Collections & your rights

How to answer a consumer debt case in New York City

Sources checked November 16, 20262 min readPrint

Short answer

If your summons says Consumer Credit Transaction and names the Civil Court of the City of New York, contact the clerk in the borough handling the case. You may answer in person through the clerk or file a written answer. The City Civil Court deadline depends on how and where the plaintiff served you.

Find the event that starts your deadline

If someone handed the summons to you personally within New York City, City Civil Court Act § 402 gives you 20 days after service to appear and answer. If service used another method or happened outside the city, the statute gives you 30 days after proof of service is filed with the clerk. If you are unsure which rule applies, ask the clerk how to find the filed proof of service and get legal help checking your deadline.

Choose an in-person or written answer

For an in-person answer, tell the clerk which statements you dispute and which defenses you want recorded. The clerk fills out the court form from what you say. Read your copy before you leave. For a written answer, use the current CIV-GP-58B form and complete its signed affirmation under penalties of perjury. Make two copies, give the original and one copy to the clerk, and keep one. The court’s instructions say the clerk provides the plaintiff’s copy.

Keep the case number and watch for a court date

Use the court and county shown on the summons. Bring all the papers even if you cannot find an index number. Keep your answer copy and any notices. Check the next date with the clerk after you answer. If you learn a judgment may already have been entered, ask the clerk how to get the court record and seek legal help about reopening the case.

Rules, exceptions and limits

These instructions apply to the Civil Court of the City of New York. If your papers name the Supreme Court, a District Court or a City Court outside New York City, start with that court’s instructions. The answer deadline concerns your response to a pending case. Any time limit on the plaintiff’s original lawsuit involves a separate legal question.

Sources

  1. New York State Senate · New York City Civil Court Act § 402
  2. New York City Civil Court · Answering a debt collection case
  3. New York City Civil Court · Written Answer Consumer Credit
  4. New York Courts · How to check for a civil default judgment
  5. New York courts · Current answer form
  6. New York CPLR 2106 · Affirmation

Sources checked November 16, 2026

Tell us what you owe. We’ll help you find the way through.

It takes about two minutes. Free to ask, no credit check, no obligation.

Get my options