whose amounts are excluded. The FTC publication date of December 7, 2018 is distinct from the final court entry on November 30. Original PDF download attempts returned HTTP 403. Exact numbered court and FTC report returns and byte-download receipts are preserved. The English refund page returned an error, and the FTC’s official Spanish notice supplies the cohort and 90-day window. The reports give amounts sent, prior amounts returned and number of consumers who cashed one or more payments. Exact second-round amount realized, ultimate closure, total judgment collected or suspension reinstatement are outside the verified evidence. No private award, loan eligibility, forgiveness, individual payment or account fact was investigated. Entered joint judgment and conditional suspension are distinct from amounts mailed and returned. Preserve report cutoffs, recipients who cashed at least one payment, and the Spanish FTC notice cohort requiring first payment acceptance and more than 155 dollars paid. No exact second-round realized payout is inferred.

  • The Southern District of Florida FTC matter named Student Debt Doctor LLC and Gary Brent White Jr. individually and as an officer. The FTC said the settlement resolved allegations that the operation collected at least $7 million illegally from student-loan borrowers. The public refund notice also describes allegations of large upfront fees and false promises of immediate, permanent relief and forgiveness. The November 30, 2018 stipulated order records that the defendants neither admitted nor denied the allegations except as specified and admitted facts needed for jurisdiction for purposes of this action.

    reembolsos-de-student-debt-doctor · www.ftc.gov ftc-settlements-will-ban-student-l · www.ftc.gov student_debt_doctor_final_order_fo · www.ftc.gov

  • The 2017 stipulated preliminary injunction, signed October 13 and entered October 16, conditionally barred debt-relief fees until alteration of at least one debt under a valid customer-executed agreement and at least one customer payment under it. For individually resolved debts it required a fee proportional to the enrolled debt share or the same percentage of savings for each debt. It provided for an asset freeze and expired on entry of final judgment. The later final order permanently bans the two named defendants from marketing, selling or assisting with secured or unsecured debt-relief products or services.

    student_debt_doctor_final_order_fo · www.ftc.gov student_debt_doctor_stipulated_pre · www.ftc.gov

  • The final order enters $13,224,856.15 against the two defendants jointly and severally. In partial satisfaction it directs turnover of covered company, receivership and White funds and separately requires White to transfer specified property to the receiver. The remainder is suspended after the specified payments and transfers. The order permits lifting the suspension as to a defendant on FTC motion and a court finding of material asset nondisclosure or another qualifying material financial misstatement or omission. The remaining judgment then becomes immediately due from that defendant, with payment credits and interest from entry. The FTC described the required payment as approximately $2.2 million and the order provides for equitable relief including consumer redress.

    ftc-settlements-will-ban-student-l · www.ftc.gov student_debt_doctor_final_order_fo · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC’s 2022 annual report records $2,087,712.43 mailed in June 2022, with 22,817 eligible consumers and 14,047 consumers who had cashed a payment at that report’s cutoff (61%). Its 2024 annual report separately records $1,457,820 returned in prior distributions and $581,220 sent to 14,067 consumers on July 16, 2024, with 15,137 consumers recorded as having cashed at least one payment. The sent and returned amounts and the reports’ recipient counts are different measures.

    2022_FTC_REFUNDS_TO_CONSUMERS.pdf · www.ftc.gov ftc-refunds-consumers-2024.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC’s official Spanish-language notice describes the second-round cohort as people who accepted their first payment and paid Student Debt Doctor more than $155. The notice tells recipients to cash checks within 90 days. The eligibility statement is limited to the announced second distribution.

    reembolsos-de-student-debt-doctor · www.ftc.gov

Student Debt Relief Group FTC injunctions and closed refund program

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

FTC posting date June 11, 2018 is distinct from June 8 court filing and signature. Case 2:17-cv-06855-ODW-PLA is separate from Student Debt Doctor, Mission Hills and Premier. Actual total judgment collection and suspension reinstatement remain unverified. The expected asset turnover, judgment, refund fund and final returned amount measure different things. Individual eligibility, later private payment, effects on loan balance or forgiveness, and any reopening remain outside the verified public record. Exact binary results are documented in the download receipt. Numbered original publisher returns remain intact. Separate entered joint liability, conditional suspension, turnover expectation, amounts sent and funds returned. The 2023 closure components sum to 1784761 dollars and cashing participation rounds to 85.7 percent. No account result is established.

  • The FTC’s Student Debt Relief Group case named M&T Financial Group and American Counseling Center Corp. and their officer Salar Tahour. The FTC alleged the entities used multiple trade names, falsely implied Department of Education affiliation, charged up to $1,000 in advance for help enrolling in free government programs and represented that monthly service charges would be credited toward student loans. The FTC attributed at least $7.3 million in collections to the alleged conduct at the complaint stage. The final stipulation records that defendants neither admitted nor denied the allegations except as specified and admitted jurisdictional facts for this action.

    172-3065-x170051-mt-financial-grou · www.ftc.gov student-loan-debt-relief-scam-oper · www.ftc.gov mt_financial_final_order.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The October 10, 2017 preliminary injunction conditioned debt-relief fees on alteration of at least one debt under a valid consumer-executed agreement and at least one consumer payment under it, with proportionate or consistent savings-percentage fees for individually altered debts. A separate paragraph also restrained collection, attempted collection or assignment of rights to collect payment for the defendants’ debt-relief products or services. The final order permanently prohibits the defendants from selling, marketing or assisting with secured or unsecured debt relief and separately bars specified deceptive telemarketing, Do Not Call and TSR practices.

    mt_financial_final_order.pdf · www.ftc.gov sdrg_stipulated_pi.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The entered June 8, 2018 order imposes $11,694,347.49 jointly and severally on Tahour and the corporate defendants. It separately orders Tahour to pay $379,596.62 to the FTC within seven days of entry and cooperate with the receiver’s sale of specified property, including providing power of attorney within 14 days. The remainder is suspended upon specified transfers and completion of the obligations. If the FTC moves and the court finds a material financial omission or misstatement as specified, suspension is lifted as to that defendant and the judgment becomes due with credits for prior payments and interest from entry. The FTC described anticipated asset turnover of more than $2.3 million. The order permits funds actually paid to support redress and administration.

    student-loan-debt-relief-scam-oper · www.ftc.gov mt_financial_final_order.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC’s February 10, 2021 notice announced more than $1.7 million sent through 867 checks and 18,559 PayPal payments, with 90 days to deposit or cash checks and 30 days to accept PayPal payments. The 2022 annual report separately records 2,367 additional payments totaling $167,228 sent in March 2022, $1,500,000 returned in earlier distributions and 16,626 consumers who had cashed at least one payment. The amounts sent and returned are separate measures.

    172-3065-x170051-mt-financial-grou · www.ftc.gov ftc-sends-more-17-million-refunds- · www.ftc.gov 2022_FTC_REFUNDS_TO_CONSUMERS.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC’s 2023 annual report lists the program as closed in 2023. Its row records a $1,784,761 total fund, $1,660,262 returned to consumers, $117,597 in administration, $6,902 leftover, and $0 for consumer education. It records 19,426 consumers sent a payment and 16,645 who cashed at least one payment, or 85.7%. These are the agency’s aggregate closure measures.

    ftc-refunds-to-consumers-2023.pdf · www.ftc.gov

Student Loan Pro CFPB advance fees, consent order and penalty collection

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

No official CFPB source reviewed established a Student Loan Pro consumer allocation or payments. The Period 25 table supports only that period. The entered order’s net advance-fee harm figure does not itself establish a redress award or actual loan relief. The October 2026 report is the latest verified agency status. Later motion outcomes, compliance with the dissolution terms, actual benefit or eligibility and private account facts are held. The separate Washington Attorney General 2017 resolution was identified, but the official page returned HTTP 403 for numbered retrieval. Its search-only reference was not adopted as proof of the state relief or payments. The official FNZA dismissal PDF rendered clearly at page 2 despite an unusable text extraction. The untouched PDF, the page image and the labeled bounded transcription are separately preserved. S4 span is verified in adjacent exact native checks. Separate enforceable Doc. 185 terms, 3437251.40 dollars in stated harm, and 2000 dollars in actually collected penalty. No case-specific consumer disbursement verified. Pending motions are attributed to dated CFPB reporting.

  • In March 2021, the CFPB sued Judith Noh doing business as Student Loan Pro, Noh individually and Syed Faisal Gilani, and named FNZA Marketing as relief defendant. The CFPB alleged fees as high as $795 initially, charged before debt alteration and payment, for help accessing free federal loan programs. The December 9, 2024 stipulated order records that the company requested or received fees before both qualifying debt alteration and consumer payment from September 2015 through November 6, 2019, and states $3,437,251.40 in harm after chargebacks and company refunds. It defines an Affected Consumer as someone who paid Student Loan Pro a fee from September 1, 2015 to November 6, 2019. The settlement was entered without adjudication and the Noh defendants neither admit nor deny the allegations except as specified.

    cfpb_student-loan-pro-noh-gilani-f · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb-takes-action-against-operator · www.consumerfinance.gov student-loan-pro-judith-noh-syed-f · www.consumerfinance.gov

  • The entered order permanently restrains Noh and Student Loan Pro from directly or indirectly offering, providing or assisting with consumer financial products or services, with related employment and ownership restrictions. It also restrains specified persons from collection or transfer of collection rights from affected consumers, bars Noh defendants’ business involvement with Gilani, and limits use of covered customer information, subject to the stated lawful-disclosure exception. The order directs Noh to file abandonment of the fictitious name and submit FNZA cancellation or dissolution within 30 days, take required steps to complete FNZA cancellation or dissolution within 180 days, and furnish proof of compliance within 14 days of completing each action.

    cfpb_student-loan-pro-noh-gilani-f · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The Noh defendants’ entered order jointly imposes a $2,000 civil money penalty based on inability to pay, payable within 10 days of the effective date, for deposit to the Civil Penalty Fund. The CFPB FY2025 annual report records actual collection of $2,000 on January 7, 2025. That report’s May 30, 2025 Period 25 allocation table names other matters and lists no Student Loan Pro allocation. The order’s consumer harm figure and the actual collected civil penalty are separate measures. No case-specific CFPB consumer disbursement was verified.

    cfpb_fy2025-cpf-bar-annual-report_ · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb_student-loan-pro-noh-gilani-f · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • In a separate December 18, 2024 entered order, Doc. 187, the court dismissed relief defendant FNZA Marketing with prejudice and directed each party to bear its own costs and attorney fees in connection with the plaintiff’s claims. The October 2026 CFPB report states that the agency filed renewed motions after the stay on September 16, 2025 to amend Noh’s stipulation and order and September 19, 2025 for summary judgment as to Gilani. The report described both motions and the case as pending.

    cfpb_spring-2026-semi-annual-repor · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb_student-loan-pro-noh-gilani-f · files.consumerfinance.gov student-loan-pro-judith-noh-syed-f · www.consumerfinance.gov

Premier Student Loan Center FY2025 redress reissues and collections

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

E163W-C005 remains the FY2024 distribution baseline and E163W-C002 remains the earlier CAC judgment and October 18, 2023 collection baseline. E164N records only additional FY2025 events. E164I-C003 concerns the separate Student Loan Pro case and an unrelated row of the same report. The FY2025 report gives no separate amount by Wen collection date, no recipient count or exact reissue dates, no tracing from the March CAC collection to the reissued payments, and no all-time total. Actual personal receipt, eligibility, current claim access and individual loan effects remain held. FY2025 report separately identifies direct reissues of 20809 dollars, CAC redress collection of 88712 dollars, and Wen civil penalties of 2018085 dollars across three dates. No per-date allocation or funding linkage is established. Reissues follow FY2024 administrator closure and establish no account-specific result.

  • The CFPB’s FY2025 Bureau-Administered Redress report states that it distributed $20,809 directly to consumers in the Premier Student Loan Center matter after the third-party administrator’s FY2024 distribution concluded and unclaimed funds returned to the CFPB. The report identifies the direct recipients as victims who requested reissued payments. It reports the reissues separately from the cases that began Bureau-Administered Redress distributions in FY2025.

    cfpb_fy2025-cpf-bar-annual-report_ · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • Table 10 in the same report separately records $88,712 in Bureau-Administered Redress collected on March 27, 2025 from Consumer Advocacy Center Inc., doing business as Premier Student Loan Center, in the Premier matter. The table describes a collection from CAC, whose redress judgment was treated as an allowed general unsecured bankruptcy-estate claim in the entered order covered by E163W. The report does not link this collection to the $20,809 in direct reissues.

    cfpb_fy2025-cpf-bar-annual-report_ · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • Table 3 separately records $2,018,085 in FY2025 civil penalties collected from defendant Kaine Wen in the Premier matter across three listed dates: November 22, 2024, January 10, 2025 and February 4, 2025. It gives one total for the three dates. This is a Civil Penalty Fund collection entry, distinct from CAC redress collections and the CFPB’s direct payments to consumers.

    cfpb_fy2025-cpf-bar-annual-report_ · files.consumerfinance.gov

Performance SLC and Performance Settlement CFPB judgment and consumer redress

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Verified money categories are conditional judgments, ordered penalties, the reported Civil Penalty Fund allocation, and FY2024 amounts and checks mailed. Defendant payment dates, any tax-benefit source for specific amounts and the receipt or cashing of checks remain unverified. The February 15, 2024 compensation page has that same last-modified date. Current intake, later reissues, closure or changes to the court order remain unverified. A targeted search of the FY2025 CPF and Bureau-administered redress annual report returned no matching Performance SLC text. That is a search result with limited coverage. The specified order and compensation cohorts govern this action. Individual eligibility, identity, amounts, debt cancellation, student loan discharge and account status remain outside the public-source record. Keep April 29 entered judgments, conditional suspension and civil penalties distinct from CPF allocations and checks mailed. The two funds reconcile to 10936618 dollars and 8571 checks. The two allocation cohorts have separate dates and predicates. Amounts actually cashed and individual outcomes remain unverified.

  • The CFPB distinguished Performance SLC’s federal student-loan debt-relief business from Performance Settlement’s general debt-settlement services. Its November 2020 action alleged approximately $9.2 million in unlawful upfront student-loan debt-relief fees and inadequate trust-account disclosures. The July 2021 amendment added Performance Settlement’s use of a settlement preauthorization form. The court entered the stipulated judgment on April 29, 2022. The judgment contains stipulated findings on the two fee gates, trust-account disclosures, preauthorizations and OneLoanPlace.com referrals, with the stated qualification that defendants generally neither admitted nor denied the complaint allegations and admitted jurisdictional facts.

    cfpb_performance-slc_stipulated-fi · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb-to-distribute-more-than-10-9- · www.consumerfinance.gov performance-slc-llc-performance-se · www.consumerfinance.gov

  • The entered order permanently barred Performance SLC from covered debt-relief activity and imposed the corresponding ban on Daniel Crenshaw for five years from entry. Performance Settlement was enjoined from specified loan-related misrepresentations and referrals, and from using blanket settlement preauthorizations. The order required a customer signature on the specific settlement or offer, or written authorization obtained after the customer reviewed the specific agreement. The order separately prohibited Crenshaw’s covered advance-fee activity before an executed agreement altered at least one debt and the consumer made a payment under it, and enjoined collection and transfers of covered Performance SLC fee payments.

    cfpb_performance-slc_stipulated-fi · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The April 29, 2022 entered order imposed joint and several consumer redress judgments of $10,448,467.90 against Performance SLC and Crenshaw and $704,350.30 against Performance Settlement and Crenshaw. Full payment was subject to specified suspension conditions, including contingent reimbursement and tax-benefit transfers. A material omission or misrepresentation could terminate suspension for the affected defendant upon Bureau motion and court determination. Separate civil money penalties of $30,000 for Crenshaw and $1 for each company were due within 15 days of entry and designated for the CFPB Civil Penalty Fund.

    cfpb_performance-slc_stipulated-fi · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The CFPB reported a period 20 Civil Penalty Fund allocation of $10,950,818.20. Its FY2023 Q4 CFO report identifies $10,448,467.90 for consumers who from January 1, 2016 through April 29, 2022 paid some or all of Performance SLC’s fee into a dedicated trust account or entered a credit plan to finance the fee, and $502,350.30 for consumers who were referred by OneLoanPlace.com from August 27, 2018 through April 29, 2022 and paid a Performance Settlement fee.

    cfpb_cfo-update_report_fy-2023_q4. · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb_performance-slc_stipulated-fi · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • On February 15, 2024 the CFPB announced a combined $10,936,618 check distribution for 8,571 consumers through Rust Consulting. Its FY2024 report recorded $10,734,630 distributed and 8,267 checks mailed from the Civil Penalty Fund, plus $201,988 distributed and 304 checks mailed from Bureau-administered redress. Both reported distributions began in FY2024 Q2. The compensation page was last modified February 15, 2024 and lists that date as the start of distribution.

    cfpb_financial-report-fy-2024.pdf · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb-to-distribute-more-than-10-9- · www.consumerfinance.gov performanceslc · www.consumerfinance.gov

Student Aid Institute and Steven Lamont CFPB consent order and closed consumer distribution

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The consent order’s permanent-restraint wording and §79 order-termination clause are both included. No finding about later modification, a qualifying extension, current enforceability or the status of any respondent. The approximately $3.6 million harm estimate, $50,000 actual civil penalty collection, exact $3,508,900.27 fund allocation, whole-dollar report distributions, check counts and cashed percentage describe separate measurements. The change in checks mailed across reports is recorded as reported. No reason for the change or cashing amount is inferred. The 2023 Gebase distribution is cited solely to delineate the separate program. Individual check receipt, account outcomes, loan forgiveness, specific eligibility and actual credit report changes remain outside this evidence. Preserve permanent conduct restraint language and conditional five-year order termination clock separately. No actual termination date is established. The April 1 penalty collection and victim-class allocation are distinct. Preserve interim 3265 and final 3269 check counts, 85 percent of funds cashed and closure. The Gebase mailing concerns a separate action.

  • The CFPB issued its final administrative consent order on March 30, 2016 against Student Aid Institute and its CEO Steven Lamont, file 2016-CFPB-0008. The Bureau found that customers typically paid $395 or $495 upfront plus $39 per month and that SAI debited accounts or charged cards immediately after electronic signature, before asking for federal repayment enrollment documents. It estimated approximately $3.6 million in net fee harm for about 4,300 consumers. The Bureau also found misrepresentations about federal program fees, savings, eligibility and Department of Education affiliation, and a failure by SAI to provide required privacy notices. Respondents consented without admitting or denying wrongdoing.

    201603_cfpb_consent-order-student- · files.consumerfinance.gov 201603_cfpb_stipulation-and-consen · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The order immediately rescinded existing SAI agreements, including service agreements and powers of attorney, and stopped assessment of fees under them. It required permanent cessation of operations within 45 days, 30-day removal steps for covered negative information previously supplied or requested by respondents, and specific paperwork and reminder duties for federal plan recertification or renewal deadlines within the first 30 days. The order permanently restrained both respondents from covered debt-relief activities and separately included a five-year order-termination clause measured from entry or the latest qualifying CFPB enforcement action, subject to its stated exceptions.

    201603_cfpb_consent-order-student- · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The order required the two respondents to pay a $50,000 civil money penalty to the CFPB within 10 days for deposit into its Civil Penalty Fund. The CFPB’s FY2016 financial report records a $50,000 collection for the named case on April 1, 2016.

    201603_cfpb_consent-order-student- · files.consumerfinance.gov 112016_cfpb_Final_Financial_Report · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The CFPB’s FY2016 financial report records a May 27, 2016 period 7 Civil Penalty Fund allocation of $3,508,900.27 for the Student Aid Institute and Steven Lamont victim class. The FY2017 report shows $3,508,900 distributed and 3,265 checks mailed for the distribution begun in FY2017 Q2. The FY2019 closure report shows $3,508,900 distributed, 3,269 checks mailed, and 85% of distributed funds cashed, with completion in FY2019 Q2. The agency’s compensation page, last modified June 29, 2026, dates distribution February 2017 to February 2019, names Rust Consulting, and says payment and reissue requests are closed.

    112016_cfpb_Final_Financial_Report · files.consumerfinance.gov bcfp_annual-financial-report_fy-20 · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb_financial-report_fy17.pdf · files.consumerfinance.gov student-aid-institute · www.consumerfinance.gov

  • The November 13, 2023 CFPB announcement of $240,994 for 845 former SAI consumers was attributed to the separate action against Processingstudentloans operator Frank Ronald Gebase Jr., involving unauthorized fees alleged against that operation. It reported a separate planned Civil Penalty Fund mailing.

    cfpb-to-distribute-more-than-24000 · www.consumerfinance.gov

Frank Ronald Gebase Jr. CFPB judgment, collected penalty and closed consumer distribution

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The 2022 Gebase matter concerns alleged debits by Processingstudentloans. Its affected consumer and funding scope is separate from the 2016 administrative Student Aid Institute order and that case’s distribution reviewed in E164V. The collections table supplies the aggregate penalty and two collection dates. It supplies no actual per-date amount. The order’s scheduled amounts are preserved separately. The compensation page’s important-date range and FY2025 report’s distribution-conclusion quarter describe separately labeled reporting. The underlying closing or reissue process, individual check receipt, individual qualification and account effects remain unverified. Keep Doc. 5, penalty collection, allocation and consumer distributions distinct from the earlier SAI order. Preserve the one-dollar allocation difference, claimed percentage, fiscal quarter closure and separate dated compensation-page dates.

College Education Services, Vargas and Liz CFPB judgment and closed consumer distribution

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The amounts attributed to the complaint are allegations. The entered stipulation’s non-admission and adjudication limits remain applicable. Actual collection is verified only for the federal $25,000 penalty. Later Florida collections, individual payor shares, order amendments and compliance history remain unverified. The consumer compensation page dates and FY2020 financial report conclusion quarter are preserved under their source labels. The administrative timing difference and reasons the allocation exceeded distributed amounts are unverified. Refund eligibility, individual check receipt or cashing, loan forgiveness and credit outcomes remain outside the evidence. Doc. 7 entry, federal penalty actually collected, and deferred Florida amounts retain distinct scope. Civil Penalty Fund allocation differs from distributed amount and cashing percentage. Preserve fiscal closure and compensation-page dates separately; no individual payout is inferred.

  • The CFPB and Florida Attorney General sued College Education Services LLC, Marcia Elena Vargas and Frank Liz on December 11, 2014. The complaint alleged fees of $195 to $2,500, averaging about $500, with all or a substantial portion due before the company performed services, alongside guaranteed relief representations. The Middle District of Florida entered stipulated Doc. 7 on January 15, 2015 without adjudication of disputed facts or law. The defendants generally neither admitted nor denied the allegations and admitted jurisdictional facts. For the order, CES includes predecessor College Defaulted Student Loan LLC and successors and assigns.

    201412_cfpb_complaint_the-college- · files.consumerfinance.gov 201510_cfpb_consent-order_the-coll · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The order defines affected consumers as those who paid a covered advance fee to CES. Its advance-fee definition refers to an executed agreement altering at least one debt, at least one payment by the consumer under the agreement, and proportional or savings-based fees when debts are settled separately. The order permanently restrains all three defendants from offering or assisting in covered debt-relief services or specified financial or work ties to such services. It also restricts covered misrepresentations about consumer financial products and services and disclosure, use or benefit from CES consumer data, with stated disclosure exceptions.

    201510_cfpb_consent-order_the-coll · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The order imposed a joint and several $25,000 CFPB civil money penalty due within 14 days for deposit in the Civil Penalty Fund. The FY2015 CFPB report records $25,000 collected on January 30, 2015. The order separately imposed joint and several Florida investigative and attorney fees of $15,000 and a $10,000 Florida civil penalty. It deferred collection subject to the financial disclosures and a specified court finding on motion by the Florida Attorney General.

    201510_cfpb_consent-order_the-coll · files.consumerfinance.gov 201511_cfpb_report_fiscal-year-201 · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The CFPB allocated $3,459,336 from the Civil Penalty Fund for the College Education Services class on May 29, 2015. The FY2020 financial report shows $2,420,068 distributed, 2,717 checks mailed and 80% of distributed funds cashed, with distribution conclusion in FY2020 Q1. The consumer compensation page lists February 14, 2018 to July 1, 2019 as its distribution dates, names Epiq Systems, and says the matter is closed and payment and check reissue requests are no longer honored on its June 29, 2026 version.

    201511_cfpb_report_fiscal-year-201 · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb_annual-financial-report_fy-20 · files.consumerfinance.gov college-education-services · www.consumerfinance.gov

IrvineWebWorks Student Loan Processing.US entered judgments and closed consumer distribution

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The detailed February 5 ruling explicitly calls the disposition on count III partial and the March 15 final order describes counts III and V as partial. The February conclusion uses broader wording for I, III and V. Both exact passages are preserved. Further additional penalties from the shutdown reserve, judgment reinstatement, later modification, separate state recovery and individual application remain unverified. The public reports state counts by funding source and describe one victim class. A deduplicated recipient total, individual check receipt, original student-loan obligations or credit-report results remain outside the evidence. The named operator and relief are distinct from Student Aid Institute and the separate Gebase case. The summary judgment citation crosses two native returns and is verified in adjacent pieces. Distinguish entered liability, conditional suspension, actual March 23 collections and separate funding streams for one victim class. Preserve allocation versus distribution, cashing percentage and closure without inferring individual payments.

  • On December 11, 2014 the CFPB sued IrvineWebWorks, Inc., doing business as Student Loan Processing.US, and James Krause. The February 5, 2016 court ruling awarded the Bureau summary judgment on its Telemarketing Sales Rule advance-fee count. The court found that the defendants represented they offered debt-relief services and collected fees before submitting enrollment documents to the Department of Education. The court denied the affiliation counts II and IV at summary judgment and adjudicated cost-disclosure issues under counts III and V. The final stipulation records the relief on III and V as partial and resolves remaining issues without adjudication, subject to its stated admissions and non-admission language.

    201603_cfpb_court-ruling-student-l · files.consumerfinance.gov 75_-_Stipulated_Final_Judgment_and · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The March 15, 2016 entered judgment immediately rescinded covered student-loan service agreements, including powers of attorney, and stopped charges under them. It required the defendants to cease operations within 45 days, take steps within 30 days to remove specified derogatory information supplied or requested by them, complete specified federal plan renewal and reminder work for deadlines within 30 days, and mail notice to affected consumers within 30 days. It permanently barred covered debt-relief and student-loan service activities, subject to the identified wind-down and administrative duties.

    75_-_Stipulated_Final_Judgment_and · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The order imposed $8,249,548.48 in equitable monetary relief and damages for affected consumers, with full payment suspended subject to specified conditions including a $326,000 payment due within 10 days and a separate $1 civil penalty due within 10 days. It required a $129,000 shutdown and existing-rent reserve, with unused or unreasonably spent amounts payable as additional penalties following Bureau review. The FY2016 report records actual collections of $326,000 in Bureau-administered redress and a separate $1 civil money penalty, both on March 23, 2016.

    112016_cfpb_Final_Financial_Report · files.consumerfinance.gov 75_-_Stipulated_Final_Judgment_and · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The CFPB’s FY2017 report shows $326,000 in Bureau-administered redress distributed through 86 checks in a distribution that began in FY2017 Q1. The CFPB separately allocated $7,923,548.48 from the Civil Penalty Fund on May 27, 2016 and reported $7,923,524 distributed through 4,800 checks, 96% of distributed funds cashed and completion in FY2019 Q1. The FY2017 report identifies one victim class compensated from both funding sources.

    112016_cfpb_Final_Financial_Report · files.consumerfinance.gov bcfp_annual-financial-report_fy-20 · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb_financial-report_fy17.pdf · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The CFPB’s initial distribution notice describes consumers who paid enrollment or other fees under agreements entered by March 15, 2016 and had yet to receive a full refund. Its compensation page names Rust Consulting, dates distribution December 9, 2016 through November 13, 2018, and says payment and reissue requests are closed on its June 29, 2026 page version.

    201612_cfpb_IrvineWebWorks_Consume · files.consumerfinance.gov irvinewebworks · www.consumerfinance.gov

Student Loan Care and Debt Resolve New York Attorney General judgment and restitution

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Targeted exact-name searches did not verify an FTC-filed action against Student Loan Care LLC. This candidate concerns the independently verified New York Attorney General plaintiff and the named federal district court consent judgment. Exact search returns are preserved. New York officially confirms approval, named parties and consumer implementation. The signed district court instrument is independently preserved from the CCH public mirror and its relevant signed date is read through the Orrick public rendition. No first-party official host for the entered binary was found in the recorded search. The official state-hosted Doc. 160-1 is a proposal. A direct download of the Orrick mirror returned 403. The court conditions bankruptcy approval, financial disclosures and performance. The separate approval instrument and later performance beyond the agency-reported mailed restitution checks are unverified. The agency reports the two settlement payments as sources but does not state an exact total mailed or cashed, check count, or individual shares in the cited passage. NY Attorney General confirms entry and restitution; exact clauses come from matched public court reproduction. The 5.5 million joint judgment applies to three companies. The 250000 settlement payment is unallocated among the settling group, and Equitable separately paid 225000. The exact FTC identity and individual payout remain held.

  • The New York Attorney General brought the Debt Resolve action in September 2018. Its complaint identified Student Loan Care as a debt-relief contractor and alleged that its Equitable financing terms in 2016 required 48 monthly payments of $39, totaling $1,872 with a stated interest rate of 20.99%. It alleged that Equitable paid the contractors upfront and that a 2017 model added an upfront $99 to $199 escrow payment for Student Loan Care and Student Advocates Team customers. The New York Attorney General confirms that the federal district court approved the Debt Resolve consent judgment on June 25, 2020. The entered judgment identifies Debt Resolve, Student Loan Care, Progress Advocates, Bruce Bellmare and Stanley E. Freimuth as its settling group.

    information-about-student-debt-rel · ag.ny.gov debt_resolve_summons_complaint.pdf · ag.ny.gov NYDebtResolve062520.pdf · business.cch.com Buckley%20InfoBytes%20-%20NY%20AG% · infobytes.orrick.com

  • The entered order restrains the five settling defendants from marketing, providing, assisting or financing covered debt-relief services to any consumer, acting as assignee or holder of covered financing and maintaining an ownership interest over 10% in an entity engaged in covered services. It also bars collection and transfer of covered debt-relief payments, including qualifying debts returned by a lender. For covered reporting, the three companies must request deletion from consumer reporting files within 20 days of learning of a report. They must mail notice within 20 days of learning of a consumer whose debt is subject to the order’s forbearance.

    Buckley%20InfoBytes%20-%20NY%20AG% · infobytes.orrick.com

  • The entered judgment makes Debt Resolve, Progress Advocates and Student Loan Care jointly and severally liable for $5.5 million. It ties suspension to an unallocated $250,000 settlement amount due from the settling group within three business days of Bankruptcy Court approval, subject to the stated conditions. The order permits the New York Attorney General to use the amount for restitution, penalties or costs and provides for possible lifting of suspension on specified findings.

    eac_doc._160-1_proposed_consent_ju · ag.ny.gov NYDebtResolve062520.pdf · business.cch.com

  • The New York Attorney General reports that restitution checks were mailed in September 2020 to eligible New York consumers from the Debt Resolve defendants’ $250,000 payment and Equitable’s separate $225,000 payment. The agency says eligible consumers did not need to make a claim and distinguishes financed debt-relief fees from the underlying student loans, which remained payable.

    information-about-student-debt-rel · ag.ny.gov

Equitable Acceptance New York consent judgment for debt-relief financing and restitution

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Agency release August 8, court text dated August 9, agency-reported approval August 12, and attachment file headers August 28 are preserved as distinct dates. The rendition retains a proposed caption and a judge’s order date. The NYAG public page independently confirms approval. Complete numbered native returns from the NYLAG rendition are sealed. Direct binary retrieval returned HTTP 403, and screenshot retrieval was unavailable. A first-party entered binary and document-level effective-date computation remain unverified. The agency identifies the funding amounts and September 2020 mailing. Exact amounts mailed or cashed, check counts, actual wire dates, individual eligibility and actual credit deletion remain unverified. The more than $950,000 describes balances reported at announcement, separate from cash restitution. The subsequent E165K Debt Resolve consent judgment and the other Equitable proceedings are outside this scope. Preserve state release date, reproduced order date and AG-reported approval date separately. Exact terms are from the matched public reproduction; direct order binary remains held. The Equitable-only judgment, conditional 225000 dollar payment and Debt Resolve contribution are distinct. The AG reports September 2020 checks; individual payment and underlying student loan outcomes remain unverified.

  • The New York Attorney General’s action identified Equitable Acceptance Corporation as a financier of debt-relief services. The August 8, 2019 state release attributed a 20.99% financing rate and more than 4,000 New Yorkers to the lawsuit, and described more than $950,000 in then-outstanding balances covered by cessation of collection. The state later reported court approval of the Equitable consent order on August 12, 2019. The publicly reproduced court text is dated August 9, 2019 and records Equitable’s qualified non-admission and jurisdictional admission.

    attorney-general-james-holds-lende · ag.ny.gov information-about-student-debt-rel · ag.ny.gov NY-Judgment.pdf · nylag.org

  • The order permanently bars Equitable from financing, holding or taking assignment of financing contracts, and marketing or assisting in covered debt-relief products or services offered to New York consumers. Its collection and transfer restrictions cover qualifying debt-relief financing held by Equitable as creditor or assignee where the consumer resided in New York when entering the contract or at any time since. Equitable must request deletion from each consumer reporting agency to which it furnished the debt within 10 days of the effective date, and mail a notice identifying the seller, balance and reporting treatment within 20 days. The order requires a further mailing when a new address is found after specified returned mail.

    information-about-student-debt-rel · ag.ny.gov NY-Judgment.pdf · nylag.org

  • The Equitable-only judgment is $1,665,103. It provides conditional suspension on payment of $225,000, with $150,000 due within seven days and $75,000 within 60 days of the effective date. It permits use for restitution, penalties or costs and allows the court to lift suspension on the Attorney General’s motion and specified findings.

    attorney-general-james-holds-lende · ag.ny.gov NY-Judgment.pdf · nylag.org

  • The Attorney General identifies Equitable’s $225,000 payment as one source of the restitution checks it says were mailed to eligible New York consumers in September 2020. It separately identifies the Debt Resolve defendants’ $250,000 payment. The order addressed financed service fees and the state expressly says the underlying student loans remained payable.

    information-about-student-debt-rel · ag.ny.gov

FTC Equitable Acceptance federal Student Advocates Team judgment and refunds

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The 2022 reports verify case-level consumer mailings and cashing counts. Equitable’s actual escrow transfer, its share of funds used, dollar amount cashed, later refunds and individual account application are unverified. This scope concerns the FTC’s Student Advocates Team case. The New York Attorney General’s state action, the separate FTC Manhattan Beach Venture proceeding and co-defendants’ standalone 2021 order terms are outside this packet. Direct binary downloads from FTC returned HTTP 403. Complete numbered returns from the FTC’s signed court-order PDF, 2022 reports and case sources are sealed, with direct-download failures recorded. Federal Doc. 9 and the New York order remain distinct. Preserve conditional suspension, financing and deletion scope, and case-level mailed and cashing measures.

  • The FTC filed the Student Advocates Team action on September 11, 2019, and the Central District of California entered Doc. 9 against Equitable Acceptance Corporation on September 12. The named corporate service providers were Student Advocates Team, Progress Advocates Group doing business as Student Advocates, Student Advocates Group, and Assurance Solution Services, alongside individual defendants Bradley Jason Hunt and Sean Quincy Lucero. The FTC alleged Equitable assisted covered unlawful telemarketing and misstated terms of the credit used to pay for debt-relief services. The judgment records its qualified non-admission and admission of jurisdictional facts.

    172-3036-student-advocates-team-ll · search.ftc.gov 2020_06_semiannual_litigation_repo · www.ftc.gov 172_3036_pag_stipulated_order_eac_ · www.ftc.gov

  • The order permanently bars Equitable from financing covered secured or unsecured debt relief and assisting others in marketing, selling or financing it. It also requires written, clear and retainable disclosures before signing when fixed credit is repayable in one or more installments, including creditor identity, amount financed, finance charge, annual percentage rate, payment schedule and total payments.

    172_3036_pag_stipulated_order_eac_ · www.ftc.gov

  • The order prohibits collecting or transferring Equitable debt and credit tied to purchases from the four named corporate defendants. For previously furnished covered debt Equitable must request deletion from each consumer reporting agency within 10 business days of entry and mail specified notices within 10 business days of the request. The notices identify the service seller, the cessation and reporting terms, and the applicable reporting-agency request.

    172_3036_pag_stipulated_order_eac_ · www.ftc.gov

  • The entered federal order imposes $24,101,854 in equitable monetary relief against Equitable. It orders $863,800 held by counsel in escrow to be paid within seven days after entry, after which the remainder is suspended subject to financial disclosures. A qualifying court finding on the FTC’s motion can lift suspension. The order permits paid funds to be used for equitable relief and redress administration.

    172_3036_pag_stipulated_order_eac_ · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC’s 2022 reports record the Student Advocates Team case distribution of $822,172.37 mailed in August 2022, 14,521 eligible consumers, and 8,308 who cashed a payment to date, or 57%. The FTC’s Truth in Lending Act report describes the recipients as borrowers who paid Student Advocates and Equitable for debt-relief services. These are case-level figures from the reported mailing and cashing counts.

    172-3036-student-advocates-team-ll · search.ftc.gov 2022_FTC_REFUNDS_TO_CONSUMERS.pdf · www.ftc.gov p154802cfpbtilareport2022.pdf · www.ftc.gov

GST Factoring private student debt relief fee judgments and consumer distributions

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The Doc. 61 operative amount controls the stated GST/Graff order finding. The agency summary’s different number and the separately matching Doc. 72 amount remain visible. Judgments across defendants and cohorts are not summed. FY2020 Slaughter row wraps across printed report pages. The published $21,568 Mize collection is a rounded figure, while the order supplies cents. Additional defendant collections or full payment of civil penalties, net revised Civil Penalty Fund allocation, overlap among recipients, cashed amounts and payment/reissue after May 2026 remain unverified. The evidence is limited to public enforcement and distributions. No inference is drawn about personal loan balances, individual coverage or creditor identity. Operative Doc. 61 paragraph 30 gives 11618552 dollars; preserve the overview discrepancy and separate Champion amount. Distinguish conditional liability, actual collections, fund allocation and separately mailed streams. Do not infer unique recipients or realized cashing.

Timemark federal student debt-relief judgment, collections and refund waves

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

August 12 Doc. 6 supplies the operative terms. July 7 Doc. 3-1 was attached to the motion. CFPB’s early chronology describes the agreement and proposed terms. The July 2023 announcement and FY2023 tables report different dollar metrics. Final cumulative redress, amount of later mailings or reissues, actual cashing and definitive distribution closure remain unverified. The administrator’s closed claims intake and CFPB’s older distribution label concern distinct statuses. The financial report records aggregate defendant collections. Actual remittances allocated to each defendant, individual borrower eligibility, refunds and underlying loan obligations remain outside verified scope. Distinguish entered suspended liability, August collections, allocation and FY2023 mailed streams totaling 3543787 dollars and 7185 checks. Preserve the announced amount separately. Epiq later validated and additional mailings do not establish final aggregate cashing. Administrator claim closure and CFPB ongoing label refer to distinct published statuses.

  • The CFPB filed against Timemark Solutions, Inc., Timothy Lenihan Sr., Mark Nagler and Casey Gassaway on July 7, 2020. The court entered the stipulated final judgment as Doc. 6 on August 12, 2020. The order states that in 2016 through October 2019 the defendants requested and received federal student-loan debt-relief fees before an agreement executed by the consumer altered at least one debt and the consumer made one payment under it. The order records the qualified non-admission and jurisdictional admission. The later CFPB announcement describes fees up to $699 for paperwork to pursue federal options available through the Department of Education for free.

    cfpb_timemark-et-al_stipulated-fin · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb-to-distribute-more-than-3-5-m · www.consumerfinance.gov

  • The entered order permanently restrains all four defendants from offering or assisting in covered debt relief or specified ownership, compensation and work for persons offering those services. It also restricts use of customer information and attempts to collect or transfer payment rights from debt-relief customers, subject to specified customer-information disclosures.

    cfpb_timemark-et-al_stipulated-fin · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The court imposed $3,784,360 in joint and several redress with conditional suspension. The order names $5,000 from Timemark Solutions, $7,000 from Nagler and $10,000 from Gassaway, all due within ten days. It separately ordered a $1 civil money penalty from each of the four defendants. The FY2020 financial report records aggregate collection of $22,000 in Bureau-administered redress on August 19, 2020 and $4 in penalties on August 27.

    cfpb_annual-financial-report_fy-20 · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb_timemark-et-al_stipulated-fin · files.consumerfinance.gov

  • The CFPB’s FY2021 financial report records $3,762,360 allocated from the Civil Penalty Fund for the 2016 through October 2019 debt-relief payment cohort. The FY2023 report separately records $3,521,904 distributed through 6,979 Civil Penalty Fund checks and $21,883 distributed through 206 Bureau-administered redress checks, both beginning FY2023 Q4. The July 2023 public announcement described an anticipated combined $3,543,000 distribution. The compensation page identified 7,185 anticipated recipients.

    cfpb_final-financial-report-fy_202 · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb_financial-report_fy2021.pdf · files.consumerfinance.gov cfpb-to-distribute-more-than-3-5-m · www.consumerfinance.gov timemark · www.consumerfinance.gov

  • Epiq’s CFPB-linked public FAQ identifies eligible consumers as those who paid Timemark Solutions for debt-relief services from January 1, 2016 through October 31, 2019. It reports mailing initial checks on July 6, 2023, validated-claim checks on January 9, 2025, and additional checks after reviewing responses following the March 15, 2025 deadline. The administrator reports that new claims and supporting documentation are no longer accepted. The CFPB page marked July 6, 2023 separately labels distribution ongoing.

    FAQ · www.cfpb-timemark.org timemark · www.consumerfinance.gov

FTC Student Loan Assistance Center, Aspyre and Navloan judgment and closed refunds

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The 2021 announcement of mailed checks, 2024 returned funds and administrative costs are distinct measurements. The $350,000 total fund is a reported accounting amount. Exact later receipts from the assigned judgment or tax refunds, closing transfer date or recipient for leftover funds, and individual check outcomes remain unverified. The FTC case page’s 2021 Pending label refers to its dated public case listing. The 2024 report verifies refund program closure. Later court enforcement or modification remains unverified. Direct binary downloads of the FTC order and 2024 report returned HTTP 403. Complete numbered returns from the FTC-hosted signed order, complaint and reports are sealed. Scope is limited to SLAC, Navloan, Student Loan Assistance Center LLC and Owens, with no conflation with New York Student Loan Care. Exact publisher returns verify Doc. 22 and operative clauses. Direct order and report binaries returned HTTP 403. Resolve the duplicate S3 return by the sealed exact digest. Joint relief, escrow, judgment assignment and tax receipts have distinct terms. Closure components sum to 350000 dollars and cashing participation rounds to 56.9 percent. The announcement is a mailed amount, distinct from returned dollars.

  • The FTC’s case identifies SLAC, Inc. doing business as Student Loan Assistance Center and Aspyre, a separately named Student Loan Assistance Center, LLC, Navloan, Inc., and Adam Owens individually and in his officer or management capacities. The complaint alleged that defendants commonly requested or received $699 upfront and $39 monthly before changing loan terms or the first consumer payment under new terms. It also alleged misleading claims about lasting relief and undisclosed incentives for positive BBB reviews. The district court entered Doc. 22 on May 22, 2020. The order records the defendants’ qualified non-admission and admission of jurisdictional facts.

    172-3090-slac-inc · www.ftc.gov 172_3090_slac_inc._-_stipulated_pe · www.ftc.gov doc_1_complaint.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The order permanently bars covered marketing, sales or assistance involving secured or unsecured debt-relief products and permanently restrains the specified deceptive telemarketing and Telemarketing Sales Rule violations. It requires notice within 14 days to covered existing customers who received services in the three months before defendants signed the order, and bars charges or collection from them until an opt-in confirmation. A limited customer-data exception permits work on listed federal student-loan applications for consumers who received notice and opted in. The order separately restricts false representations about reviewer independence.

    172_3090_slac_inc._-_stipulated_pe · www.ftc.gov

  • The order imposed $23,920,690 in joint and several equitable relief against the three companies and Owens, with conditional suspension. It required $350,000 held in escrow to be transferred within seven days, assignment of rights to a stated $123,565.55 judgment on which defendants stipulated no amount had been collected, and transfer of specified tax-related receipts for tax years 2015–2018. It permits reinstatement on a qualifying court finding on the FTC’s motion.

    172_3090_slac_inc._-_stipulated_pe · www.ftc.gov

  • In June 2021 the FTC announced checks of more than $316,000 to 10,689 people, with Analytics as administrator and a stated 90-day cashing window. The FTC’s 2024 closure table reports a $350,000 total fund, $271,120.50 returned to consumers, $63,073.09 in administrative costs, and $15,806.41 in leftover funds. Of 10,689 consumers sent a payment, 6,083 cashed at least one payment, or 56.9%.

    ftc-sends-checks-people-who-lost-m · www.ftc.gov ftc-refunds-consumers-2024.pdf · www.ftc.gov

FTC American Student Loan Consolidators entered order and closed refunds

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The shared December 7 release also describes the separate Student Debt Doctor action covered in E164A. The ASLC claims use only its own named defendants and release section. The FTC’s approximately $1.3 million turnover requirement, exact entered judgment, total reported program fund and actual reported returns describe different measures. The 2023 closure is the FTC refund program. Doc. 46 §XIV retains jurisdiction for construction, modification and enforcement. Later court enforcement or modification, exact asset-by-asset realized receipts, the date or recipient of any actual leftover-fund transfer and individual refunds or loan consequences are unverified. The public source tool returned numbered text of the entered order, complaint and refund report. Local attempts to download original order and 2023 report bytes failed on hostname resolution. No original binary is attested. The numbered returns and binary attempts are sealed. Court entry November 30 precedes FTC publication December 7. Preserve allegations, joint judgment, conditional transfers and actual consumer returns separately. Closure components reconcile and consumer cashing rounds to 50.6 percent.

  • FTC matter 172 3076/X170053, Southern District of Florida action 0:17-cv-61862-DPG, named American Student Loan Consolidators LLC doing business as ASLC Processing; BBND Marketing LLC doing business as United Processing Center, United SL Processing and United Student Loan Processing; and Daniel Upbin and Patrick O’Deady individually and in owner, officer or manager capacities. The court entered stipulated final Doc. 46 on November 30, 2018. The FTC’s December 7, 2018 timeline date reflects its settlement publication. The order records qualified non-admission of complaint allegations and admission of jurisdictional facts for this action.

    172-3076-x170053-american-student- · www.ftc.gov american_student_loan_consolidator · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC complaint alleged that the operators represented that consumers were approved or preapproved for forgiveness, claimed or implied loan-servicer or Department of Education affiliation, and typically charged an initial $499 to $799, sometimes representing the fee as applied to consumers’ loans. Its advance-fee count alleged requests or receipt before a valid agreement altering at least one debt and a consumer payment under that agreement. The FTC’s settlement announcement described fees up to $899 and at least $23 million allegedly collected. Those are distinct attributed allegations and fee measures.

    ftc-settlements-will-ban-student-l · www.ftc.gov 1723076aslccomplaint.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • Doc. 46 §I permanently bars defendants from marketing, selling or assisting those activities for covered secured or unsecured debt-relief products or services. Sections III–IV separately prohibit specified misrepresentations, including refund terms and affiliation, and require competent and reliable substantiation for covered financial-product benefit, performance or efficacy claims. Section VII requires redress information within 14 days after a written request and limits use, disclosure or retention of specified previously obtained customer data, including destruction within 30 days of written direction with a government-request or legal-requirement exception.

    american_student_loan_consolidator · www.ftc.gov

  • Section V enters $23,391,546 in joint and several equitable monetary relief against the defined corporate and individual defendants. It requires Upbin’s $135,000 and O’Deady’s $90,000 escrow payments within seven days, specified liquidations and third-party transfers, and transfer of receiver-held net proceeds after court-authorized payments. The remainder is suspended upon completion of specified asset transfers. On the FTC’s motion, a qualifying material financial misstatement, omission or failure to disclose found by the court lifts suspension as to that defendant, making the judgment amount immediately due less prior §V payments plus interest from entry. The FTC announcement’s approximately $1.3 million requirement includes asset turnover.

    ftc-settlements-will-ban-student-l · www.ftc.gov american_student_loan_consolidator · www.ftc.gov

  • The July 9, 2020 FTC announcement reported mailing 41,048 checks totaling more than $1 million and named Rust Consulting, Inc. as administrator. The FTC’s 2023 closed-program table reports $1,198,387 total fund, $896,187 returned to consumers, $202,210 administrative costs, $99,990 leftover and $0 spent on consumer education. Of 41,048 consumers sent a payment, 20,767 cashed at least one, or 50.6%. Section VI(E) separately authorizes the FTC or its designee to apply order receipts for equitable relief including redress and administration, with a prescribed alternative disposition for remaining money.

    ftc-refunds-to-consumers-2023.pdf · search.ftc.gov 172-3076-x170053-american-student- · www.ftc.gov ftc-sends-more-1-million-refunds-v · www.ftc.gov american_student_loan_consolidator · www.ftc.gov

FTC Alliance Document Preparation entered orders and closed refunds

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The agency aggregate for proposed and final orders and their unsuspended portions is distinct from each signed instrument and case-level refund accounting. No defendant-specific realized contributions, reinstatement, later court activity, leftover transfer date or individual refund are verified. Doc. 193 retains jurisdiction. The FTC case listing uses Direct Consulting Service LLC in its general party line. Signed Doc. 193 controls its exact scoped Direct Consulting Group, LLC name. The default instruments, the date reported in the press release and the agency web timeline publication are preserved as distinct events. Exact separate entered Rubeni, Reuveni and Ratliff instruments remain outside the verified monetary scope. Local downloads of the Doc. 193 and refund report PDF binaries failed on hostname resolution. Exact numbered public-tool returns are sealed. Actual consumer loan terms and individual refunds remain outside scope. Preserve signature, filing header and FTC-reported entry dates as attributed. Keep stipulated, relief-defendant and default terms separately scoped. Closure components sum to 5652048.24 dollars; the 32452 count denotes consumers cashing at least one payment, not checks, and rounds to 81.7 percent. Announced mailed amounts differ from actual returned dollars.

  • FTC matter 172 3126 in the Central District of California was brought in case CV-17-07048 SJO (KS), also numbered 2:17-cv-07048-SJO-KS. Alliance Document Preparation, LLC used EZ Doc Preps, Grads Aid and First Document Aid. The FTC described alleged upfront fees up to $1,000, false claims of education department or servicer affiliation, and promised qualification or approval for permanently reduced payments or loan forgiveness or discharge. The complaint alleged requesting or receiving fees before a valid agreement altering at least one debt and a customer payment under it.

    172-3126-alliance-document-prepara · www.ftc.gov student-debt-relief-operators-agre · www.ftc.gov 1723126ezdocscomplaint.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The October 25, 2018 signed Doc. 193 defines Benjamin Naderi, Alliance Document Preparation, LLC, SBS Capital Group, Inc. and First Student Aid, LLC as stipulating defendants. It separately defines Direct Consulting Group, LLC and Capital Doc Prep, Inc. as relief defendants. The stipulating defendants agreed to qualified non-admission, admitted jurisdictional facts for this action, and are permanently barred from marketing, selling or assisting covered secured or unsecured debt-relief products or services. The judge directed final entry as to the stipulating defendants under Rule 54(b).

    alliance_document_prep_-_dkt_193_f · www.ftc.gov

  • Doc. 193 §IV enters $10.2 million in joint and several equitable relief against the stipulating defendants. It calls for specified asset transfers and relinquishment of claims to remaining specified receivership funds after authorized fees, with a separate waiver by relief defendants as to their funds. It suspends the remainder after the required payments and permits lifting the suspension as to a particular stipulating defendant on an FTC motion and a court finding of a material nondisclosure, misstatement or omission.

    alliance_document_prep_-_dkt_193_f · www.ftc.gov

  • The separate default judgments in Doc. 189 and Doc. 190 impose $1,526,902.84 against Elite Doc Prep, LLC doing business as Premier Student Aid, and $1,792,753.68 against Elite Consulting Service, LLC formerly known as and doing business as First Grad Aid, respectively. The FTC release reports September 5 entry for both. The public PDFs show August 30 filed headers, with the Doc. 189 signature page displaying 9/1/18 and the Doc. 190 signature page displaying August 30, 2018. These dates are recorded by source and event type.

    172-3126-alliance-document-prepara · www.ftc.gov student-debt-relief-operators-agre · www.ftc.gov ez_doc_default_judgment_ecs.pdf · www.ftc.gov ez_doc_default_judgment_edp.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • Separately, Doc. 191 orders $158,790 joint and several equitable relief against Shawn Gabbaie and SBB Holdings, LLC, comprising a $109,183 payment due within seven days and waiver of rights to $49,607 in company funds. Doc. 186 orders $200,000 against Farzan Azinkhan with conditional partial suspension on transfer of specified bank funds. The Azinkhan instrument is signed and stamped filed August 7, 2018, and the FTC release reports August 9 entry.

    172-3126-alliance-document-prepara · www.ftc.gov student-debt-relief-operators-agre · www.ftc.gov ez_doc_azinkhanstipfinalorder.pdf · www.ftc.gov ez_doc_stipfinalorderentered_gabba · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC announced September 30, 2019 that it was sending over $5.4 million in 39,734 checks, averaging $136.48, with a 60-day check window and Analytics as administrator. The FTC’s 2024 closure table reports a $5,652,048.24 fund, $5,264,069.41 returned to consumers, $189,412.16 administrative costs, and $198,566.67 leftover. Of 39,734 consumers sent a payment, 32,452 cashed at least one, or 81.7%.

    ftc-refunds-consumers-2024.pdf · search.ftc.gov 172-3126-alliance-document-prepara · www.ftc.gov ftc-sends-more-54-million-people-w · www.ftc.gov

FTC Arete Financial entered orders and public refunds

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The FTC publication dates and court instrument dates describe distinct events. The Doc. 172 filed header and operative terms are verified, with court signature or exact later entry metadata outside the saved text. The March 30, 2022 amended Doc. 215 signed body controls its scope despite the FTC URL filename. Exact defendant-by-defendant receipts, later court enforcement or modification, actual receiver transfer date, final second-round funds cashed, refund program closure, and individual eligibility, payments or loan balances remain unverified. Do not aggregate instrument judgments into consumer returns. Local original PDF downloads failed on hostname resolution. Exact numbered FTC source-tool returns and access attempt receipts are sealed. No original binary is attested. Use Doc. 172 for proposal chronology only. Doc. 180 signed and filed date and terms are verified from the court-stamped order hosted by the court-appointed receiver. The FTC January 26, 2022 press release reports that Singh paid $743,386. Exact date and receipt remain unverified. The receiver’s May 24, 2022 public update reports its final report and request for discharge were filed April 4, 2022 and were then pending. Actual transfer and discharge dates and subsequent enforcement or modification remain unverified. Final second-round amount cashed, program closure and individual eligibility, payment or loan outcomes remain unverified. Refund distributions and monetary judgments describe different amounts. The independent review verified numbered publisher and receiver-hosted returns. Original candidate binary downloads were unsuccessful, and no independent original-binary verification is asserted. C003 must bind new signed-order evidence through a separately reviewed adoption overlay. A text-only override would retain stale proposal pins. C004 replacement preserves the independently verified earlier sentences.

  • The FTC’s Arete Financial Group matter 192 3040 is the Central District of California case initially listed as 8:19-02109-JVS-ADS. The FTC complaint alleged falsely implied education department or servicer affiliation, promises to reduce or eliminate federal student loan debt or monthly payments, upfront fees from about $500 to $1,800 and recurring fees typically $19 to $49. It alleged collection of at least part of the upfront fee before work, misrepresentations about applying monthly fees to loans and taking over servicing, and ensuing borrower harm.

    192-3040-arete-financial-group · www.ftc.gov ftc-sends-more-33-million-consumer · www.ftc.gov 192_3040_arete_financial_group_com · www.ftc.gov

  • The September 9, 2020 signed Doc. 145 permanently bars Carey G. Howe, Anna C. Howe, Shunmin Hsu, Ruddy Palacios and Oliver Pomazi from covered debt-relief activities. It enters a $43,337,292.83 joint and several judgment and orders initial payments of $133,496.42 by the Howes, $43,252.16 by Hsu, $260,582 by Palacios and $54,505 by Pomazi, plus the specified trust funds and applicable deferred obligations. The remainder is suspended subject to payment, transfer and deed-of-trust proof terms.

    145_order_for_perm._inj._as_to_are · www.ftc.gov

  • The March 30, 2022 signed amended Doc. 215 defines its stipulating group to include Arete Financial Group, Arete Financial Group LLC, CBC Conglomerate LLC, Diamond Choice Inc., J&L Enterprise LLC, La Casa Bonita Investments Inc. and relief defendant MJ Wealth Solutions, LLC. The order sets a permanent covered debt-relief ban and $22,079,787.30 joint and several monetary relief against the group as defined, with conditional suspension after the Section X payment. Within 120 days after entry, the receiver must file with the court and serve on the parties a final accounting, report and compensation request, subject to court extension for good cause. After court approval of compensation, the receiver must transfer the group’s remaining monetary assets in its possession to the FTC. Remaining duties must be completed and the receivership must terminate within 60 days after transfer.

    proposed_orderr-arete_corps.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • For the first June 14, 2023 distribution, the FTC’s 2023 report lists $3,335,694 sent, 37,844 eligible consumers and 25,184 who had cashed a payment at that report cutoff, or 66.55%. The launch notice specified JND Legal Administration and 90 days to cash. The FTC’s March 2025 notice reports more than $2.6 million in first-round refunds realized and announced 18,509 second checks totaling over $551,000 for consumers who accepted their first payment and paid Arete more than $750, with 90 days to cash.

    arete-financial-refunds · www.ftc.gov 192-3040-arete-financial-group · www.ftc.gov ftc-sends-more-33-million-consumer · www.ftc.gov ftc-refunds-to-consumers-2023.pdf · www.ftc.gov

Arete Financial signed Doc. 180 correction

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Doc. 172 supports proposal chronology only. The court-stamped Doc. 180 exact public return controls the order terms. The numbered native public returns are preserved. No original PDF binary is attested. The FTC reports payment. The actual payment date and transaction receipt, later enforcement or modification, consumer refund amounts and individual outcomes remain outside this correction. This one-claim supplement resolves the source distinction for the held E166M-C003 if independently verified and adopted. Preserve the original E166M pass and its existing claims. Doc. 172 supports proposal chronology only. The signed court-stamped receiver-hosted Doc. 180 numbered return controls binding terms. No original PDF binary is attested. Payment and partial suspension are attributed to the January 26, 2022 FTC announcement; exact payment date, transaction receipt and consumer refunds remain held. E166M manifest independently verified and preserved.

Accelerated Debt Settlement corporate default judgment and FTC amount discrepancy

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The signed, filed court instrument controls the amount it entered. The reason for the discrepancy, later docket changes or enforcement, money received, actual redress and individual eligibility or payment remain unverified. The public order itself permits use of money received and does not prove collection or distribution. No aggregation with other orders or defendants’ judgments. No original PDF binary is asserted. No calculation is necessary to establish that the two displayed figures differ. Signed court-stamped Doc. 90 controls the entered 108586567.60 dollars. Attribute 106.8 million dollars to the FTC release and preserve the discrepancy. Corporate default scope and joint-and-several language are confined to the order. Section VIII.F addresses use of money actually received; no receipts, distributions or individual refunds are verified.

  • In case 2:25-cv-02443-SMB, the District of Arizona’s October 14, 2026 corporate default judgment and permanent injunction, Doc. 90, bars the defaulting defendants from the specified sale, marketing and assistance activities involving debt relief products or services and from participating in telemarketing.

    ADS-DefaultJudgmentAgainstCorporat · www.ftc.gov

  • Section VIII.A of signed Doc. 90 enters $108,586,567.60 in favor of the FTC against the defaulting defendants, jointly and severally with any other defendant against whom judgment may be entered. The FTC press release describing the same October 14 corporate default reports $106.8 million. The figures differ. The signed order supplies the amount entered in that instrument.

    court-permanently-shuts-down-illeg · search.ftc.gov ADS-DefaultJudgmentAgainstCorporat · www.ftc.gov

  • Section VIII.F permits the FTC or its designee to use money actually received under Doc. 90 for consumer relief and related administration. It also addresses related relief if direct redress is impracticable in whole or part or money remains after redress. The order does not establish actual collections or consumer payments.

    ADS-DefaultJudgmentAgainstCorporat · www.ftc.gov

Superior Servicing corporate default judgment and receivership terms

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Actual transfer, receiver extension or termination, monetary collections, consumer distributions and individual eligibility remain unverified. The February 10 receiver anchor is attributed to Doc. 119, and no exact calendar deadline is computed. No original PDF binary is asserted. No separate individual judgment amount or subsequent judicial effect is inferred. Doc. 119 signed June 24 and filed June 26, 2026. Preserve defined corporate default parties and conditional joint liability wording. Section VI.E addresses amounts actually received. Section VIII expressly anchors the 180 days to February 10 entry of the Merdjanian final order, subject to the stated extension clause. Actual transfers, collections and refunds remain held.

  • The District of Nevada order in case 2:24-cv-02163-GMN-MDC, Doc. 119, is dated June 24, 2026 and filed June 26, 2026. Sections I and II permanently bar the defaulting companies from specified sales, marketing and assistance involving secured or unsecured debt-relief products or services and from participating in telemarketing.

    SuperiorServicing-OrderGrantingDef · www.ftc.gov

  • Section VI.A enters $45,959,012.69 in monetary relief in favor of the FTC against the defaulting defendants, jointly and severally with any other defendant to the extent subsequently ordered. Section VI.E permits use of money actually received for consumer relief and administration. It permits related relief when direct relief is impracticable in whole or part or funds remain, and directs money unused for such relief to the U.S. Treasury.

    SuperiorServicing-OrderGrantingDef · www.ftc.gov

  • Section VIII continues the permanent receiver and specifies a 180-day duty-completion period measured from the February 10, 2026 entry of the Merdjanian final order, subject to a request for court extension for good cause. On termination and final payment of approved fees, costs and expenses, the receiver must transfer remaining estate assets to the FTC or its designated agent.

    SuperiorServicing-OrderGrantingDef · www.ftc.gov

Helping America Group FTC refund rounds

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The August 2026 case-page return supplies the current numbered text. Indexed historical search output shows a December 2021 prior version and gives stand-alone round figures, but no exact numbered prior publisher return was verified. The distinct December 2021 amount and count remain held here. Do not add announced mailing totals to actual refunds. The August 2026 actual amount cashed, unique people across all rounds, final program closure and individual eligibility or receipt remain unverified. No calculation is needed. July 2020 release gives announced checks and amount. August 2026 page attributes more than 20 million dollars in realized refunds to the first two rounds combined; December 2021 standalone amount and count remain unverified. The third-round amount and cohort are announced payments, and actual cashing remains unverified.

National Landmark and Absolute Financial FTC refund outcomes and second round

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

E137R-C004 already records the December 2024 first-round mailing of 1,625 checks totaling more than $540,000. This supplement adds the FTC’s later first-round result and the second mailing. The earlier linked press release timed out on this capture. Its original reviewed evidence remains separate. The second-round amount actually cashed, final program closure and individual entitlement, payment or debt outcome remain unverified. The two published figures use distinct measures and are not added. No calculation is needed. E137R-C004 remains intact: 1625 checks totaling more than 540000 dollars were mailed in the first round. The later FTC page reports more than 464000 dollars in resulting first-round refunds. May 2026 reports 1389 payments totaling more than 69000 dollars to first-payment accepters. Exact realized amounts, second-round cashing, unique combined recipients and individual payment remain unverified.

  • The FTC reports that the December 2024 first payments in the National Landmark and Absolute Financial refund program resulted in more than $464,000 in refunds. This is the FTC’s later description of the first-round result.

    national-landmark-refunds · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC’s May 2026 case refund page reports that funds remained and the agency was sending 1,389 second-round payments totaling more than $69,000 to people who accepted their first payment. It says to cash a check within 90 days. The FTC’s active-program index lists the case in May 2026.

    refunds · www.ftc.gov national-landmark-refunds · www.ftc.gov

Cleo AI cash-advance settlement entry and FTC refund announcement

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The June 2025 FTC report establishes its reported entry date. The blank judicial fields establish the limit of the exact posted order copy. A secondary docket locator is preserved as discovery only. The exact entered signed PDF, actual settlement receipt date, actual refund amounts accepted, final closure and individual payment or entitlement remain unverified. No difference is computed between the posted judgment amount and announced distribution. The evidence does not identify what happened to any difference. FTC litigation report establishes April 25, 2025 entry. Posted copy has blank judicial date and signature; exact signed body and actual receipt remain held. October 27, 2026 is announced distribution start, and payment count and value are announced figures. Consumer acceptance and realized payments remain unverified.

  • The FTC June 2025 semiannual litigation report records entry of the stipulated permanent injunction and monetary relief on April 25, 2025, in FTC v. Cleo AI, No. 1:25-cv-2594 (S.D.N.Y.). The separate FTC-posted order copy shows $17 million in monetary relief and payment within seven days of entry, but its judicial date and signature lines are blank. These are terms of the posted copy. The exact entered order text is held.

    2025-06-Final-Public.pdf · www.ftc.gov cleo_order_-_executed_-_for_press_ · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC refund page announced that, starting October 27, 2026, it would send 2,124,796 PayPal payments totaling more than $15.8 million to people who paid Cleo AI for eligible instant cash advances. It instructs recipients to accept a payment within 30 days. These are the announced distribution terms.

    cleo-ai-refunds · search.ftc.gov

FloatMe judgment, first refund outcome and second distribution

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The filed header supplies January 22, 2024. The judge line and January signature block are preserved but no separate handwritten date is asserted from imperfect extracted text. No original PDF binary is asserted. Keep the entered judgment, FTC-reported payment, first distribution announcement, first-round result and second-round announced distribution separate. Final program closure, actual second-round acceptance and individual eligibility, receipt or loan outcome remain unverified. No calculation applies. Filed Doc. 7 establishes the joint judgment and seven-day payment requirement. Attribute actual three million payment to the FTC; exact receipt date remains unverified. September 2024 announced and resulting refunds are separate. April 2026 amount and count describe announced payments to first-payment accepters; actual second-round acceptance and final totals remain unverified.

  • The Western District of Texas stipulated order in case 5:24-cv-00001-XR, Doc. 7, filed January 22, 2024, enters $3 million in joint and several monetary relief against the individual and corporate defendants and requires payment to the FTC within seven days of entry. The FTC later says FloatMe paid $3 million. The exact receipt date is unverified.

    floatme-refunds · www.ftc.gov DktNo7FinalOrder.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC announced more than $2.6 million for the first FloatMe distribution and planned to send PayPal payments on September 23, 2024 to 449,344 members who paid for instant cash advances. Its later case page reports that the September 2024 payments resulted in more than $1.5 million in refunds. The announced distribution and later reported result are separate measures.

    floatme-refunds · www.ftc.gov ftc-sends-more-26-million-consumer · www.ftc.gov

  • The April 2026 FTC case page says funds remained and the FTC was sending 255,739 payments totaling more than $1 million to people who accepted their first payment. It specifies 90 days to cash a check and 30 days to accept a PayPal payment. Actual second-round acceptance and final totals remain unverified.

    floatme-refunds · www.ftc.gov

Brigit entered judgment and FTC first and second refund measures

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The entered instrument and dated agency payment account have separate provenance. The court-hosted filing text itself is accessed through the FTC publisher copy. Exact docket number is omitted from claim text because the extracted header and body identifiers differ. Round-one sent amount, the report-date cashing count, the later first-round refund result and round-two sending are separate measures. The count fraction 1,041,261 divided by 1,818,930 rounds to 57.2%. Final closure, second-round actual acceptance and individual outcomes remain unverified. Order and FTC-reported payment both state 18 million dollars; exact receipt date remains held. The first-round ratio rounds to 57.2 percent and counts consumers, not dollars. First-round sent and realized amounts have different reporting points. The May 2026 count and amount are announced, and actual second-round receipt or acceptance remains unverified.

  • The November 8, 2023 stipulated court order against Bridge It, Inc., doing business as Brigit, enters $18 million in monetary relief and requires payment to the FTC within seven days of entry. The FTC refund page separately reports that Brigit paid $18 million. The exact receipt date remains unverified.

    brigit-refunds · www.ftc.gov DE%20011%20Final%20Order%20ENTERED · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC 2024 refund report lists the November 18, 2024 first Brigit distribution as $17,043,374.10 sent, 1,818,930 eligible consumers, and 1,041,261 consumers who had cashed a payment to date (57.2%). The May 2026 FTC case page separately reports that the November 2024 first payments resulted in more than $9.8 million in refunds. These are distinct measures and reporting points.

    brigit-refunds · www.ftc.gov ftc-refunds-consumers-2024.pdf · www.ftc.gov

  • In May 2026 the FTC reported that the Brigit fund still had money and it was sending 1,052,038 payments totaling more than $6.8 million to people who accepted their first payment. The FTC says to cash a check within 90 days or accept a PayPal payment within 30 days. The amount accepted in the second round remains unverified.

    brigit-refunds · www.ftc.gov

Student Advocates service-provider stipulation and FTC entry report

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The separate signed court order body for this group and actual payment or suspension are held. Treat exact Doc. 71 text as stipulated terms and entry as the FTC account. E165R already covers separate Equitable Acceptance Doc. 9 and case-level 2022 refund implementation. E165K concerns separate New York relief. No duplicate refund claim. FTC litigation report establishes May 17, 2021 entry. Attribute exact parties, ban, 24561908 dollar joint judgment and Hunt 11500 dollar payment condition to published Doc. 71 stipulation. Exact signed body and actual payment remain held. Equitable refunds and New York relief remain separately scoped.

  • The FTC June 2021 litigation report states that final injunction and monetary-relief orders for the remaining defendants were entered May 17, 2021. The published Doc. 71 filed that day is styled a stipulation as to entry for Student Advocates Team, Progress Advocates Group, Student Advocates Group, Assurance Solution Services and Bradley Jason Hunt. Its stipulated terms permanently bar the group from the specified debt-relief marketing, sales and assistance activities.

    2021_06_semiannual_litigation_repo · search.ftc.gov 71_-_stipulation_for_judgment_re_c · www.ftc.gov

  • Doc. 71 specifies $24,561,908 in joint and several monetary relief and an $11,500 payment by Hunt within seven days of entry, with the remainder suspended upon payment subject to stated conditions.

    71_-_stipulation_for_judgment_re_c · www.ftc.gov

First Capital Group temporary restraining order and complaint scope

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The signed date and FTC issue date are verified. A separate filing stamp or docket number for the instrument, any later hearing or preliminary injunction, actual receiver control or assets, merits, monetary award and consumer relief remain held. No case-specific consumer records, balances or payments are verified. No arithmetic applies. Use the signed November 5 TRO date and November 16 show-cause date as ordered. Filing stamp and later procedural events remain unverified. Asset restraint and temporary receiver are interim. More than 20 million dollars is the complaint allegation, with final judgment, redress and individual outcomes held.

  • The Central District of California temporary restraining order in case 8:26-cv-03224-MRA-KESx is dated November 5, 2026. It temporarily restrains disposition of covered defendant assets, appoints Thomas McNamara temporary receiver of the Receivership Entities, and directs defendants to show cause on November 16, 2026 why a preliminary injunction should not issue. The hearing date is as ordered in the captured instrument.

    FCG-TRO.pdf · search.ftc.gov

  • The FTC complaint alleges that defendants collected more than $20 million from consumers. The FTC announcement attributes the case to alleged deceptive debt collection practices. The sum is the FTC allegation of payments to defendants. The captured TRO establishes provisional relief. A final monetary judgment, actual redress or individual debt outcome remains unverified.

    FCG-Complaint.pdf · search.ftc.gov ftc-action-results-court-issuing-t · www.ftc.gov

Lead Express and Harvest Moon stipulated debt treatment and FTC refund measures

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Doc. 94 is the filed stipulation. The FTC report supplies the attributed entry date for the separate injunction. Exact signed order, actual debt treatment, judgment enforcement, and individual refunds remain held. 10,653 divided by 26,698 rounds to 40%. No dollar amount cashed is derived. Attribute April 1 entry to the FTC report and exact deemed-paid formula to filed Doc. 94. Signed April body remains unverified. June 2022 mailed dollars and consumer cashing counts are distinct; actual dollars cashed remain unverified.

  • The FTC litigation report records April 1, 2021 entry of a stipulated permanent injunction against the listed Lead Express corporate defendants and two individuals. It separately records the motion against La Posta Tribal Lending Enterprise.

    2021_06_semiannual_litigation_repo · www.ftc.gov

  • The separate January 27, 2021 filed stipulation, Doc. 94, defines existing debt as consumer debt issued by the tribal defendant and assigned to the corporate or individual defendants before the May 19, 2020 TRO. Its text deems such debt paid in full to the extent it exceeds the amount financed plus one finance charge. The stipulated text bars collection, transfer and credit reporting of paid-in-full debt and directs transfer of other existing debt to the receiver. Exact April 1 signed terms are unverified.

    de_94_-_stipulation_to_enter_final · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC 2022 annual report records $970,786.65 mailed in June 2022 in the Lead Express/Harvest Moon case, with 26,698 eligible consumers and 10,653 who had cashed a payment to date (40%). The reported cashing count measures people. The corresponding dollar amount cashed remains unverified.

    2022_FTC_REFUNDS_TO_CONSUMERS.pdf · www.ftc.gov

Vantage Point Services permanent debt-collection order and May 2022 refunds

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Doc. 295 pertains to its four covered defendants. Other defendants or instruments, actual enforcement, transfers, individual outcomes, final program closure and dollar amount cashed are unverified. Neither judgment measures the refunds mailed. 2,097 divided by 5,726 rounds to 37%. No collection or refund dollar estimate is derived. Preserve separate judgment groups and seven-day payment clauses. The FTC May 2022 figure is mailed dollars; 2097 of 5726 eligible consumers rounds to 37 percent. Collections, actual dollars cashed and individual payment remain unverified.

  • In case 1:15-cv-00006-WMS-HKS, the September 17, 2018 signed and filed Doc. 295 permanently bars the covered Vantage Point defendants from the specified debt collection activities. It enters $22,534,919 jointly and severally against Gregory MacKinnon and Vantage Point Services, and $4,423,795 jointly and severally against Angela Burdorf and Payment Management Solutions. The order specifies payment within seven days for each judgment.

    295_vantage_point_services_final_o · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC 2022 refund report lists $255,399.19 mailed in May 2022 in the Vantage Point Services case, with 5,726 eligible consumers and 2,097 who cashed a payment to date (37%). It does not give the dollar amount cashed in that row.

    2022_FTC_REFUNDS_TO_CONSUMERS.pdf · www.ftc.gov

GAFS permanent debt-collection order and August 2022 refund measures

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

Doc. 60 covers its named settling defendants. No separate orders, actual transfer or liquidation, amount collected, individual outcomes or final program closure are established. Preserve printed and recomputed rates.

  • In case 3:19-cv-00055-GCM, Doc. 60 was signed June 11, 2019 and filed June 12. It permanently prohibits the covered GAFS settling defendants from participating in debt collection and from the specified marketing or transactions in debt or debt-related consumer information. It enters $3.1 million in equitable monetary relief, jointly and severally with any other Charlotte Debt Collection defendants against whom judgment may be entered. The remainder is suspended upon the specified transfers and liquidation, subject to the order’s conditions.

    gafs_stipulated_final_order_-_nc_d · search.ftc.gov

  • The FTC 2022 annual refund report lists $1,015,455.23 mailed in August 2022 for GAFS Group, with 1,966 eligible consumers and 856 who cashed a payment to date. Its percentage column prints 43%. Dividing the displayed counts yields about 43.54%, or 44% rounded to the nearest whole percent. The reason for the difference and the dollar amount cashed remain unverified.

    2022_FTC_REFUNDS_TO_CONSUMERS.pdf · www.ftc.gov

Stark Recovery Doc. 354 judgment and FTC fiscal 2021 disbursement

Library record saved 2026-11-13

Research scope and limits

The date on the public Doc. 354 filed header and the entry chronology in the FTC report are separate. The signed page is not verified in the numbered redacted capture. Doc. 354 addresses only its specified defendants. Other stipulated orders are outside this candidate. Actual transfer, suspension, defendant-level collection, individual payment, cashing totals and closure remain unverified. Do not equate the stated judgment with disbursement. No arithmetic applies. Separate the October 27 filed redacted Doc. 354 header from October 30 FTC-reported entry. Attribute exact parties, ban, monetary relief and conditional suspension to the filed body; exact signed page and actual performance remain held. FY2021 case-level disbursements establish neither dollars cashed nor defendant-specific funding.

  • In Northern District of Illinois case 1:16-cv-03463, the public redacted Doc. 354 carries an October 27, 2017 filed header and covers six specified companies and Hirsh Mohindra. Its body permanently bans the stipulating defendants from debt collection and specified debt, debt-payment and debt-information activity. It specifies $47,220,491 jointly and severally and provides that the remainder is suspended once the specified transfers and other obligations are completed, subject to stated conditions. The FTC litigation report separately records entry of stipulated final judgments and permanent injunctions on October 30, 2017.

    2017-12_semiannual_litigation_repo · www.ftc.gov stark_doc354stipperminjhirshetal_r · www.ftc.gov

  • The FTC fiscal 2021 agency financial report records $4.1 million disbursed in more than 10,000 payments in the Stark Law phantom debt matter and attributes the refunds to a 2017 settlement. This is case-level disbursement. The report does not establish dollars cashed or which defendants funded the distributions.

    ftc_fy2021_agency_financial_final. · www.ftc.gov