Short answer
Measure all the debts you enrolled. Add payments to creditors, provider and account fees, and the current amount still due on unresolved accounts. Keep separately any funds you still own, possible tax and any uncertain payoff amounts.
Start with the enrollment balances
Save the original balance and date for every enrolled debt. In another column, record today’s confirmed payoff or balance. That lets you see how much interest or how many fees were added while an account was waiting for negotiation.
Track what left your control
Count creditor payments and fees you’ve actually paid. Track fees still owed and future scheduled amounts separately. A dedicated-account deposit that remains available to you is not a payment to the creditor. Counting the deposit and the later payment would count the same dollars twice.
Include accounts the provider hasn’t resolved
If a creditor declines an offer, include the updated balance for that debt when estimating what paying every enrolled account could cost. Do the same for accounts still in collection. If an account is disputed or a lawsuit may change the amount, mark the uncertainty and model a range. Don’t treat an unaccepted offer as the current payoff.
Run the whole-program example
Suppose you enrolled debts of $8,000, $6,000 and $4,000, totaling $18,000. You settled the first for $4,800, paid $1,200 in provider fees and paid $150 in account fees. The other two balances are now $7,200 and $4,650. Your cash already paid is $6,150 and your unpaid balance is $11,850. If you paid those balances in full today, the combined amount would be $18,000 before any tax or further charges. That is the same as the starting total even though the first creditor accepted less.
Separate the estimate from the final outcome
Update the ledger whenever a creditor confirms a balance, a payment clears or you receive a signed agreement. Keep a potential cancellation-of-debt tax estimate separate until you know how the IRS rules apply. Compare fully paying the remaining debts with any documented alternatives you are actually eligible to use.
Rules, exceptions and limits
Use the enrollment balances as a baseline when evaluating a program’s savings claims. For your decision today, compare only the costs you would still face under each option, using the same starting date and balances. Treat the updated balance as an estimate of what you could owe today and revise it when you have a verified payoff. Canceled debt can be taxable unless an exception or exclusion applies.
Sources
- CFPB · How unsettled accounts can offset savings
- FTC · Savings claims, enrollment balances and fees
- IRS · Publication 4681 and tax treatment of canceled debts
Sources checked November 16, 2026