Business operating debts · Page 2 of 3

Selected findings from library records with scoped primary-source review.

Research reference · Consumer guides and topic map

Plain-English guides on this topic

Canada BIA Division I proposal stay and relief exceptions

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

The pass verifies the listed federal statutory branches. Province-specific source-deduction law, individual security validity and priority, actual order terms, third-party enforcement, deadlines with calendar adjustments, and judicial gloss on material prejudice or public interest remain matters for file-specific verification. Companion passes cover lease disclaimer E189B, critical suppliers E189H, voting and approval E194A, and performance default/annulment E194E. A focused statutory pass does not establish whole-area acceptance. Hold C012 as materially imprecise. Effective replacement: If an insolvent corporation files a notice of intention under §50.4(1) or makes a proposal, §69.31(1) bars commencing or continuing an action against a director on a claim against directors that arose before BIA proceedings began and relates to corporate obligations for whose payment directors are liable under any law in their capacity as directors. The stay lasts until court approval of the proposal, if filed, or the corporation becomes bankrupt. It excludes actions on director guarantees relating to corporate obligations and actions seeking injunctive relief against a director in relation to the corporation. If all directors resign or are removed by shareholders without replacement, a person managing or supervising management of the corporation’s business and affairs is deemed a director. S09 lines 30–38 verified. Existing CCAA stay and eligible-contract coverage distinct.

  • An insolvent person’s filed notice of intention under s. 50.4 starts the s. 69 stay, which runs until the trustee files the proposal under s. 62(1) or the person becomes bankrupt. At filing of the proposal and prescribed statement of affairs with the official receiver, s. 69.1 takes effect. Its general creditor bar restricts remedies against the insolvent person or their property, and the commencement or continuation of recovery proceedings, for claims provable in bankruptcy until trustee discharge or bankruptcy, subject to statutory exceptions.

    section-62.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-69.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-69.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The notice and proposal stays also neutralize a secured agreement term that takes away rights to use or deal with collateral on insolvency, default under the security agreement or a specified filing. Separately, s. 62(1.1) measures proposal claims at the notice filing or, if there was no notice, the proposal filing, with an exception for environmental remediation claims under s. 14.06(8). If bankruptcy intervenes, consult the separate bankruptcy stay in s. 69.3 and its secured-creditor exceptions.

    section-62.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-69.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-69.3.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-69.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The notice track requires the cash-flow statement and prescribed trustee and debtor reports within ten days. Section 50.4(8) gives a deemed-assignment consequence for failure to comply with the cash-flow package or a failure to file the proposal in the 30-day filing period or an extension. The debtor applies before expiry for extensions of up to 45 days each, capped in aggregate at five months after expiry of the original 30 days. Good faith and due diligence, a likely viable proposal and absence of material prejudice to any creditor are each required.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The trustee, interim receiver if appointed, or a creditor can apply to terminate the period early. Any of the listed grounds may suffice: lack of good faith and due diligence, likelihood of no viable proposal by expiry, likelihood of no creditor-acceptable proposal by expiry, or material prejudice to creditors as a whole if the application is denied. An early termination invokes the deemed-assignment and related steps as if the period expired.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The notice and proposal provisions preserve specified enforcement routes. They cover collateral taken into possession for realization before the relevant filing, a s. 244(1) notice given more than ten days before the notice of intention (or before the proposal if there was no notice of intention) unless the secured creditor agrees to the stay, and s. 244(1) notice followed by the debtor’s s. 244(2) consent. For the possession branch, compare possession to the notice filing under s. 69(2)(a) and to the proposal filing under s. 69.1(2)(a).

    section-244.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-69.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-69.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 244(1) concerns enforcement covering all or substantially all of the specified inventory, receivables or other business-related property. Its ordinary minimum wait is ten days after sending notice, and early debtor consent must follow the sending. The notice section itself does not apply or ceases to apply for secured creditors protected under s. 69.1(5) or (6), after the specified s. 69.4 stay relief, or when there is a receiver in respect of the insolvent person.

    section-244.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • At the proposal stage, a creditor whose particular security was excluded from the proposal may deal with that security as otherwise entitled. The same rule applies from a secured class vote for refusal to holders of claims of that class. Both routes remain subject to ss. 79 and 127–135 and s. 248(1). Under s. 248(1), the court can direct compliance with duties in ss. 244–247 or restrain realization pending compliance where a duty was breached.

    section-248.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-69.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • An affected creditor under ss. 69–69.31, or another person affected by the director stay in s. 69.31, can ask for a declaration lifting the operation of those sections as to that applicant. The court may qualify the relief and needs likely material prejudice from continuation or another equitable ground for the declaration.

    section-69.4.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Separate stays govern the specified federal and provincial source-deduction and pension or employment-insurance collection routes in ss. 69(1)(c)–(d) and 69.1(1)(c)–(d). At proposal stage the provision lasts until trustee discharge, six months after court approval or bankruptcy, whichever occurs first, subject to earlier statutory loss. A default on a qualifying amount becoming due after the relevant filing, or another creditor’s entitlement to realize qualifying collateral, can remove the relevant stay for Canada and every province. If s. 69(3) disapplied or ended the notice-stage stay, proposal filing does not restore it.

    section-69.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-69.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 69.5 preserves the operation of analogous provincial collection provisions for the specified withholding or comprehensive pension-plan amounts and associated charges, subject to the express Crown stays. It gives those provisions the specified federal-equivalent effect and scope against creditors, including secured creditors.

    section-69.5.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • A qualifying regulatory investigation, action, suit or proceeding by or before the regulator generally continues through the notice and proposal stays, with enforcement of a payment ordered by the regulator or court outside that exception. The insolvent person may ask the court, with notice to the regulator and likely affected persons, to stay specified proceedings if without relief a viable proposal could not be made and applying the stay is consistent with the public-interest test. For a dispute over whether the regulator is acting as creditor, the insolvent person may seek a court declaration on notice to the regulator that the enforcement is stayed.

    section-69.6.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 69.41 excludes the claims defined in s. 121(4) from ss. 69–69.31. The covered support liability is payable under an order or agreement made before the initial bankruptcy event and at a time when the qualifying family member was living apart. After bankruptcy, remedies against vested estate property or amounts payable under s. 68 remain barred for that claimant.

    section-121.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-69.41.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For an eligible financial contract entered before the applicable first filing and terminated on or after it, s. 65.1(9) allows contract-authorized netting, set-off or compensation and dealings with financial collateral despite ss. 69(1) and 69.1(1). The counterparty owed a net termination value is deemed a creditor with a provable claim as to that value under ss. 69(1)(a) and 69.1(1)(a), so ordinary collection of the balance remains subject to the general stay and its exceptions. The prescribed categories include qualifying derivatives traded on a regulated market or recurrently dealt in specified markets.

    section-65.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal trustee duties and cash-flow reporting

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

Scoped to the federal statutory sequence and prescribed Forms 29, 30 and 34. Check actual court orders, filing timestamps, effective-date transitions, deadline computation, local filing practice, and what constitutes a material adverse change on specific facts. Detailed professional-conduct/licensing, post-approval default and discharge, stay exceptions, vote arithmetic, priority entitlement and a full CCAA monitor audit are outside this pass. The official BIA and CCAA consolidations accessed display October 19, 2026, and the General Rules page displays September 30, 2026. This is a research candidate pending separate review. Hold C015 as prior E194I extension coverage and C017 as prior E190G CCAA monitor duties. Retain C003, C012–C014 for distinct reports, package and forms; earlier filing clocks are context only. Official Rule 90 header derivative reconciles encoded comma alias. Individual deadlines held.

  • An insolvent person may file the prescribed notice of intention with the local official receiver before filing the proposal with a licensed trustee. The notice identifies the consenting licensed trustee by name and address, gives the listed information about known or recorded claims of at least $250, and includes the trustee’s written consent.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Within five days after filing, the named trustee must send a copy of the notice with the required information to every known creditor in the prescribed manner. The $250 amount applies to the list in the notice. The delivery obligation covers every known creditor.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Within ten days after the notice filing, the insolvent person files the package with the official receiver. The person prepares a projection on at least a monthly basis, the trustee reviews it for reasonableness, and both sign. The trustee prepares and signs the prescribed reasonableness report. The insolvent person prepares and signs the prescribed representations report.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • On the proposal route, the proposer first supplies the signed written proposal and prescribed statement of affairs to a licensed trustee in an insolvent-person case. The trustee files both with the official receiver. With that filing the trustee files the monthly-or-more-frequent projection (revised if a projection was filed under the notice provision), the trustee’s signed reasonableness report and the proposer’s signed representations. The proposer prepares the projection and signs it jointly with the trustee. For a proposal in respect of a bankrupt, the initial filing is with the trustee of the estate and inspectors’ approval is required before further action.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-62.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Current OSB Forms 29 and 30 are the trustee and proposer reports respectively. Form 29 describes inquiries, analytical procedures and discussions. The trustee checks hypothetical assumptions against the purpose of the projection, reviews support for probable assumptions and the presentation of the projection, and gives no assurance about achievement. Form 30 and Rule 90(2) address disclosure of assumptions, support and consistency of probable assumptions, reasonableness and purpose consistency of hypothetical assumptions, and the possibility of material actual variances.

    forms · ised-isde.canada.ca form-29-trustees-report-cash-flow- · ised-isde.canada.ca form-30-report-cash-flow-statement · ised-isde.canada.ca section-90.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • General Rule 90(1) requires the trustee to file copies of its enumerated documents with the court as soon as those documents are filed with the official receiver. The list includes the proposal, the notice, both stages’ cash-flow packages and official-receiver material-adverse-change reports, the proposal-stage business-and-financial-affairs report, and the creditors’ meeting notice.

    section-90.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • At either stage any creditor can request a copy of the applicable cash-flow statement from the trustee. A court can withhold all or part from some or all creditors if disclosure would unduly prejudice the debtor and withholding would not unduly prejudice the affected creditors. A trustee who acts in good faith and uses reasonable care in reviewing the statement is protected from liability for loss or damage resulting from another person’s reliance on it.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • From notice filing until proposal filing or bankruptcy, subject to court directions under s. 47.1(2)(a), the trustee accesses and examines property and records as needed to assess the business and finances. After ascertaining a material adverse change in projected cash flow or financial circumstances, the trustee files the state-of-affairs report, including any prescribed information, with the official receiver without delay and sends a report about the change to creditors without delay. The trustee reports to the court at or before the hearing of any s. 50.4(9) extension application and whenever else the court orders. In the notice-to-proposal interval the trustee also advises on and participates in preparation, including negotiations.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • From proposal filing until court approval or bankruptcy, subject to s. 47.1(2)(a) directions, the trustee continues the required examination and monitoring. On ascertaining a material adverse change, the trustee files the state-of-affairs report with the official receiver, including any prescribed information and sends a change report to creditors, both without delay. The trustee files the state-of-affairs report with the court whenever ordered. The ten-day pre-meeting report is a separate duty.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The court can direct an appointed interim receiver to perform the specified monitoring duties jointly with or in place of the trustee. Where the receiver substitutes for the trustee under s. 50(10), the receiver delivers its state-of-affairs report to the trustee at least 15 days before the s. 51(1) meeting. The trustee sends it to creditors and the official receiver in the prescribed manner at least ten days before the meeting.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The trustee appraises and investigates the debtor’s affairs and property, or arranges that work, sufficiently to estimate the financial position and causes of distress with reasonable accuracy, and reports the result to the creditors’ meeting. At least ten days before the meeting the trustee sends creditors and the official receiver the prescribed-manner state-of-affairs report, including any prescribed information and the trustee’s reasonableness opinion on any decision to exclude ss. 95–101 from the proposal.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The trustee calls the meeting for within 21 days after filing with the official receiver under s. 62(1), and at least ten days before it sends every known creditor and the official receiver the prescribed package. It includes meeting details, a condensed assets-and-liabilities statement, the list and amounts of recorded or known claims at least $250, the proposal, applicable blank forms if not already sent, and a voting letter. Where the prior meeting and substantially unchanged estate conditions apply, the trustee may omit the condensed statement and list. The official receiver or nominee chairs.

    section-51.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Following creditor acceptance, within five days the trustee applies to the court for a hearing appointment. At least 15 days before the hearing the trustee gives prescribed notice to the debtor, every creditor with a proved claim, the proposer and official receiver. At least ten days before the hearing the trustee sends its report to the official receiver, and at least two days before the hearing files the prescribed report with the court. Before approval, the court hears the report on proposal terms and the debtor’s conduct.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Failure to comply with the ten-day notice-stage package requirement, or failure to file the proposal within the initial 30-day period or a granted extension, engages the deemed-assignment mechanism. The trustee promptly files the prescribed report with the official receiver (Form 34, which calls for the extension order to be attached if one was granted) and, within five days after issuance of the certificate, sends notice of the s. 102 creditors’ meeting. The trustee, appointed interim receiver or a creditor may apply for early termination on the grounds in s. 50.4(11), which applies the same assignment and notification steps on a termination order.

    form-34-report-trustee-non-filing- · ised-isde.canada.ca fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Amounts payable under an approved proposal go to the trustee for distribution to creditors after payment of proper fees and expenses under s. 60(1). Section 60(1) requires the proposal to provide for priority payment of claims legally directed to be paid in priority and payment of the trustee’s proper fees and expenses.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I director stay under section 69.31

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

This correction addresses E194I-C012. Existing CCAA stay and eligible-contract coverage is distinct. Exact corrected replacement for held E194I-C012. Preserve liability under any law in director capacity for payment, filing trigger, court approval or bankruptcy endpoints, guarantee and injunction exclusions and deemed director rule. Original review remains intact.

  • If an insolvent corporation files a notice of intention under §50.4(1) or makes a proposal, §69.31(1) bars commencing or continuing an action against a director on a claim against directors that arose before BIA proceedings began and relates to corporate obligations for whose payment directors are liable under any law in their capacity as directors. The stay lasts until court approval of the proposal, if filed, or the corporation becomes bankrupt. It excludes actions on director guarantees relating to corporate obligations and actions seeking injunctive relief against a director in relation to the corporation. If all directors resign or are removed by shareholders without replacement, a person managing or supervising management of the corporation’s business and affairs is deemed a director.

    section-69.31.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal inspectors and trustee oversight

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

A specific inspector’s powers depend on the actual proposal terms and how the circumstances affect statutory applicability. No specific proposal or court order was reviewed. Section 54 creditor acceptance, subsection 50(10) trustee reporting, subsection 50(3) prior approval for a proposal made in respect of a bankrupt, and section 62.1 default waiver are contextual cross-references to neighboring passes E194A, E194M and E194E. They are outside the new claim set. Division II consumer proposals and a complete inventory of generally applicable trustee powers and inspector approval requirements remain outside this assignment. Distinct Division I inspector appointment and supervision. General BIA inspector duties map only where applicable and with necessary modifications and proposal terms. Preserve creditor resolution precedence and court review. Original native numbering preserved.

  • Creditors may appoint inspectors of the debtor’s estate under Division I. If they appoint inspectors, they may appoint one to five. Those inspectors have the powers of an inspector under the BIA, subject to extensions or restrictions in the proposal terms. Outside Division II of Part III, other BIA provisions apply only where applicable, with modifications the circumstances require.

    section-56.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • At a meeting to consider the proposal, creditors may include terms in the proposal governing supervision of the debtor’s affairs if the debtor consents.

    section-55.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The BIA’s general inspector duties include periodically checking the estate’s bank balance, examining the trustee’s accounts and looking into whether the trustee’s filed security is adequate. The statute also provides for inspector approval of the trustee’s final statement of receipts and disbursements, the dividend sheet and the disposition of unrealized property, subject to subsection 120(4). Before approval of the final statement, inspectors must satisfy themselves that all property is accounted for and that administration has proceeded as far as reasonably possible. They also determine whether disbursements and expenses are proper and authorized, and whether fees and remuneration are reasonable in the circumstances. Apply these duties in Division I where applicable, with necessary modifications and subject to the proposal’s terms.

    section-120.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-56.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The BIA’s general inspector rules require prior court approval before an inspector may purchase or acquire estate property, directly or indirectly, for themselves or someone else. The Division I applicability and proposal-term qualifications apply when mapping the general inspector rules to a proposal.

    section-120.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-56.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The general estate administration rule directs the trustee, subject to the BIA, to have regard to directions from inspectors and to directions adopted by creditor resolution at a general meeting. A conflicting creditor direction takes precedence. On request by the trustee or another interested person, the court may review an inspectors’ action or decision, revoke or vary it, substitute directions, permission or authority, or send the matter back for reconsideration. Section 119(1) is worded for bankruptcy property administration and distribution. Use the Division I applicability and proposal-term qualifications when mapping section 119 to a proposal.

    section-119.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-56.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal notices for the creditor meeting and court approval hearing

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

Distinct published OSB Forms 92 and 40.1, exact proof versus proxy/voting deadlines and Form 1.1 electronic details. Prior meeting and approval notice statutory rules retained as context for form-specific requirements.

  • The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy publishes Form 92 as the trustee’s notice to creditors under BIA section 51. It identifies the debtor who lodged the proposal and supplies the meeting date, time, and either the location or electronic participation details. It identifies the enclosed proposal copy, condensed assets-and-liabilities statement, and list of affected creditors with claims of at least $250. The threshold applies to the list. Section 51 requires sending the notice to every known creditor and the official receiver. Section 51(2) permits omission of the condensed statement and list if the required information was presented at a qualifying earlier meeting and the estate is substantially unchanged.

    form-92-notice-proposal-creditors · ised-isde.canada.ca page-9.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Form 92 says to lodge proofs of claim with the trustee before the meeting starts. Proxies and voting letters intended for the meeting may be filed up to the moment a vote is called. The form’s enclosure note lists a proof-of-claim form, a proxy form and a voting letter.

    form-92-notice-proposal-creditors · ised-isde.canada.ca

  • The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy publishes Form 40.1 as the trustee’s notice under BIA paragraph 58(b) of the hearing on an application to approve a proposal the creditors have accepted. It identifies the court and debtor, the city, date and time of the hearing, and the date of the meeting at which creditors accepted the proposal. Paragraph 58(b) requires sending the notice in the prescribed manner at least 15 days before the hearing to the debtor, every secured or unsecured creditor with a proved claim, the person making the proposal and the official receiver.

    form-401-notice-hearing-applicatio · ised-isde.canada.ca page-9.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Forms 92 and 40.1 require adding the sender’s name and contact information prescribed in Form 1.1 at the end when a copy is sent electronically, such as by email.

    form-401-notice-hearing-applicatio · ised-isde.canada.ca form-92-notice-proposal-creditors · ised-isde.canada.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal effects on secured and non-released claims

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E194A-C007–C011 already cover proof in unsecured capacity, valuation of secured and unsecured portions, class votes, binding effect and the two conditions for a section 178(1) debt to be released by the proposal. E194I-C002 and C005–C008 cover the insolvent-person claim date, stay, and secured-enforcement gateway. E192K-C007–C008 address parallel CCAA provisions. This pass adds BIA-specific cleanup proof and security, identified fraud-related liability categories, and acceptance effects for other liable persons. The approved proposal, order, accepted proofs, relevant ballots, collateral and surety documents are needed to tell which particular debts and parties remain liable. Actual fraud classification, whether a distinct release or order affects the surety, whether a regulatory obligation qualifies as a remediation cost claim, scope of environmental collateral and any independent basis for enforcement require case-specific evidence. Other section 178(1) categories and bankruptcy discharge procedures remain outside this pass. BIA Division I guarantee and environmental scope distinct from CCAA. C002 section 62(2.1) is prior context for exact BIA categories. C003 earlier filing baseline context only. Preserve qualifying Crown collateral and local enforcement, with individual coverage held. Original native numbering preserved.

  • A creditor’s acceptance of a Division I proposal does not itself release anyone whom the debtor’s discharge would leave liable under the BIA. Section 179 identifies a person who, at the time of bankruptcy, was a partner or co-trustee with the bankrupt, was jointly bound or had made a joint contract with the bankrupt, or was a surety or in the nature of a surety for the bankrupt. A creditor’s yes vote alone therefore does not release the debtor’s surety.

    section-179.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-62.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For business debts, the section 178(1) cross-reference includes liability arising from fraud, embezzlement, misappropriation or defalcation while acting in a fiduciary capacity or, in Quebec, as trustee or administrator of another’s property. It also includes debt or liability arising from obtaining property or services through false pretences or fraudulent misrepresentation, subject to the equity-claim exclusion in paragraph (e). Paragraph (h) includes interest owed in relation to those amounts. Those statutory categories feed into the particular-debt release test in section 62(2.1).

    section-178.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-62.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For a proposal made in respect of a bankrupt, claims normally are determined as of the date that person became bankrupt. The environmental cleanup cost exception in section 14.06(8) applies to that baseline as well as the separate filing-time baseline for an insolvent person. A claim against the debtor for the cost of remedying an environmental condition or damage affecting its real property or immovable is provable whether the condition arose or the damage occurred before or after the date of proposal filing or bankruptcy.

    section-14.06.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-62.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • In a proposal, a federal or provincial Crown claim for the cost of remedying an environmental condition or damage affecting the debtor’s real property or immovable carries statutory security on that property and on the debtor’s property that is both contiguous and related to the activity causing the condition or damage. That security ranks ahead of other claims, rights, charges and security against the affected collateral and is enforced under local law like a mortgage, hypothec or other real-property security. Establish the Crown’s claim and its security separately when checking whether a particular secured claim falls within section 62(2)(b).

    section-14.06.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-62.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I default notices and trustee duties after approval

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E194E-C001–C007 already cover default grounds, waiver, cure and notice times, the post-2009 Form 43 options and electronic identification, annulment and assignment consequences. E194M covers trustee duties up to approval and approved-payment distribution, E194U-C003 covers inspectors’ account-review duties and E194I-C001 covers the stay endpoint. E194Y covers the proposal and approval-stage form. This pass adds the trustee’s notice proof, the observed professional-conduct treatment, the final account trigger, taxation steps, and discharge and creditor objection process. Determine the application of the general estate procedures and form attachments with necessary modifications when there is no final dividend, no inspector, or the court directs another procedure. The court order, proposal terms, actual notice proof, approved accounts, creditor proofs and any local filing directions govern case-specific dates and obligations. The OSB post-2009 HTML Form 43 displays two options. A standalone OSB-hosted F43_EN.pdf surfaced in search with the discharge-without-annulment wording alone. The applicable cohort for that PDF and the identity of the current forms index’s post-2009 PDF target remain unverified. S12 is held for form-version reconciliation. Late cure, stay consequences and subsequent creditor remedies remain outside the new claims. Preserve Rule 93 and Form 43 as prior context. Distinct dispatch proof, 2024 file-specific disciplinary illustration, triggered final accounting, taxation, dividend and court discharge procedure. Timing and forms apply only as specified.

Canada BIA Division I duties after proposal annulment

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E194E-C004–C007 cover grounds, order and deemed-assignment consequences, section 63(5) dispatch within five days after the order, the immediate report and certificate, the official receiver’s copying and filing, and form numbers. E195I covers performance-default delivery and proof, the paragraph 66(1.2)(b) accounting trigger and proposal taxation/discharge. The current post-2009 index links for the Form 43.1 and Form 44 PDFs could not be fetched. Numbered alternate OSB PDF text is preserved as residual evidence, as the index links to different filenames and the PDF prevails. The OSB search excerpt for the post-2009 Form 44 HTML displays the same security, bankruptcy-notice and applicable meeting instructions as the alternate PDF, pending a numbered read of the indexed version. The Form 73 claim relies on the statute and indexed PDF. The 23R page says issued TBD and is retained as consultation text only. Case-specific ascertainment of the effective order and appointment dates, resulting form choices in a summary administration, overlap of the separate accounting triggers if accounts were already prepared, and local filing or publication directions remain open. Distinct ordinary bankruptcy steps following annulment. Deemed assignment and five-day dispatch already covered in E194E and retained as context. Preserve Form 43.2 property alternatives, dates from appointment versus order, summary exceptions and independent final account trigger.

  • Form 43.2 gives different property language for the court order depending on the debtor’s status. For an insolvent person, it names the trustee in whom the property vests following the deemed assignment. For a proposal by someone already bankrupt, it substitutes language revesting in the named trustee the property vested in the bankrupt under the proposal approval order. Read the signed order to establish the property direction in a particular estate.

    F43.2_EN.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca section-63.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For a first meeting under section 102 after Division I annulment, the trustee identifies the bankrupt’s creditors and sends the prescribed bankruptcy and meeting notice to the bankrupt, every known creditor and the Superintendent. Send a list showing claims of $25 or more and their amounts, a proof-of-claim form and an unnamed proxy. For an individual, include the required financial and section 68 payment information. Form 68 identifies the deemed assignment and trustee, sets out the meeting details and tells creditors to file proof of claim and any necessary proxy before the meeting to vote.

    Form68.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca section-102.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-63.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For an ordinary estate, section 102 sets the first meeting within 21 days following the day of the trustee’s appointment. The local official receiver may extend the meeting window by 10 days, or by up to 30 days where special circumstances exist, if satisfied the extension will not harm creditors and serves the administration. The trustee publishes Form 73 in a local newspaper as soon as possible after bankruptcy and no later than five days before the meeting. Summary administration has separate rules for calling a meeting and for newspaper publication.

    Form73.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca section-102.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-155.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-63.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The ordinary bankruptcy trustee gives security to the official receiver upon appointment, in cash or by a qualifying bond or suretyship, in favour of creditors generally. The official receiver can adjust it. For a summary administration the section 16 security is required only if the official receiver directs it.

    section-155.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-16.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The deemed assignment following a Division I annulment falls within the independent assignment trigger for the proposal trustee’s duty to prepare the final statement of receipts and disbursements without delay. The statute separately identifies the trustee’s earlier notice of performance default to creditors and the official receiver as its own trigger.

    section-63.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal property control and disposition

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E194M-C009 already covers the end of monitoring access under subsection 50(10), and E194M-C016 covers the subsection 60(2) remittance rule. E194U-C001–C005 cover inspectors, consensual supervision terms and applicable bankruptcy inspector powers. E194I covers the stay, neutralization of specified security-agreement terms and the distinct gateways to creditor enforcement. E194A/E195E cover claim and security treatment and E194E/E195M cover the separate annulment and resulting bankruptcy. E189Y addresses CCAA section 36 and supplies no BIA authority. For an approved proposal, obtain the signed approval order, incorporated proposal and amendments, schedules or actual conveyance, any separate sale or vesting order, and security agreements and registration/title evidence before asserting who may control, sell, or retain proceeds from a particular asset. The text of section 65.13 specifies filing triggers and sets out the authorization route. Whether an unlisted later transaction after court approval falls under that section, needs a new order or is already authorized depends on the actual transaction, posture and applicable authority. No post-approval case or order was authenticated for that question. Keep that point unresolved, together with asset-specific ownership and proceeds routing, application of pension transition rules, valuation, priority and account-specific terms. Ordinary-course classification, transfer formalities and separate court authority or receiver appointments remain file-specific. Other registered property-law and federal/provincial priorities remain outside this statutory pass. Distinct BIA Division I property, receiver endpoints, distribution in kind and sales. Related CCAA sale and BIA trustee payment rules are context. Preserve approval exception and source qualifications. No verified later post-approval transaction authority or particular vesting result.

  • A bankruptcy order or filed assignment generally vests the bankrupt’s property in the bankruptcy trustee, subject to the Act and secured creditors’ rights. When the court approves a proposal made after bankruptcy, the approval annuls that bankruptcy and revests the trustee’s right, title and interest in the debtor’s property in the debtor or another person the court approves, unless the proposal terms provide otherwise. The trigger is approval of a proposal made after bankruptcy.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • After a notice of intention or proposal filing, a court may appoint the proposal trustee, another trustee, or both jointly as interim receiver over specified property if the appointment is shown necessary to protect the estate or the interests of one or more creditors. Court directions may confer possession, control of the covered property and business, conservatory measures and summary disposition of perishable or rapidly depreciating property. The appointment expires at the earliest of court approval of the proposal, statutory-receiver possession of covered property, or trustee possession of covered property. Check any asserted authority after approval against its own legal basis and order.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • If the proposal provides for distribution of the debtor’s promissory notes or other evidence of obligations by or on behalf of the debtor, or a corporate debtor’s own shares, the property is handled as nearly as possible in the same manner as money paid to the trustee and distributed by the trustee after proper fees and expenses. Section 147 applies to the trustee’s distributions under both provisions. This distribution rule addresses the listed property when the proposal provides for its distribution.

    fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 65.13 requires court authorization for a sale or other disposition outside the ordinary course of business by an insolvent person for whom a notice of intention under section 50.4 or a proposal under subsection 62(1) is filed. A court may authorize the transaction even without otherwise required shareholder approval. For an individual carrying on business, the court’s authorization is limited to assets acquired for or used in relation to the business. An insolvent person applying must notify secured creditors likely to be affected.

    section-65.13.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca fulltext.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The court considers a nonexhaustive list that includes reasonableness of the sale process, trustee approval of that process, whether the trustee filed a court report opining that the sale is more beneficial to creditors than a bankruptcy sale, the extent of creditor consultation, effects on creditors and other interested parties, and fair and reasonable consideration having regard to market value.

    section-65.13.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For a related-person transaction, after considering subsection (4), the court may authorize only if satisfied that good-faith efforts were made to sell or otherwise dispose of the assets to unrelated persons and that the proposed consideration is superior to that of every other offer made through the process. The statutory class includes directors and officers, current or former direct or indirect controllers in fact, and persons related to those groups.

    section-65.13.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • If the court approves the sale or disposition free and clear of a security, charge or other restriction, it must also order that other assets of the insolvent person or the proceeds be subject to a security, charge or other restriction in favour of the creditor affected by the order.

    section-65.13.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For the statutory sale authorization, the court must be satisfied that the insolvent person can and will make the employee and prescribed-pension payments that paragraphs 60(1.3)(a) and (1.5)(a) would have required had the court approved the proposal. The monetary inputs and any transitional pension treatment depend on the applicable employer and plan facts.

    section-65.13.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • If an agreement in place on a specified notice-of-intention or proposal filing day grants another party use of IP included in a subsection (7) disposition, the sale leaves that party’s use right in place, including the right to enforce exclusivity, for the agreement term and periods extended as of right, so long as that party continues to perform its obligations in relation to IP use.

    section-65.13.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal approval safeguards

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E194A-C014 already covers the mandatory reasonableness and general-creditor-benefit test in the first limb of subsection 59(2). E194M-C013 and E194Y-C003 cover section 58 and the trustee’s report, timing and hearing notice. E194M-C016 covers subsection 60(1) and trustee payments under subsection 60(2). E195Q covers post-approval property consequences and asset-sale wage and pension protections under section 65.13. E190O’s analogous rules govern CCAA sanction. E194E, E195I and E195M cover later default or annulment. The exact prior scope screen used the R029 queue, R029 and adjacent C_CA findings and pending R029 candidate findings. For a specific approval, obtain the signed order and incorporated proposal, any section 173 finding and court-directed percentage, and evidence of the value and enforceability of security. Obtain the Crown’s written consent where relied upon and verify the underlying remittance category, filing dates, due dates, and payments or defaults. Wage amounts require employment and payroll evidence and the applicable underlying paragraph 136(1)(d) rules. A general power to approve proposals on court-imposed conditions outside these express provisions, procedural practice in a specific court, the treatment of any particular cost, and pension-plan approval and transition issues remain unresolved in this pass. Section 59(1) participants are distinct from section 58 report and notice mechanics previously covered. The section 59(2) offence ground is discretionary and distinct from the mandatory general-benefit and reasonableness test. Verified $100,000 × 50% = $50,000 assuming no court-directed percentage. Security must still be reasonable. Approval conditions are confined to the specified statutory gates. Pension transition, general conditioning authority, application to a given employer or remittance, and allowance of particular trustee costs were not determined.

  • Before approval, in addition to receiving the trustee’s prescribed report, the court must hear the trustee, debtor, person making the proposal, any opposing, objecting or dissenting creditor, and any further evidence it requires.

    section-59.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The court may refuse approval if it is established that the debtor committed any offence mentioned in sections 198 to 200.

    section-59.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • If a fact mentioned in section 173 is proved against the debtor, the court must refuse approval unless the proposal provides reasonable security for payment on all provable unsecured claims against the debtor’s estate. The statutory benchmark is at least 50 cents on the dollar or the percentage directed by the court. The section 173 list includes deficient business records as defined there, continued trading after awareness of insolvency, failure to account satisfactorily for loss or deficiency of assets, previous bankruptcy or a prior proposal, and fraud or fraudulent breach of trust.

    section-173.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-59.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • On approving the proposal, the court may order an amendment to the debtor’s constating instrument that accords with the proposal and reflects a change permitted by federal or provincial law.

    section-59.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Unless the Crown consents, the proposal must provide for full payment to the federal or provincial Crown within six months after approval of listed amounts outstanding when the notice of intention was filed, or when the proposal was filed if there was no such notice. The rule reaches amounts of a kind collectable under the listed demand provisions, covering Income Tax Act subsection 224(1.2), specified Canada Pension Plan and Employment Insurance Act collection provisions, and qualifying provincial provisions within paragraph (c).

    section-60.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The court must refuse approval if at the approval hearing the federal or provincial Crown establishes that the debtor is in default on a subsection 60(1.1) remittance that fell due after filing the notice of intention, or after filing the proposal where no notice was filed.

    section-60.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For an employer proposal, the court must be satisfied that the employer can and will make the prescribed payments immediately after approval. The proposal must provide current and former employees at least the amounts they would qualify for under paragraph 136(1)(d) if the employer became bankrupt on the notice-of-intention filing date or, absent notice, the proposal filing date. It must also cover wages, salaries, commissions or compensation for services rendered after that date and before approval, plus qualifying travelling salespersons’ disbursements in the same period. A person has no claim for those amounts for voting on questions relating to the employer proposal.

    section-60.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • If the court refuses approval, costs the debtor incurred on or incidental to the approval application cannot be allowed out of the debtor’s estate. The provision excepts costs incurred by the trustee from that prohibition.

    section-61.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I prescribed pension approval and transition

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E195U covers the other approval safeguards and expressly defers pension approval and transition. E195Q-C008 covers the section 65.13(8) asset-sale cross-reference and leaves its transition application open. E190O-C007 and E191M-C004 already record the CCAA transition in section 7(2), and E191M separately covers CCAA wage and pension payment conditions. This pass adds the BIA employer exception in section 7(1), the Division I baseline and additions, and source verification of their valuation benchmark. The case-specific application remains open for proposals that straddle April 27, 2027, including a notice of intention or proposal filed before the anniversary with approval after it. The text uses separate participation, amendment-application and deficit-measurement concepts. No controlling decision or order was authenticated for the straddling case. Also unresolved are predecessor or successor identity, sponsor or plan changes, applicable provincial funding or special relief provisions, actual arrears and actuarial amounts, any overlapping amounts and whether a particular regulator-approved agreement and court order apply. Obtain the April 26, 2023 plan participation and regulatory record, any succession or replacement-plan records, notice-of-intention and proposal filing records, plan valuations and contribution schedule, evidence of amounts paid and unpaid, any relevant regulator’s written approval and the signed approval order with the incorporated proposal. A returned English search extract attributed to Justice Laws annual HTML presented the CCAA-style proceedings-commencement wording for the other-plan clause. Fresh numbered annual HTML, the bilingual annual statute PDF, parliamentary Royal Assent text and the BIA consolidation all give the filing date wording. The search extract is preserved for provenance and carries no claim. Assent April 27, 2023, prior-day participation April 26, 2023, and fourth anniversary April 27, 2027 verified. The harmonized English and French enactment places the clause (A.2) benchmark at the notice-of-intention or fallback proposal filing. The CCAA analogue is prior context. Straddling cases, plan succession, actuarial amounts and regulator approval require case evidence. S05 review derivative normalizes only the displayed official URL wrapper.

  • The Pension Protection Act, S.C. 2023, c. 6, received royal assent and came into force on April 27, 2023. The Act supplies no separate commencement date. The federal Interpretation Act provides the assent-date default, and the official Table of Public Statutes records commencement on assent.

    P.pdf · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-6.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca page-1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca royal-assent · www.parl.ca

  • Section 7(1) delays application of PPA sections 2 to 4 to an employer who participated in a prescribed pension plan for its employees on April 26, 2023, until the fourth anniversary of commencement, April 27, 2027. Section 2 adds the Division I approval amounts. Sections 3 and 4 amend the separate BIA bankruptcy and receivership provisions. An employer outside the day-before participation exception has no section 7(1) deferral, subject to otherwise meeting the approval provision’s conditions. The timing rule for CCAA companies is in section 7(2).

    P.pdf · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca royal-assent · www.parl.ca

  • General Rules section 59.1(a) prescribes pension plans regulated by an Act of Parliament or of a provincial legislature for BIA subsection 60(1.5). Through the section 7(1) transition, the pre-amendment approval requirements continue to apply where the employer participates in such a plan for its employees. The proposal must provide for the covered unpaid amounts and the court must be satisfied the employer can and will pay them. The baseline includes payroll deductions, normal cost, defined-contribution amounts and the specified pooled-plan amounts, as applicable. For other prescribed plans the employer amounts are tested on the federal statutory bases specified in clauses (A), (B) and (C).

    section-60-20121214.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-59.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca royal-assent · www.parl.ca

  • When the amendments apply, clauses 60(1.5)(a)(ii)(A.1) and (A.2) add the applicable unpaid special payments required under section 9 of the Pension Benefits Standards Regulations, 1985 to liquidate an unfunded liability or solvency deficiency, and the amount needed to liquidate any other unfunded liability or solvency deficiency. The latter is determined at notice-of-intention filing, or proposal filing if no notice of intention was filed.

    section-60.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca royal-assent · www.parl.ca

  • When the amendments apply, clause 60(1.5)(a)(iii)(A.1) uses the special payments that would have been required under the federal Regulations if the plan were federally regulated. Clause (A.2) measures the other unfunded liability or solvency deficiency at notice-of-intention filing, or proposal filing if no notice of intention was filed. The English and French annual statute PDF, Parliament’s Royal Assent text and the numbered Justice Laws materials agree on that filing benchmark.

    2023_6.pdf · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-60.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca royal-assent · www.parl.ca

  • Under subsection 60(1.6), the court may approve a proposal that omits payment of the subsection 60(1.5) amounts if satisfied that the relevant parties entered into an agreement respecting their payment and that the relevant pension regulator approved that agreement.

    section-60-20121214.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-60.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada Division I and the federal distressed pension plan workout safeguards

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E195Y-C006 established the BIA court exception and E195Y left case-specific regulator approvals open. No active retirement enactment or official regulator instruction expressly establishing a separate approval route for subsection 60(1.6) was authenticated in this pass. The Nova Scotia clause is a direct but unproclaimed lead. The fresh R029 evidence concerns the federal workout election timing, representative appointments, payment deferral and acceleration, and the objection and funding-schedule approvals. No reported decision or signed approval establishing that a federal workout schedule also satisfies subsection 60(1.6) was authenticated. A live file requires plan registration and eligibility, dated election and insolvency filings, representative orders, contribution and payment records, disclosed proposed agreement and objection tabulations, the signed agreement, approval decision and funding schedule, plus any regulator approval and proposal court order under subsection 60(1.6). The April 2027 transition issue remains as recorded in E195Y. The captured Nova Scotia sources exclude section 111 and its heading from the verified commencement proclamation. The federal PBSA workout is a separate process. Ministerial approval remains discretionary and requires the Superintendent’s regulatory-compliance opinion. Exactly one third of beneficiaries objecting blocks submission even if the member threshold is satisfied. The prescribed periods are 30 and 40 days from disclosure and 15 days from the close of the 40-day period. E195Y-C006 is context for the distinct BIA subsection 60(1.6) court exception. A federal workout approval satisfying that exception in a given case remains unverified.

  • Nova Scotia enacted a provision specifically empowering its Superintendent to approve an agreement by the relevant parties on the subsection 60(1.5) payments for a BIA proposal. The 2015 proclamation excluded section 111 and its preceding heading. The Legislature’s April 1, 2025 consolidation lists them as unproclaimed, and no later proclamation was verified. The enacted clause therefore supplies no verified operative approval route.

    ma0115.pdf · novascotia.ca pension%20benefits.pdf · nslegislature.ca

  • For an eligible federally regulated defined benefit plan outside the multi-employer category, the declaration may identify existing BIA Part III proceedings as the basis for election. Liquidation in progress, an assignment, bankruptcy or a full plan termination bars an election. Liquidation, assignment or bankruptcy also ends an existing negotiation period and prevents its extension. The scheme does not apply to an employer who is a federal Crown agent.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The statutory deferral reaches otherwise-due payments during negotiations to the extent specified in the declaration, except normal cost and employee deductions. If the employer becomes subject to BIA Part III during negotiations, deferred payments and interest become due immediately. The subsection 29.07(1)–(3) regime is inapplicable when the employer is already in Part III at election.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • After filing the election declaration, the employer must promptly apply for appointment of exclusive negotiating representatives for beneficiaries and any non-unionized members. In a Part III proceeding the application goes to the court in which the notice of intention or proposal was filed. The employer bears the application costs.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • A proposed schedule excludes amounts due before negotiations began and normal cost. A representative other than a bargaining agent may consent only if fewer than one third of the people they represent object within the prescribed 30 days. To submit the funding schedule to the Minister, fewer than one third of members and fewer than one third of beneficiaries must object within the prescribed 40 days, and the request must be submitted within 15 days after that window. The Minister approves the funding schedule subject to the Superintendent’s opinion on regulatory compliance. Any reliance on the Division I court exception requires evidence satisfying BIA subsection 60(1.6) in the particular case.

    section-60.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada Division I proposal examination and statutory oversight safeguards

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

The statutory pre-approval examination is separate from the previously verified Division I proposal-approval hearing, trustee reporting or court-appointed interim receiver. E194M covers trustee diligence and reporting, E194U covers inspector oversight, E195Q covers court-directed property control, and E195U covers conditional court approval. This pass does not determine who must personally attend for a corporate debtor in a given file, the method or timing of service under Rule 117, or the consequences of nonattendance in a particular proceeding. A case-specific application requires the filing and examination dates, any notice and attendance record, meeting date, and approval or bankruptcy date. No specific trustee complaint, investigation, written conservatory direction, delegation or discipline decision was authenticated. Determine any operative measure from its own signed instrument, statutory ground, scope and date. The scope of the prescribed retention period or fee, and whether a particular document was entered into the public record, remain open. The official receiver examination uses BIA sections 66(1), 66(1.3) and 161 as applicable to Division I. Trustee diligence, inspectors, court property control and approval hearings remain prior coverage. A complaint does not itself trigger a conservatory direction. An actual inquiry, qualifying circumstances and the issued direction control. Corporate attendance, Rule 117 service, nonattendance consequences, specific investigation or discipline, and public record retention and fees remain unverified.

  • The official receiver is deemed an officer of the court. For a person in respect of whom a notice of intention under section 50.4 or a proposal under subsection 62(1) is filed, the subsection 161(1) examination under oath is held on attendance before the court approves the proposal or the person becomes bankrupt. The applicable examination concerns the debtor’s conduct, the causes of insolvency and what happened to the debtor’s property. The official receiver uses the prescribed questions or equivalent questions and may ask further questions.

    form_26_eng.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca section-12.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-161.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For an individual debtor, OSB Form 25 identifies the proposal and communicates the requirement to attend the examination at the date, time and place or video conference stated in the notice. Form 26 calls for recording the questions and answers on a sheet attached to the form. To the extent applicable to the Division I proposal under subsection 66(1), section 161 requires the official receiver to make a record and send it to the Superintendent and trustee. If the examination precedes the first creditors’ meeting, the record is communicated to creditors at the meeting. If the examination follows that meeting, it is made available to a creditor on request.

    form_25_2023.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca form_26_eng.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca section-161.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The Superintendent supervises administration of all estates and matters under the BIA, encompassing Division I proposal matters. The Superintendent can initiate an inquiry or investigation considered appropriate, including into trustee conduct, and the Superintendent or an appointed investigator can access, examine and copy relevant records including electronic data. The Superintendent receives and records complaints from creditors and other persons interested in an estate and determines which specific complaint investigations to conduct.

    section-5.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • If a circumstance in subsection 14.03(2) exists, including an inquiry or investigation under paragraph 5(3)(e), the Superintendent may issue directions to protect an estate, creditor rights or the debtor. The directions can arrange estate property handling or continued administration, preserve estate records, restrict bank or other depository payouts of estate funds, or prevent the official receiver from appointing the trustee to new estates until a decision under subsection 13.2(5) or 14.01(1). A direction must state its statutory authority, binds its recipient and is conclusive proof of its stated facts in the recipient’s favour. The recipient’s protection from liability covers acts done solely to comply.

    section-14.03.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • After an inquiry or investigation into trustee conduct, the Superintendent can act on apparent improper performance or estate management, noncompliance of the kind specified in paragraph 14.01(1)(b), or public interest grounds. Available measures include licence suspension or cancellation, licence conditions or limits, restitution to the estate for money it lost due to the trustee’s conduct, and action the trustee agrees to take and the Superintendent considers appropriate. Before deciding whether to exercise those disciplinary powers, the Superintendent must give the trustee written notice of the contemplated powers and reasons, and a reasonable opportunity for a hearing. The hearing and record are public subject to the statutory balancing exception. After a hearing, the written public decision and reasons are due to the trustee within three months after it concludes and the decision may be reviewed under the Federal Courts Act.

    section-14.01.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-14.02.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The Superintendent must keep a public record that includes proposals for the prescribed period and provide information contained in that record on request, subject to any prescribed fee. The separate authority to keep other records under subsection 11.1(2) does not make those records part of the public proposal record.

    section-11.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada Division I proposal examination notice and nonattendance

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E196G already covers examination timing, the examination record and statutory oversight. This pass addresses prescribed notice, delivery, the corporate addressee, and nonattendance safeguards. Hold any case-specific conclusion about timely receipt or sending, the designated corporate representative, the validity of a warrant, liability, or the effect of nonattendance on proposal approval. Verify the filing dates, operative form, designation if relevant, delivery evidence, specified date and venue, applicable court orders, application and any actual warrant or judgment. Hold the applicable conduct-money and witness-fee amount, local court procedure, and any case-law conclusion treating Form 24 or 25 as a served appointment or summons for section 166. The two statutory warrant branches have distinct predicates. Rule 117 sends the prescribed notice before a section 159 or 161 examination. Rule 6 distinguishes four-day receipt from ten-day sending, with the Rule 4 short-period rule and court exceptions. Form 24 and Form 25 identify their distinct addressees. Division I application of bankruptcy-based sections 159, 166 and 198(2) remains subject to section 66(1) and required adaptations. The two warrant branches retain their distinct predicates. No case-specific designation, proper service, fee tender, criminal liability or proposal consequence verified. S02 review files preserve original numbers and normalize the official redirect wrapper only.

Canada Division I proposal proof adjudication and appeal

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E194A covers voting eligibility, thresholds, classes and proof in the secured-vote context. E194M covers the trustee’s filing, meeting and distribution duties. E194U covers the inspector role. E190S addresses the separate CCAA claims protocol. The R029 findings screen found no earlier coverage of the section 135 adjudication and appeal, Rule 113 or Form 77. File-specific service, any applicable deeming rule, the appeal deadline, local filing and service procedure and the standard or result of review require the operative notice, delivery evidence, local procedure and relevant orders or authorities. Rule 113 establishes permissible methods. Subsection 135(4) identifies service as the trigger. The sources establish the statutory timetable and on-time extension-application route. Any argument based on general extension powers, a defective notice, lack of notice or late relief requires separate case-law and court-file review. A voting objection or an ongoing appeal may raise separate questions for the vote or distributions under the actual proposal and court orders. Section 66(1) applies the Act as applicable and with required modifications. Rule 113 governs the prescribed notice and subsection 135(4) measures 30 days from service, including when an extension application must be made. Deeming, late relief and case-specific mechanics remain open. E194A covers general meeting disputes. The section 108 voting treatment and its distinction from adjudication are new here. The General Rules review files preserve original numbers and normalize the official redirect wrapper.

Canada Division I proposal secured proof, surrender, redemption and valuation adjustment

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E194A covers the secured-class vote, including the separate court application to revise a proposed assessed value under subsection 50.1(4). E195E covers security and release upon approval. E195I and E195M cover default and bankruptcy pathways. E196N covers section 135 adjudication and appeal. The R029 scope screen found no prior dedicated treatment of realization or whole-claim surrender under section 127, the sections 128–130 redemption and election procedure or the sections 131–132 correction and distribution consequences. The statutory bridge establishes proof mechanics. Application of trustee powers in a live proposal depends on the particular collateral and the trustee’s authority or interest under subsection 66(1), including the operative proposal and court orders, enforcement stays, and security and ownership documents. The section 130 vesting clause is limited to interests actually vested in the trustee. A section 128(1.1) disposition requires court leave and case-specific evidence of valid service and timing. The official Form 76 search result identified the subsection 128(1) notice but its numbered page retrieval timed out. The packet grounds service and the conditional sale remedy in the Act. The operative notice wording, permitted service method in context and any proposed adaptations to Form 76 remain to be verified for use in a proposal. The record does not determine net sale proceeds, security validity or priority, sufficient evidence of a valuation mistake or later change, any prior trustee election, available dividend funds, or the effect of an actual amended proof on a past vote. Those questions require the relevant proof, collateral and realization records, election and service evidence, proposal terms and orders, and where necessary case law. E194A supplies context on inclusion and voting. The express general-creditor proof bridge to sections 124–134, the included-claim and subsequent bankruptcy boundaries, and the valuation, surrender, redemption and correction mechanics support the distinct scope. Example checked: $100,000 less $65,000 is $35,000, and less $60,000 net realization is $40,000. Surrender may permit proof of the full $100,000. These are proof bases. Case-specific distributions and trustee powers depend on actual proposal terms, court orders and collateral. Form 76 implementation remains unverified.

  • Paragraph 50(1.6)(b) expressly points to sections 124–134 for a secured creditor proving under the Division I proposal made to creditors generally, subject to section 50.1 for included secured claims. Subsection 50(1.7) treats that creditor and proved claim as included in later Division I references to unsecured creditors and claims. Subsection 66(1) applies the rest of the Act outside Division II of Part III only as applicable and with the necessary modifications.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 50.1 provides an included creditor a prescribed proof route for the particular secured claim, expressly applying sections 124–126 as applicable with necessary modifications. Section 50.2 bars the proof of secured claim for a particular claim outside the secured proposal. If the insolvent proposer later becomes bankrupt after making the proposal to one or more secured creditors on secured claims, section 50.3 ends the effectiveness of any section 50.1 proof and applies sections 112 and 127–134 to a secured creditor’s proof in the bankruptcy.

    FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 127 allows proof of the balance after deduction of net realization proceeds, or proof of the whole claim when the creditor surrenders its security to the trustee for creditors’ general benefit. When the creditor retains the security, subsection 128(2) limits the dividend to the balance after deducting the assessed value of that security.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Subsection 128(1) allows a trustee aware of potentially encumbered property to serve prescribed notice requiring a prescribed proof with full particulars, the date the security was given and the person’s assessed value. When a duly served recipient fails to file proof within 30 days after the day of service, subsection 128(1.1) permits a sale or disposition free of the security with court leave, where that provision applies. OSB Form 31 section 6C records the secured claim, collateral value and security particulars. The OSB directions call for copies of the security and registration documents. Its version instructions use the new form for estates filed on or after September 16, 2024, and the pre-2024 form for earlier filings.

    form-31-proof-of-claim-new · ised-isde.canada.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca instructions-completing-form-31-pr · www.ised-isde.canada.ca form-31-proof-of-claim-new · www.ised-isde.canada.ca FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Where applicable, subsection 128(3) permits trustee redemption by paying the debt or the creditor’s assessed security value in the proof. Under section 129, a trustee dissatisfied with the assessment may require a sale offer on terms and timing agreed with the creditor or directed by the court. Section 130 lets the creditor give written notice requiring the trustee to elect redemption or realization. If the trustee fails to communicate a written election to exercise the power within one month of receiving that notice or the further time allowed by the court, the power is lost, any redemption equity or other interest vested in the trustee passes to the creditor, and the assessed value reduces the claim.

    section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 131 substitutes net realization proceeds for the earlier creditor valuation when the creditor later realizes the security or it is realized under section 129. Under section 132, if the trustee has yet to elect acquisition, the creditor may amend its valuation and proof by satisfying the trustee or court that the original estimate was a good-faith mistake or that the security’s value later rose or fell. The provision calls for amendment at the creditor’s cost on court-ordered terms unless the trustee permits it without court application. Amending under section 132 requires prompt repayment of any excess dividend, or allows a shortfall to be caught up from available dividend funds ahead of future dividends without disturbing distributions of dividends declared before filing the amendment.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 133 excludes a secured creditor from dividends for noncompliance with sections 127–132. Section 134 caps the recovery at full payment plus interest as provided by the Act, subject to section 130. In a Division I proposal, apply these rules through the general-creditor proof route and check the proposal and any operative orders for the distribution actually payable.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada Division I commercial lease disclaimer notice and bankruptcy transitions

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

R029 E189B already covers the filing window, notice periods, viability exception, rule 95 delivery methods, proof basis and class treatment under subsections 65.2(1)–(7). E189H covers continuity and immediate payment, E189S covers CCAA agreement disclaimer and E195I/E195M cover general Division I default and annulment. The distinct coverage here is the Form 45 particulars and boundary with Form 44.1, the applicable procedural limits, the two bankruptcy transitions and the preserved provincial-law rule. The source review determines no case-specific date of valid delivery, permitted court filing method, holiday deadline adjustment, extension, required proof of electronic consent or evidentiary sufficiency on viability. Check the service record, applicable time-computation law, court rules and orders. The 15-day period uses the day the lessor was given notice as its trigger. The packet does not decide the validity of any bankruptcy surrender, disclaimer or resiliation, entitlement to accelerated rent, provincial lessor rights, or actual bankruptcy priority or recovery. The $45,000 calculation assumes an otherwise allowable claim and payment for the same losses. Consumer proposals, CCAA and unconnected third-party guarantees are outside the pass. E189B already covers the filing window, periods, delivery, viability exception and classification. C001 adds Form 45 particulars and C002 adds the procedural and time-computation boundary. Sections 65.21 and 65.22 concern distinct bankruptcy transitions. $60,000 less $15,000 actually paid for the same losses gives $45,000 before priority. This assumes an otherwise allowable loss claim. Local timing, valid delivery and provincial lessor rights remain open. General Rules pins use review-sealed copies that normalize only the publisher redirect wrapper.

  • The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy publishes Form 45 for the commercial lessee’s notice to the lessor. The form records the NOI or proposal filing and filing date, lessor, date the lease was signed, property address, effective date of disclaimer or resiliation, and commercial tenant’s dated signature. It sets out the lessor’s application right and the viable-proposal test covering the lease and all other leases disclaimed or resiliated under subsection 65.2(1). The filing window is between the NOI and the proposal or on filing the proposal. The 30-day disclaimer notice and the 15-day period to apply after being given notice serve different purposes.

    forms · ised-isde.canada.ca form-45-notice-lessor-disclaim-or- · ised-isde.canada.ca section-65.2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Rule 95 permits service, registered mail, courier or electronic transmission with the recipient’s agreement. The lessor applies for a declaration that subsection 65.2(1) does not apply to the lease. The court directs which parties receive notice and must grant the declaration unless satisfied that the insolvent person could not make a viable proposal without the specified disclaimers or resiliations. For court procedure that the BIA and General Rules leave open, rule 3 applies the court’s ordinary local procedure to the extent consistent with both. Rule 4’s exclusion of Saturdays and holidays applies to periods shorter than six days, so it does not exclude intervening Saturdays and holidays from the 15- and 30-day periods on that basis.

    section-65.2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca page-4.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • A lease within subsection 65.2(1) is expressly excluded from the general agreement mechanism by paragraph 65.11(10)(b). Use the commercial-tenant Form 45 for this route. The OSB lists Form 44.1 for the general agreement notice. A real-property or immovable lease where the debtor is the lessor is separately excluded from section 65.11 by paragraph 65.11(10)(e). Section 65.2(1) addresses the debtor as commercial lessee.

    forms · ised-isde.canada.ca section-65.11.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-65.2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • If a proposal concerns a bankrupt commercial lessee of real property or an immovable and its lease has been surrendered, disclaimed or resiliated in the bankruptcy proceedings, section 65.21 expressly carries over subsections 65.2(3)–(7) as if the lessee were an insolvent person to whom the disclaimer or resiliation provisions applied. The incorporated range includes the viability provision, proposal claim treatment, classification, vote by proved amount and class determination. The cross-reference begins at subsection (3), so it does not itself carry over the advance notice and application mechanism in subsections (1) and (2) to the bankruptcy surrender, disclaimer or resiliation.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-65.2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • If the lessee used subsection 65.2(1) and becomes bankrupt after the court approved the proposal but before full performance, section 65.22 reduces the lessor’s claim for resulting losses by the compensation actually paid under the proposal for those losses. Its wording includes any claim for accelerated rent. This adjustment does not establish whether accelerated rent is independently recoverable or its ranking. Subsection 65.2(8) preserves section 146 in bankruptcy. Section 146 refers lessor rights to the law of the province where the premises are located, subject to the ranking under section 136, subsection 73(4) and section 84.1.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-146.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-65.2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada Division I proposal court-ordered assignment of agreements

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

R029 E190C already covers CCAA section 11.3 assignment. E189S covers CCAA disclaimer, E189B and E196W address the distinct commercial lease disclaimer route and E189H addresses continuity and immediate payment. This pass is limited to section 66’s Division I incorporation and the procedural consequences of using it. Section 84.1 appears in E196W as a cross-reference in the section 146 lessor-rights boundary. The R029 findings and claims search did not locate a prior standalone section 84.1 assignment pass or a prior section 66(1.1) treatment. The current English consolidation and 2007 amending Act expressly cite subsection 84.1(3) in subsection 66(1.1). Subsection 84.1(3) is labelled Exceptions and subsection (4) contains the express performance and appropriateness factors. Preserve both as written. This pass makes no judicial finding about correcting the reference. The older viability wording shown in the legislative rationale is historical. Section 84.1(1) names the trustee as applicant, section 84.1(2)(a) uses individual-application language and the OSB summary uses debtor-application language across regimes. Keep individual or debtor standing under the modified proposal route, trustee joinder or approval mechanics, and the stage at which relief is available open pending authority and the actual motion record. The Act’s section 2 separately defines the date of bankruptcy and the date of the initial bankruptcy event. Section 84.1(3)(a) uses the former. The proposal-context treatment of contracts made after an NOI or proposal filing remains open. The OSB legislative summary lists commercial leases, but current subsection 84.1(3) does not expressly list commercial leases as a category. The statutory wording here supplies no general conclusion about whether any particular real-property or equipment lease can be assigned. Review the terms, property type, governing law and applicable order. Inherent assignability, classification of the financial contract, characterization and amount of default, admissible proof, service method and timing, or the effective date of actual assignment all remain matter-specific. Public factum and draft-motion-record leads do not establish a signed order or reasons. Section 66.4(1) excludes Division I from the provisions carried into consumer proposals by that subsection. The effect of its separate incorporation on section 84.1 is outside this pass. Standalone bankruptcy application and CCAA assignment remain outside this pass. BIA subsection 66(1) imports applicable provisions with necessary modifications, and subsection 66(1.1) expressly directs consideration of trustee approval. Preserve its printed cross-reference to 84.1(3), alongside the performance and appropriateness factors in 84.1(4). No judicial correction, debtor standing, post-filing contract cutoff adaptation or assignment of a particular lease was established. Distinct sale and agreement-assignment notices remain limited to their respective recipients. Some evidence spans multiple numbered reads and is bound in review-sealed copies.

Canada BIA Division I proposal compromise of claims against directors

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E194P-C001 covers the temporary director stay under BIA s. 69.31. E191I covers the CCAA director compromise and stay. E194A and E195E cover general proposal voting and release rules. This packet covers the separate BIA s. 50(13)–(18) rules and limits the cross-reference claim to s. 50(16). The consolidation displayed by Justice Laws is current to 2026-10-19 and reports the Act last amended 2026-06-20. The source date is a consolidation date, rather than an individual subsection commencement finding. Whether another law imposes liability, whether a claim fits a statutory exclusion, how the court applies the s. 50(15) test or determines classes, and what modifications s. 50(16) requires remain file-specific. Proposal and order wording, broader releases, indemnification and actual recoveries remain outside this statutory verification. Corporate Division I proposal provisions in BIA section 50(13)–(18). The temporary BIA stay and analogous CCAA compromise are distinct. Section 50(16) applies its two specified references with necessary modifications. There is no general release finding. Legal liability under other law, exclusions, fairness, class assignment, modifications, operative terms and actual recovery remain file-specific.

  • Under BIA s. 50(13), a corporate Division I proposal may include terms compromising a claim against a director if the claim arose before BIA proceedings began, relates to an obligation of the corporation, and the director is legally liable in that capacity to pay the obligation.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Under BIA s. 50(14), those terms must exclude claims concerning a creditor’s contractual rights under a contract with one or more directors. They must also exclude claims based on alleged misrepresentation by directors to creditors or on alleged wrongful or oppressive conduct by directors.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Under BIA s. 50(15), the court may declare that a director claim is outside the compromise if it is satisfied that compromising the claim would be unjust or inequitable in the circumstances.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • BIA s. 50(16) applies s. 62(2) and s. 122 to director claims compromised under a debtor corporation’s proposal, with the modifications the circumstances require. Section 62(2) governs the binding effect of a creditor-accepted and court-approved proposal, subject to s. 62(2.1). Section 122 addresses proof in a subsequent bankruptcy at the full claim amount less proposal dividends and separately addresses proof of interest when the rate was never agreed.

    section-122.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-62.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Under BIA s. 50(17), on an application made any time after the proposal is filed, the court may determine the classes of claims against directors and assign a particular claimant’s claim to a class.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Under BIA s. 50(18), if all directors have resigned or shareholders have removed them without replacement, anyone managing or supervising the management of the corporation’s business and affairs is deemed a director for section 50.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposals and eligible financial contracts

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

Prior R029 coverage retained as context. E189H-C003 already covers the BIA s. 65.1(7)(a) exclusion from the s. 65.1(1) limits. E194I-C014 already covers the contract-authorized netting and collateral dealings in s. 65.1(9), the cutoff of the NOI or the proposal if there was no NOI, and the residual deemed provable claim under s. 65.1(10) for purposes of the two specified stay paragraphs. E194I-C014 also already verifies the s. 2(a) regulated-market or recurrent-dealings condition. C001 adds the Rules’ s. 1 derivative definition and forms and the s. 2(a) payment-or-delivery coverage. BIA s. 2 defines the net termination value by the contractual netting of mutual obligations. E197A-C003 already covers the exclusion from the court-ordered assignment route in s. 84.1(3)(b), as incorporated when applicable through s. 66(1). E192O verified the prescribed classes and collateral under the CCAA and SOR/2007-257. E189U and E191A cover the CCAA section 34 mechanics. The BIA classes and collateral definition are supported here by their own Act and SOR/2007-256. The BIA protections must be applied by their own trigger, stay and order language. The cited Justice Laws Act and Rules views display consolidations current to October 19, 2026. The Act reports last amendment June 20, 2026, and the Rules June 14, 2016. Actual agreement terms and linked transactions, evidence for the market test, exact execution and termination events, notices and rights under governing law, collateral characterization, validity and perfection, any competing priority, court order effects, avoidance provisions, other statutory restrictions and ultimate recovery remain file-specific. Consumer proposals and standalone bankruptcy mechanics are outside the Division I inquiry. BIA and SOR/2007-256 only. The derivative market condition and section 65.1 netting and collateral dealings are prior context. The BIA classifications, statutory financial collateral, section 65.11 exclusion and section 88 bar remain section-specific. Master and supporting agreements qualify to the extent specified by the regulatory cross-references. Contract terms, market facts, timing, validity, perfection and actual order effects remain unresolved.

  • BIA section 2 defines an eligible financial contract by reference to prescribed kinds, and section 2 of SOR/2007-256 prescribes those kinds for the BIA. Under section 1 of the Rules, a derivative’s obligations depend on or refer to an underlying item such as an interest rate, currency or commodity. The definition includes swaps and contracts for differences, futures, caps, collars, floors, spreads, options, and spot or forward agreements. Paragraph 2(a) covers payment-settled and delivery-settled derivatives that meet its market condition.

    section-2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Under SOR/2007-256 section 2(b)–(d), prescribed agreements cover securities or commodities borrowing or lending, including transfer agreements that allow repayment in other securities or commodities, cash or cash equivalents. They also cover clearing or settlement of securities, futures, options or derivatives transactions, securities depository services, and repo, reverse repo or buy-sellback agreements involving securities or commodities. A margin loan qualifies to the extent it concerns a securities or futures account maintained by a financial intermediary as defined in section 1. That includes a clearing agency or a person maintaining such accounts for others in its ordinary business.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 2(e)–(i) of SOR/2007-256 includes combinations of agreements within paragraphs (a)–(d). A master agreement qualifies to the extent it relates to an agreement in paragraphs (a)–(e), and a further master agreement qualifies to the extent it relates to one covered by paragraph (f). Guarantees, indemnities and reimbursement obligations must relate to liabilities under agreements covered by paragraphs (a)–(g). A financial-collateral agreement, including a security or title-transfer arrangement, must relate to an agreement covered by paragraphs (a)–(h).

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • BIA section 2 limits financial collateral to cash or cash equivalents, including negotiable instruments and demand deposits, securities, a securities account, a securities entitlement or a right to acquire securities, and futures agreements or accounts. It must be subject to an interest, or a right in Quebec, securing payment or performance of an eligible financial contract obligation, or to a title transfer credit support agreement. In that latter arrangement an insolvent person or bankrupt has provided title to property to secure payment or performance of its eligible financial contract obligation.

    section-2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Paragraph 65.11(10)(a) excludes eligible financial contracts from section 65.11. The debtor consequently cannot use that Division I disclaimer or resiliation mechanism for an eligible financial contract after a notice of intention or proposal has been filed.

    section-65.11.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 88 prohibits an order under the BIA in relation to a bankruptcy or proposal if its effect would be to subordinate financial collateral. The limit turns on the defined collateral and the effect of the order. In a Division I proposal, the relevant collateral definition remains the one in BIA section 2.

    section-2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-88.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal creditor classification disputes and court review

Library record saved 2026-11-14

Research scope and limits

E194A-C001 through C003 already cover class-wide delivery, the unsecured default, the secured-class common-interest factors and the application under s. 50(1.5). E194A separately covers equity voting and the approving-class binding test, while E195U covers the approval hearing. E196N and E196S cover claims adjudication and secured valuation. Those rules are background for the Contech application and appellate procedure. Contech is a fact-specific BC appellate decision about approval and a particular classification combined with a proposal release. Its court-authored reasons were retrieved from the proposal trustee’s public docket after the direct court URL failed through the web tool. The case is cited for its application and result. The packet leaves open the jurisdictional ground and route for any particular future order, the standards for discretionary same-court review, and province-specific procedures. Wiivv Wearables was located by neutral citation, but the official court and CanLII targets did not yield native reasons in this pass. The packet makes no claim based on its secondary account. Contech is court-authored 2015 BCCA 99 in the proposal trustee-hosted PDF retrieval. The direct court URL failed in the recorded lookup. Its ruling combines the facts of secured classification and the release. Wiivv was not relied on. Appeal grounds, Rule 31 timing, section 195 stay and section 187(5) review are distinct. Case-specific jurisdiction, exceptions, orders, and local procedure remain open. Rule 31 is pinned in a review-sealed copy with only the official URL wrapper normalized.

  • Under BIA s. 50(1.5) the court can determine secured classes and the placement of a particular secured claim after a notice of intention or proposal is filed. A creditor opposing approval is heard under s. 59(1). In Contech, the British Columbia Court of Appeal concluded that grouping an asset seller with convertible-debenture holders was unfair in the circumstances. The seller held a purchase-money security interest with priority subject to two agreed subordinations. The debenture holders had already agreed to convert their loans into shares, while the proposal required the seller to release claims including those to enforce its interest in the intellectual property. The court held that the classification together with the release made the proposal unfair, allowed the appeal, set aside the approval order and dismissed the application.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-59.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca ca_en_insolv_Contech_Contech_%20En · www.insolvencies.deloitte.ca

  • Subject to express exceptions, BIA s. 193 identifies when a judge’s order or decision may be appealed to the Court of Appeal. Grounds listed in s. 193(a)–(c) involve future rights, likely effects on similar cases in the bankruptcy proceedings, or property involved in the appeal exceeding $10,000. Section 193(d) specifically concerns discharge orders. Other cases require leave from a Court of Appeal judge under s. 193(e). General Rule 31 directs an appeal to a court referred to in s. 183(2) to be filed by notice in the registrar’s office of the court appealed from within 10 days after the order or decision, subject to further time allowed by an appeal judge. For a s. 193(e) appeal, include the leave application in the notice.

    section-193.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca page-2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • BIA s. 195 stays proceedings under the order or judgment appealed from until disposition of the appeal, except to the extent the order is subject to provisional execution despite an appeal. The Court of Appeal or its judge may vary or cancel the stay or the provisional execution order for lack of diligence or another reason it considers proper.

    FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • BIA s. 187(5) gives the issuing court power to review, rescind or vary its own order made under its bankruptcy jurisdiction. A Court of Appeal challenge proceeds under the separate statutory appeal provisions in s. 193.

    section-187.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-193.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal initial estate control and cash-flow oversight

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E194M-C003–C010 already cover the cash-flow package, projection review, monitoring access, the material adverse change reporting triggers and interim-receiver substitution. E195Q-C001–C009 already cover bankruptcy vesting, receiver possession and sale/disposition controls. E194I covers stay and secured enforcement. E197E covers compromise and classification of prior director claims. E189O covers interim financing under the CCAA, a distinct statutory route. Initial possession context from BIA ss. 50.4(7), 50(10), 47.1 and 71. For an insolvent debtor outside an existing bankruptcy, filing a notice or proposal supplies the statutory monitoring framework. The trustee’s examination power is limited to what is necessary for the statutory assessment, under any applicable court direction. Possession under a court’s s. 47.1 direction and vesting following a bankruptcy order or filed assignment require their own triggers. This does not decide title, signing authority over accounts, bank set-off, duties under a specific order, or the treatment of an individual asset. Justice Laws displayed the consolidation as current to October 19, 2026, last amended June 20, 2026. The Directive 4R finding reflects OSB’s published HTML and current index. Both identify the PDF as controlling if inconsistent. The PDF rendering did not yield verifiable operative text in this pass. The Act’s recipient language controls, including the official receiver under s. 50.4(7)(b)(i), even where the directive’s Schedule A uses the Superintendent label. File-specific findings on management, charge amount, ranking and actual funding require the entered order, loan documents, projected cash flows, trustee report, notice/service record and relevant collateral documents. No particular materiality threshold, weekly reporting practice, bank account control or secured payment instruction is inferred. BIA sections 50.6, 64 and 64.1 each require their own application, filing trigger and statutory findings. Section 47.1(4) specifies venue for an interim-receiver application. Prior monitoring and reporting law remains context for distinct Directive 4R individual review and signature. The verified Directive source is the OSB HTML; the controlling PDF did not yield confirmed text. Follow Act recipients, including the official receiver under section 50.4(7)(b)(i). Actual control, notice, funding and ranking are file-specific.

  • Once a notice of intention under s. 50.4 or a proposal under s. 62(1) is filed, the debtor may apply for an interim-financing security or charge on all or part of its property, on notice to secured creditors likely to be affected. The court decides the appropriate charge and the amount required from the lender named in the order, having regard to the applicable debtor cash-flow statement. The charge cannot secure an obligation existing before the order. An individual must carry on a business to apply, and only property acquired for or used in relation to that business can be charged.

    section-50.6.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The court may rank the new charge ahead of secured creditor claims. Priority over another charge previously ordered under s. 50.6(1) requires the beneficiary’s consent. The mandatory, non-exhaustive factors include expected duration of the proceedings, how the business and financial affairs will be managed, major creditors’ confidence in management, prospects of a viable proposal, property nature and value, material prejudice to any creditor, and the applicable trustee report under para. 50(6)(b) or 50.4(2)(b).

    section-50.6.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • After a s. 50.4 notice or s. 62(1) proposal filing, an interested person can apply under s. 64 for an order removing a director. The court must be satisfied that the director unreasonably impairs or is likely to unreasonably impair the prospect of a viable proposal, or acts or is likely to act inappropriately as a director in the circumstances. The court may separately fill a vacancy created by the removal.

    section-64.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • After a s. 50.4 notice or s. 62(1) proposal filing, the person who is the subject of the filing can apply under s. 64.1 on notice to likely affected secured creditors. The court can charge some or all of the person’s property to indemnify directors or officers against obligations or liabilities incurred in that capacity after the applicable filing and may prioritize the charge over a secured creditor. Adequate insurance obtainable at reasonable cost bars the charge. The court must exclude specific obligations or liabilities it finds were caused by gross negligence or wilful misconduct, or in Quebec by gross or intentional fault.

    section-64.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • OSB Directive No. 4R, paras. 4–7 and Schedule A, assigns review and signature of listed reports to the individual trustee. Schedule A lists Form 29 for both cash-flow statements and specifies the s. 50(10)(a)(i) material adverse change report and the state-of-affairs reports identified in s. 50(10)(b) and subparas. 50.4(7)(b)(i) and (ii). The directive requires adequate internal controls and keeps trustees responsible for professional, timely administration of delegated work. Paragraph 8 allows special arrangements with the designated senior bankruptcy analyst in unusual circumstances. Use the Act for statutory recipients and timing.

    section-50.4.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca directives-and-circulars · www.ised-isde.canada.ca directive-no-4r-coming-force-septe · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • Section 47.1(4) places the application for the proposal-stage interim receiver, whether the application follows a notice of intention or a proposal, in a court with jurisdiction in the judicial district of the debtor’s locality.

    section-47.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal cash-flow filing formats and OSB guidance

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E194M already covers the statutory cash-flow package, projections and signed reports, rule 90 representations and court filing, trustee monitoring and Form 34. E197Q already covers the cash-flow evidence for interim financing and personal review and signature under Directive 4R. This increment addresses filing formats, the Form 65bis identifier and software handling. No standalone universally prescribed Division I projection template, mandatory 13-week format, or additional regulatory forecasting standard was verified. Actual acceptance of a Form 65bis filing in a given Division I estate and delivery routing for a sealed projection remain unverified. Vendor test documentation and the published manual describe e-filing workflows as documented. The vendor table records software groupings and 65bis is an internal schema name. Optional simultaneous submission does not displace the statutory ten-day package. September 16, 2024 is the version boundary subject to the stated forms exception, and June 1, 2025 is the technical correction date. File-specific sufficiency, a universal Division I template and sealed routing remain unresolved.

  • In its vendor-facing standard co-filing table for initial Division I proposals, OSB lists Form 65bis or an electronic copy of the cash-flow statement for an individual, and an electronic copy of the cash-flow statement for a corporation. Both entries list Forms 29 and 30 alongside the forecast. The table describes common e-filing groupings.

    cofiling.html · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • The vendor co-filing table allows the projected cash-flow statement to accompany an initial notice of intention and calls for both reports if the projection is included in that submission. It lists Form 65bis or an electronic copy for individuals and an electronic copy for corporations. The option concerns simultaneous submission. BIA subsection 50.4(2) still requires the prescribed package within ten days after the notice filing.

    section-50.4.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca cofiling.html · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • The OSB vendor release explains that 65bis is the internal schema name for Form 65. The May 2025 OSB notice requires the latest amended forms for estates filed from September 16, 2024 and continuation of pre-2024 versions in older estates, subject to the stated exception for forms that are outside OSB e-filing. It identifies June 1, 2025 as the effective date for the remaining technical corrections, including a Form 65 item-number correction.

    directive8R21.html · ised-isde.canada.ca bia-amended-forms-technical-update · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • The OSB Form 65 completion guidance describes a monthly personal and family budget and expressly lists individual bankrupts and consumer debtors making a consumer proposal. The separate Division I vendor table lists a technical option for initial individual filings. Read together, the sources support describing the vendor table’s option as published. Sufficiency of that option for a particular Division I forecast remains open. Subsection 50.4(2) governs what the notice-stage projection must show and who must sign it.

    section-50.4.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca cofiling.html · www.ised-isde.canada.ca instructions-completing-form-65-mo · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • The OSB insolvency-professional guide depicts a cash-flow softcopy upload as an additional document in its notice-of-intention workflow. The same guide displays a new-filing restriction for voluntary assignments and proposals involving a sealed document, naming a cash-flow statement as an example. These are published system instructions. Court filing and the routing of a particular sealed document depend on the applicable process and order.

    e-filing-manual_2024-02-en.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca

Canada Division I notice of intention extension evidence and Ontario court procedure

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E194I-C003/C004 already cover statutory timing, the three extension criteria and early termination. E194M-C008/C014 cover the trustee's hearing report and the Form 34 order attachment upon non-filing. This candidate adds motion practice and adjudicated evidence. The two Ontario authorities are case illustrations from reproduced judicial reasons. The regional directions apply in the named regions. A case-specific order and the applicable court's current procedure control the particulars. The Toronto and Central South directions are regional. The cases are court-authored reasons reproduced in a proposal docket book of authorities. Cogent rejected the extension on its record and Nortec allowed 15 of the requested 45 days. The examples support distinct evidentiary observations, with no portable notice order, current local deadline or case-specific viability conclusion.

  • The Toronto Region practice direction lists motions to extend the proposal filing period after a notice of intention for hearing in writing by Associate Judges sitting as Registrars in Bankruptcy. The Central South Region also lists these motions for written hearing by Registrars in Bankruptcy. These are regional court directions.

    consolidated-practice-direction-fo · www.ontariocourts.ca consolidated-practice-direction-to · www.ontariocourts.ca

  • For a written motion in the Toronto Bankruptcy Court, once a hearing date is assigned, the moving party serves the motion in accordance with the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act and Rules of Civil Procedure and submits the materials and proof of service through the Ontario Courts Public Portal. For an urgent filing the direction calls for marking it time sensitive in the portal and emailing the Bankruptcy Office with details. The court delivers a granted order electronically upon disposition, and the practice direction says the order takes effect from its date.

    consolidated-practice-direction-to · www.ontariocourts.ca

  • In NS United Kaiun Kaisha, Ltd. v. Cogent Fibre Inc., 2015 ONSC 5139, paras. 9–24 and 34, vague affidavit assertions about negotiations and an absence of concrete evidence about the proposed plan led the court to find that Cogent had failed to establish either good faith and due diligence or likely viability on a balance of probabilities. The debtor could describe the plan or its objectives without divulging the contents of without-prejudice negotiations. The court treated a veto-holding creditor's stated refusal as a factor and assessed the extension on the facts. It dismissed the extension motion.

    en-ca-insolv-Eureka-BookofAuthorit · www.insolvencies.deloitte.ca

  • In Nortec Colour Graphics Inc., Re, 2000 CarswellOnt 2797, paras. 1 and 7–19, the Deputy Registrar considered concrete steps involving leases and negotiations with a prospective investor and key creditors. The opposing creditor had identified neither the prospective equipment buyers nor the amount of loss it would suffer. The court found no material prejudice on the record and granted 15 days of the 45 requested. The first extension order had directed notice to creditors for a further extension motion.

    en-ca-insolv-Eureka-BookofAuthorit · www.insolvencies.deloitte.ca

Canada Division I notice-of-intention deemed assignment and bankruptcy notice

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E194I-C003–C004 and E194M-C014–C015 already cover the original filing windows, statutory extension, early termination, Form 34 and the five-day certificate-based meeting notice. E197Y concerns extension motions and evidence. The new scope is the receiver’s Form 35 and its effect, attribution of the bankruptcy date, the parallel notice clocks and how the resulting first-meeting route is identified. E195M-C002–C004 already address ordinary notice contents and meeting timing, trustee security and summary exceptions in the distinct post-annulment route under s. 63(5). Section 102 material here supports the linkage and the difference in starting events. The source package gives the summary notice-form titles, without claim-level findings on their full contents. The indexed Form 35 PDF was also returned with a zero-line extraction. A separate numbered read of that same official URL and the indexed HTML both substantiate the certificate body and notice wording. The two renderings differ in their displayed date-field labels, which this packet does not rely on. The exact case dates, estate administration type and authorized meeting arrangements are file-specific. The deemed bankruptcy date and Form 35 issuance are distinct events. The five-day statutory clocks are keyed separately to issuance and trustee appointment. The $25 amount pertains to the list and does not limit notice recipients. Summary eligibility depends on the official receiver and the Rule 130 $15,000 threshold. A meeting request and administration type remain file-specific. Review-sealed Rule 130 copy preserves numbering and normalizes the official URL wrapper only.

Canada Division I creditor meeting ordinary resolutions and vote evidence

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

For a live dispute, obtain the actual notice, proposal, motion, signed minutes, tallies, creditor proofs, voting letters and proxies, chair’s decision, and court orders. Applicable filing deadlines, forum, review standard and the availability of particular relief depend on the actual challenge and local procedure. The interaction of the general section 105(3) casting-vote rule with a particular ordinary-resolution tally or the specific section 54 proposal acceptance test remains open. Likewise assess defective convening or service separately from mere non-receipt under subsection 105(5). Earlier R029 work governs the section 54 proposal acceptance thresholds, proof and claim filing cutoffs, adjudication under section 135 and chair rulings under section 108, the Division II consumer-proposal comparison, and post-assignment or annulment trustee appointment votes. Section 52 ordinary adjournment resolutions are distinct from section 54 proposal acceptance. Directive 22R4 distinguishes proposal votes and quorum from eligibility to move motions or vote on ordinary resolutions through a voting letter or on the specified secured balance. Sections 105 and 114 are read subject to section 66(1) in Division I. Chair appeal and section 115.1 court relief are distinct from proof adjudication. Casting-vote interaction, case-specific deadlines, service defects and actual tally remain open.

  • At the meeting considering a Division I proposal, section 52 requires an adjournment when creditors pass an ordinary resolution calling for further appraisal and investigation of the debtor’s affairs and property, or examination under oath of the debtor or someone believed to know about those affairs or property. The chair fixes the time and place. If transcribed, the testimony must be placed before the adjourned meeting or may be read in court on the proposal approval application.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 2 refers ordinary resolutions to section 115. Subject to the Act, a majority of votes carries the resolution, counting one vote per dollar of each voting creditor’s claim that is not disallowed. That applies to the section 52 adjournment motion. Section 54 separately controls whether creditors accept the proposal itself.

    section-2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Under OSB Directive 22R4, a voting letter backed by a proven claim can establish quorum and be counted as directed on the proposal. Appendix B marks a creditor participating by voting letter as ineligible through that letter to table motions or vote on ordinary or special resolutions. It separately limits a proven secured balance in Division I to quorum within its class and the proposal vote, with the unsecured portion of a partly secured claim treated as unsecured. Apply those distinctions when recording the quorum and tally for a section 52 adjournment motion.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca directive-no-22r4-proofs-claim-pro · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • Read through subsection 66(1) where applicable and with needed modifications, subsection 105(4) requires the chair to arrange preparation of meeting minutes within a reasonable time, have them signed by the chair or chair of the next meeting, and retain them with the estate records. Subsection 114(1) provides for admission without further proof of a minute signed at the same or next meeting by the person identifying as or appearing to be chair of the meeting at which it is signed. Under subsection 114(2), chair-signed minutes support a rebuttable presumption that the meeting was duly convened and held and its resolutions and proceedings were regular.

    section-105.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Subsection 51(3) supplies the appeal route for a creditor challenging the first proposal meeting chair’s decision. In an application to revoke or vary a decision affecting or potentially affecting a vote outcome, section 115.1 permits the court to act as it considers appropriate. Statutory examples include suspending the effect of the vote until the application is decided and redetermining its outcome. For Division I proposals, apply the general provision subject to subsection 66(1).

    section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada Division I creditor meeting proxy and notice safeguards

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

Held for further authority. Section 105(3) states a general casting-vote rule for a tie. The French text also describes a tie-breaking vote. Section 66(1) imports general provisions only so far as applicable and with necessary modifications. Section 54(2)(d) separately specifies the class-by-class majority in number and two-thirds in value. No official decision or OSB interpretation located in this search determines how a casting vote is counted for either limb in Division I or how a casting vote is weighted for an ordinary resolution under section 115. The preserved texts support those distinctions, not a categorical rule on counting or overriding either threshold. Sections 51(1), 54(2)(d) and 54(4), and the general section 109(1) proof deadline, are contextual where previously addressed. The packet does not determine whether a particular contested proxy was executed with authority, which remedy is available for defective convening, or the outcome of a creditor challenge. E198F remains the coverage for section 52 investigation adjournment, dollar-weighted ordinary resolutions, proposal voting letters and secured balances, signed minutes, and section 115.1 vote orders. Inspector casting votes are governed separately and do not establish the proposed rule here. The scoped pivot supplies distinct proxy and notice safeguards, with E198F ordinary resolutions and proposal thresholds retained as context. Proof and proxy filing have different cutoffs. Statutory conflicts and personal creditor voting have separate restrictions. Nonreceipt under section 105(5) does not settle defects in sending or convening. Division I casting-vote weight and its effect on the statutory thresholds remain unresolved.

Canada Division I proposal creditor access to records and reports

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E196G-C002 already covers section 161 examination-record transmission and creditor availability, and E196G-C006 covers the public record and separate subsection 11.1(2) authority. The prescribed retention and fee were expressly held there. This pass resolves the rules described above for completed Division I proposals and public-record requests. E194M-C007 already covers proposal-stage and notice-of-intention-stage cash-flow copies and the court’s power to withhold them. E194U-C003 covers inspector account review. E198F-C004 covers preparation, signature, retention and evidentiary use of meeting minutes. E195I-C003–C006 cover final account preparation, taxation, delivery and objections after default. Those duties remain contextual when identifying documents to request. The subsection 26(3) duty to allow inspection and copying at reasonable times has different wording from an obligation to prepare or transmit copies on demand. The section 27(2) rule on charging the estate actual report disbursements concerns report preparation and delivery. Specific copy charges, remote delivery, privacy, privilege, sealing orders, court registry access, and what any particular OSB record contains remain file-specific or require further authority. This pass did not access any insolvency file or submit a paid search. How sections 26, 27 and 37 apply before a proposal is filed or to a particular trustee act, order, document, privilege claim or access refusal remains open. The Rule 122(1)(a) minimum is anchored to a certificate of full performance. Retention after a proposal ends without that certificate requires separate authority. Sections 26, 27 and 37 are applied in Division I through section 66(1), where applicable and with modifications. Inspection and copying, actual report disbursements and court review are separate. Rule 122 uses full performance for the ten-year minimum and opening for the separate six-year minimum. Rule 133 sets an $8 request fee. Rule citations use review-sealed numbered files with only the official URL wrapper normalized. Actual contents, privacy, privilege, specific copying charges and incomplete proposal retention remain unverified.

  • BIA subsection 26(1) requires the trustee to keep proper administration records for each estate. They include receipts and disbursements, creditors filing claims and how the claims were dealt with, copies of notices, signed records of creditor and inspector meetings, and court orders. The records are estate property and must be delivered promptly to a successor trustee. Subsection 26(3) requires the trustee to permit inspection and copying at a reasonable time by the Superintendent, the bankrupt, any creditor, or their representative. For a Division I proposal, apply section 26 through subsection 66(1) to the extent applicable and with the modifications the circumstances require.

    section-26.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca information-bia-inspectors · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • Under BIA section 27, a specific creditor may require the trustee to report to that creditor from time to time on the condition of the estate, any money on hand and property still unsold. The trustee also reports to every creditor when required by the inspectors and to the Superintendent or creditors when required by the Superintendent. The trustee can charge the estate only actual disbursements for preparing and delivering those reports. In Division I, the bankruptcy wording of section 27 applies through subsection 66(1) where applicable and with the required modifications.

    section-27.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca information-bia-inspectors · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • Rule 39 requires trustees to act honestly and impartially and provide interested parties with full and accurate information as required by the BIA. Under Rule 40, public disclosure of confidential engagement information requires a legal obligation or authorization from the person to whom the information relates. BIA section 37 permits an aggrieved creditor to apply to the court about an act or decision of a trustee. The court may confirm, reverse or modify it and make an order it considers just. For a Division I file, any application of section 37 is subject to subsection 66(1). The statutory text gives the court discretion, and the treatment of a particular refusal depends on the record and applicable law.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For a completed Division I proposal, Rule 122(1)(a) requires the Superintendent to keep the files relating to the public proposal record for at least ten years after the section 65.3 certificate of full performance is given. Rule 122(2) separately sets a minimum of six years from opening for other records kept under subsection 11.1(2). The right under subsection 11.1(1) is to obtain information contained in the public record, subject to the prescribed fee. The OSB’s Division I creditor guide describes the online record search as providing basic debtor information.

    section-11.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-122.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca you-are-owed-money-division-i-prop · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • Rule 133 sets an $8 fee for each request for information contained in the BIA public record. In the online search instructions, OSB states that viewing BIA search results costs $8 per set of up to ten records. If the service reports ten or fewer matches, the minimum applies to view the result even when it ultimately shows zero matches.

    instructions · ised-isde.canada.ca FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada Division I proposal trustee conflicts and replacement

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E198J covers trustee proxies and voting restrictions tied to remuneration or conduct. E198F covers the ordinary-motion procedure and Directive 22R4 voting-letter and claim limits. E196G covers the Superintendent’s complaint, investigatory and disciplinary jurisdiction. E194M covers ordinary proposal trustee duties; E190G addresses CCAA monitor ethics. This packet covers the distinct appointment conflict, disclosure and substitution issues. Previously mapped bankruptcy-transition ordinary resolutions, including E198C and E194E, are outside the section 14 special-resolution finding. The proposal acceptance vote under section 54 is a separate vote. Appointment-specific voter exclusions under subsection 113(3) and their application to a particular Division I tally are reserved pending a dedicated crosswalk. The OSB debt-advisor notice supplies regulator context, with consumer proposal review language elsewhere on the page. File-specific cause, effect of disclosure or nondisclosure, good-faith acts following a defective appointment, precise meeting eligibility, validity of security, and local motion or filing procedure need further evidence or legal analysis. The section 13.3 page displays a consolidation current to October 19, 2026. The returned General Rules page displays September 30, 2026. The original numbered returns are the pinned evidence. Permission, disclosure, independent legal opinion, creditor special resolution and court replacement are distinct. Apply the applicable general provisions through section 66(1). Section 14 special resolution is separate from bankruptcy-transition ordinary votes and proposal acceptance. Appointment-specific voter exclusions, precise cause, validity, and Division I handover implementation remain open. The ethics rules use a review-sealed copy with the official URL wrapper normalized.

  • Under BIA subsections 13.3(1) and (1.1), the trustee needs court permission, subject to any conditions the court imposes, if the trustee is or in the preceding two years was a director or officer of the debtor, an employer or employee of the debtor or its director or officer, related to the debtor or its director or officer, or the debtor’s auditor, accountant or legal counsel or a partner or employee of one of those advisers. A separate current-role branch covers a trustee under a trust indenture issued by the debtor or a related person, a power-of-attorney holder under an act constituting a Québec hypothec granted by either, and anyone related to such a trustee or holder. An applicant must send a copy of the application to the Superintendent without delay. For Division I proposals, subsection 66(1) applies general BIA provisions to the extent applicable and with necessary modifications.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-13.3.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Subsection 13.3(2) requires a trustee already administering a related person’s bankruptcy or proposal, or already acting as a statutory receiver or liquidator of a related person’s property, to disclose that engagement and the potential conflict fully both on appointment and at the first creditors’ meeting. This is a separate statutory requirement from the court-permission provision in subsection 13.3(1).

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-13.3.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 13.4 requires an estate trustee to obtain a written independent legal opinion on the validity and enforceability of the security against the estate before acting for or helping a secured creditor assert a claim against the estate or deal with its security. On starting, the trustee must immediately notify the Superintendent and the creditors or inspectors that the trustee is acting, give the basis for any remuneration from the secured creditor, and notify them of the opinion. Within two days of a request, the trustee must furnish a copy to the Superintendent and to each creditor who requests it.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 13.5 requires compliance with the prescribed Code of Ethics. General Rules 35 and 44 cover an insolvency engagement to which a trustee is appointed or designated under the Act and require the trustee to avoid influences, interests or relationships that impair professional judgment or would appear to an informed person to impair it.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca page-2.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 14 expressly permits creditors at a meeting to appoint or substitute another licensed trustee for the trustee named in a proposal or otherwise appointed or substituted. Under the section 2 definition, the special resolution needs a majority in number and three-fourths in value among creditors with proven claims who are present personally or by proxy and vote on it. A creditor’s concern about a possible conflict can prompt a request, while an actual creditor appointment follows the statutory resolution process. The OSB notice on debt advisors is context for the complaint and substitution routes, and the Division I vote rule comes from the Act.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca notice-creditors-creditors-debt-ad · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • Under section 14.04 any interested person may apply for removal. The court may remove the trustee for cause and appoint another licensed trustee. Separately, section 57.1 allows the court to appoint a replacement for the trustee under a filed notice of intention or proposal after a declaration under subsection 50(12) or 50.4(11), if replacement serves the creditors’ best interests.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Subsection 14.06(1) does not oblige a trustee to accept a proposal appointment. After acceptance, the trustee must perform the statutory duties until discharge or successor appointment. Where section 36 is applicable under section 66(1), the outgoing trustee must promptly pass accounts before the court and transfer estate property, books, records and documents with a receipts and disbursements statement. The incoming trustee must notify the Superintendent and, if creditors appointed them, file the chair-signed minutes with the court. The applicability and modifications of the bankruptcy-specific handover details in a particular Division I matter require file-specific verification.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada Division I proposal expense taxation and objections

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

R029 E194M-C016 already has proposal approval and distribution after proper fees and expenses under BIA ss. 60(1) and 62(1). E194U-C003 already has inspector review and approval of accounts under s. 120(3)–(4). E195I-C003–C006 already have post-default accounting, Superintendent and taxation sequencing, the s. 152(6) 15-day statement or dividend-sheet objection and s. 41(5) five-day discharge objection. E195M-C005 already has the independent assignment trigger for final accounts. These issues are prior context. Rule 25’s legal-bill appeal, s. 152(6) objection to the final statement or dividend sheet and s. 41(5) objection to trustee discharge have different triggers and procedures. The Rule 25 deadline applies to the legal-bill decision. The OSB directly confirms the discharge-objection fee in a Division I proposal. The scope of local filing directions and any additional or exceptional fees is held. Section 66(1) calls for applicability and necessary modifications of general BIA provisions. Apply the expense, legal-bill, and procedural provisions only when their conditions are met. A below-threshold bill is exempt from mandatory Rule 18 taxation, which gives no independent entitlement to estate payment. The proposal, authorizations and court directions can matter. No general claim is made for separate summary-bankruptcy procedures, consumer-proposal fees, or costs awarded for opposition to the bankrupt’s own discharge. General Rules apply in Division I only where applicable and with needed modifications under section 66(1). Above $2,500 in aggregate excludes taxes for mandatory legal-bill taxation. Its notice and appeal each use a distinct ten-day trigger. The $50 objection fee is separate from legal-bill appeal and the trustee account or discharge deadlines. Local directions, actual charges, below-threshold estate-payment entitlement and rule application in a particular file remain unresolved. Rules use a review-sealed copy preserving original numbering.

  • Where the section 152 accounts-taxation process applies to a Division I proposal with necessary modifications, General Rule 58 puts the trustee’s own services and those of partners and employees within remuneration unless the court orders otherwise. Indirect facilities and premises costs are excluded from disbursements. The taxing officer determines which disbursements are reimbursable and applies the tariff rates where provided. The post-2009 OSB Form 12 itemizes trustee remuneration and legal fees separately.

    form-12-statement-receipts-and-dis · ised-isde.canada.ca section-152.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • When applicable to the work in question, Part III of the Schedule permits the taxing officer to allow printing and postage for listed documents sent to all creditors, including the statement of receipts and disbursements, dividend sheet and notice of application for discharge. The Schedule uses the lower applicable printing cost or folio scale, plus postage. The court may disallow these disbursements in whole or part when remuneration already compensates the trustee adequately. The listed exclusions include stay notices and other notices that are sent to fewer than all creditors.

    section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Where General Rules 18–21 apply to a legal-services bill in a Division I proceeding, taxation is mandatory above $2,500 in aggregate before applicable federal and provincial taxes. The bill must describe the work fairly, reasonably and in detail. The trustee must be represented at taxation or attach a signed declaration that the work was authorized and rendered and that the charges are reasonable in the trustee’s opinion. The taxing officer tests whether work was rendered, charges are reasonable and meet any applicable tariff, the work is accounted for and belongs with counsel, and the required authorization and approval were obtained. Where applicable through subsection 66(1), subsection 197(4) separately limits estate payment to costs for services authorized in writing by the trustee and costs the court awarded against the trustee or estate.

    section-197.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Where General Rules 22–25 apply, counsel must give the trustee and any other party liable for the bill at least 10 days’ notice of the taxation, with a certified copy of the bill, and notify the Division Office on request. The signed taxation endorsed on the bill is enforceable as a judgment. To appeal that decision to the court, give the opposite party and the Division Office notice stating the grounds within 10 days after the decision. The judge may assess the bill afresh. Rule 23 also permits the trustee to seek an ex parte order compelling delivery or presentation of the bill and, on noncompliance, an order permitting distribution of estate proceeds in hand without regard to it.

    section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • In a Division I proposal, the OSB identifies a $50 fee for an interested party’s written objection to the trustee’s discharge. Schedule Part II, item 4(f), sets the $50 registrar fee for a written dispute or opposition filed by a person other than the trustee or administrator. Keep the filing fee distinct from the statutory filing and service requirements applicable to the particular objection and from Rule 25’s separate appeal of a taxed legal bill.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca you-are-owed-money-division-i-prop · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

Canada Division I proposal withdrawal or deemed refusal before a vote

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E194A-C006 and C014 already cover the related-creditor restriction and refusal on a vote. E194I-C003–C004, E197Y and E198C address NOI deadlines, extensions, early court termination of the NOI filing period, deemed assignment, official receiver certificate or notices. E198T-C006 cites s. 50(12) as a trigger for trustee replacement under s. 57.1. E194E, E195I and E195M cover default or annulment after approval. This pass adds the nonwithdrawal rule and assignment saving, the pre-meeting deemed-refusal grounds and the exceptional court-ordered exit from an actual filed proposal. Justice McArthur’s short endorsement describes an exceptional case and does not specify the statutory analysis. The Fourth Report supplies the trustee’s assessment and the alternative requested relief. The order does not grant a favourable related-party vote. This case supplies no general entitlement to withdraw a filed Division I proposal. The court exhibit contains an unsigned specimen completion certificate. The actual filing time and OSB recording were not independently verified. An unfiled proposal or a proposal that cannot be brought before creditors for another reason requires its own filing history, meeting record and any operative order. This pass does not establish an automatic result merely from inability to table a proposal. Section 50(4) nonwithdrawal and the section 50(4.1) assignment saving are distinct from pre-meeting deemed refusal. The Down Under order and endorsement are reproduced in the trustee-hosted record and describe exceptional conditional prospective relief. The effective time depends on filing the completion certificate; the excerpt is an unsigned specimen and exact filing and OSB recording were not verified. The nonbankruptcy clause is limited to the enumerated effects. The alternative favourable related-party vote was requested but not granted.

  • BIA s. 50(4) prohibits withdrawal of a Division I proposal or any security, guarantee or suretyship tendered with it while the creditors’ and court’s decisions are pending. Section 50(4.1) preserves the ability of an insolvent person in respect of whom a proposal was made to subsequently make an assignment.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Under s. 50(12), the trustee, a s. 47.1 interim receiver if appointed, or a creditor may apply before the meeting for an order deeming the filed proposal refused. The court must be satisfied of one of three statutory grounds: lack of good faith and due diligence, likely nonacceptance, or material prejudice to creditors as a whole if denied. An order engages paragraphs 57(a)–(c) under s. 50(12.1), including deemed assignment in respect of an insolvent person, trustee report, receiver certificate and first-meeting steps. The possibility of nonacceptance is grounds for an application and does not itself constitute refusal.

    section-50.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-57.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The Fourth Report says Down Under’s sole creditor was considered related by the trustee. Section 54(3) bars a related creditor from voting in favour and permits a vote against. The creditor did not oppose withdrawal. The trustee reported that the bank had been paid in full and Down Under was able to meet obligations as they became due. The trustee assessed it as solvent and supported the motion to withdraw. The application alternatively sought permission for a favourable related-party vote. The court granted withdrawal relief and characterized the matter as exceptional.

    RespMotionRecordTrusteeDec82022.pd · cdn.albertgelman.com section-54.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The Ontario Superior Court of Justice’s September 10, 2021 order, paras. 7–9 and Schedule A, addressed Down Under’s March 18 notice of intention and August 30 filed proposal. It set the effective time at the trustee’s filing of the completion certificate with the court. From that time the filings were deemed withdrawn prospectively, the applicable stay ended prospectively and the trustee was discharged as to Down Under’s filings. The trustee was to send the executed certificate and order to the OSB to record the withdrawal. The order barred a deemed bankruptcy for Down Under solely for missing creditor approval, missing court approval, or procedural irregularity caused by the order. The later Sixth Report confirms the NOI proceedings were withdrawn in accordance with the order.

    RespMotionRecordTrusteeDec82022.pd · cdn.albertgelman.com

Canada BIA Division I proposal approval of third-party releases

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E195E-C001 covers the effect of acceptance alone under ss. 62(3) and 179. E197E-C001–C006 cover the statutory director compromise and its limits. E195U covers the approval hearing. E197M-C001 already records the binding outcome in Contech, where classification together with the release made that proposal unfair. This packet adds the affirmative authority and release-specific reasoning of the Ontario trial court in Kitchener Frame. Kitchener Frame was an Ontario trial-level decision on an unopposed motion, and counsel reported that no creditor or stakeholder objected to the scope of the release. The reasons record that an order was signed. The signed order and implementation were not separately authenticated. Effect on a specific claim requires the sanctioned terms, operative order, notice record and applicable statutory limits. The packet does not decide the reach of a contested release, the effect on noncreditors or the enforceability of a release of a specific guarantee. Justice Laws displayed a consolidation current to 2026-10-19, last amended 2026-06-20. The case source is a complete court-authored and CanLII-marked copy embedded as Tab 3 in a publicly posted motion brief on Lazer Grant’s domain. The motion brief’s argument is not relied upon. The cited text is the court-authored 2012 ONSC 234 reasons reproduced in a third-party hosted motion book, not the enclosing counsel argument. The reasons report a signed order, whose separate instrument was not authenticated. The unopposed case and its disclosed proposal illustrate the approval analysis and exceptions. Contested releases, noncreditors, specific guarantees and operative order effect remain open.

  • In Kitchener Frame Limited (Re), 2012 ONSC 234, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (Commercial List) interpreted s. 62(3) as preserving the default effect of proposal acceptance without imposing a categorical bar to an express third-party release in a court-approved Division I proposal. It reasoned that the BIA and CCAA should be read harmoniously where their text permits. The court applied the proposal approval standard in BIA s. 59(2) and signed an order sanctioning this proposal, including its release.

    section-59.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-62.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca 08.1-Motion-Brief-MLT-Aikins-Court · www.lazergrant.ca

  • At paras. 80–82, Kitchener Frame drew on Metcalfe to assess whether the proposed releasees were essential to the restructuring, the claims to be released were rationally related to and necessary for the proposal, the proposal depended on the releases, the releasees made concrete contributions, and creditors generally as well as the debtors would benefit. The court said the analysis depended on the facts of each claim and no single consideration decided it.

    08.1-Motion-Brief-MLT-Aikins-Court · www.lazergrant.ca

  • The motion in Kitchener Frame was unopposed. The court found that releasees made substantial contributions, that some would likely withhold support without the release, that the release was needed to satisfy borrowing conditions and that creditors generally benefited. The scope and effect of the release were disclosed in advance of the vote. As described in the reasons, the proposal preserved enforcement of the applicants’ and trustee’s proposal obligations and expressly excluded unaffected claims, criminal or other wilful misconduct and matters under s. 50(14) as to the applicants’ present or former directors. These terms and circumstances describe the approved proposal.

    08.1-Motion-Brief-MLT-Aikins-Court · www.lazergrant.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal amendments before the creditor vote

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

Hold the general effect of a material or immaterial amendment on a previously submitted voting letter or proxy, including carry-forward, revocation, replacement, prejudice and vote counting. Obtain the actual form, proposal versions, notices, directions and chair ruling for a live file. Hold any universal right to advance circulation of an amendment, a redline, a supplemental trustee report or fresh forms, and any fixed interval or automatic restart of the initial section 51 ten-day period. Section 104 refers to subsequent meetings generally. Whether its five-day rule applies to an adjourned continuation of the initial Division I meeting requires further authority. Hold any universal materiality test or entitlement to an adjournment merely because terms changed, and the effect or remedy for defective sending, service, actual nonreceipt or inadequate disclosure. A specific adjournment, order, notice, proof, proxy, voting letter, tally and court procedure can affect those questions. Eureka supports the court’s order, the proposal trustee’s announced protocol and the reported filing and vote. The sources do not independently confirm posting, service, the fate of individual ballots, or a generally governing notice rule. Rule 92 clerical corrections at court approval and post-acceptance modification are outside this pass. The Act subsection 54(1), ordinary adjournment mechanics and statutory initial notice serve as context for the distinct dated Form 37 wording and the case-specific amendment notice. Prior R029 findings control background topics identified in the overlap screen. Form 37 identifies the proposal by date. Section 51 initial notice and section 104 later meeting notice have different triggers; application of section 104 to a reconvened initial meeting is unresolved. The court-authored August 5, 2020 Eureka order and trustee notices are in the public trustee docket. The August 17 notice announces the protocol. The later notice reports filing on August 26 and rejection at the August 28 reconvened vote. No confirmed posting, individual ballot treatment, automatic carry-forward or general circulation requirement. Rule 91 and order pins use original-number-preserving review copies with official redirect wrappers normalized.

  • OSB Form 37 asks the proposal trustee to record the creditor’s vote for or against the proposal made on the date entered on the form. Section 53 gives timely advance assent or dissent on a proven claim the effect of attendance and voting, and General Rule 91 lists personal delivery, mail, facsimile and electronic transmission. Subsection 54(1) permits the vote on the proposal as made or as altered at the meeting or its adjournment. The date field is evidence of the version identified by the letter. The cited provisions and form leave the treatment of an earlier letter after an alteration unresolved.

    form-37-voting-letter-division-i-p · ised-isde.canada.ca F37_EN_Amended_September-22-11.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca page-9.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Subsection 51(1) requires the trustee to send every known creditor and the official receiver the initial meeting notice, a proposal copy and the prescribed voting letter as part of the package at least ten days before the meeting. Section 104 separately specifies, for meetings of creditors other than the first, notice of time and place and an agenda with a reasonable explanation of each item, sent at least five days beforehand to each creditor at the address in the proof of claim. Subsection 104(2) limits whom it is necessary to notify after the first meeting to creditors with proved claims. Section 66(1) brings in other BIA provisions only insofar as applicable, with the modifications circumstances require, and excludes Division II. The applicability of section 104 to a particular reconvened Division I meeting is held.

    page-9.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-104.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · www.laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • In Eureka 93 Inc. et al. (Re), the Ontario Superior Court recorded that noteholders voted to postpone proposal votes and seek further investigation and examinations under section 52. Paragraph 12 of the August 5, 2020 case conference order set an examination completion date and required voting to finish by August 28, subject to further order or written agreement and any application or appeal that had to be determined first. In the August 17 Eureka 93 reconvening notice, the proposal trustee said it would file the amended proposal with the OSB and post the amended proposal, a version identifying the changes, a supplementary report and revised proxy and voting-letter forms. The trustee instructed that any revised proxy or voting letter intended for the reconvened meeting had to be for the amended proposal and lodged before the reconvened meeting began. These were the timetable and instructions in that proceeding.

    ca_en-Insolv_Eureka_CaseConference · www.insolvencies.deloitte.ca en-ca-insolv-Eureka-NoticeofReconv · www.insolvencies.deloitte.ca

  • The trustee’s subsequent notice reports that Eureka 93 filed the amended proposal on August 26, 2020, and creditors voted on and rejected the amended proposal at the August 28 reconvened meeting. The record establishes the filing and vote sequence in that proceeding. Whether each announced document was posted or delivered and how any earlier voting letter was treated remain unverified.

    en-ca-insolv-Eureka-NoticetoCredit · www.insolvencies.deloitte.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal certificate of full performance and remaining obligations

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

The record does not resolve disputed performance, remedies for a delayed or withheld certificate, or a separate time limit for giving it. Whether a specific secured or post-filing claim, lien, guarantee, or express release survives depends on the approved terms, claim, orders and applicable law. Section 62(3) third-party releases remain covered by E199E. The current OSB e-filing index and the older Division I specimen were line-verified. The current combined form landing page and schema timed out on numbered fetch. Hold exact current combined field wording and applicability dates. Certificate of full performance and trustee discharge are distinct. The prescribed certificate goes to debtor and official receiver and starts final statement preparation. The OSB index and historical specimen support Form 46 and bounded date fields. Current combined form fields and applicability dates are unverified. Certification establishes no new claim scope or substitute for express compromise and a favourable creditor vote on a section 178(1) liability. Disputed performance remedies and applicability to specific claims remain open.

Canada BIA Division I certificate of full performance, combined Form 46 version

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

The English combined HTML timed out and the indexed English PDF yielded no numbered text. Exact English wording and the individual e-filing schema contents remain unverified. The official French HTML and PDF support the field descriptions. Directive 8R6 effective September 18, 2009 governs its listed event routes, and the OSB directory distinguishes both categories. The officially numbered French HTML and PDF verify the combined Form 46 fields and the syndic and administrateur alternatives. The accepted English claim is a field description, not authenticated English wording. Current English combined HTML and PDF wording, schema fields and individual version applicability remain unverified.

  • The OSB forms directory lists a Form 46 in each of its categories for persons covered by the 2009 amendments and for persons outside them. Directive No. 8R6, which took effect on September 18, 2009, records that former consumer-proposal Form 57 was merged into Form 46. For Directive No. 8R6 applicability, check the listed events on or after that date. For a Division I proposal, those events include filing a notice of intention, filing a proposal without a prior notice of intention, or a proposal being made in respect of the person without that prior notice. The Directive also lists bankruptcy and specified receivership events.

    forms · ised-isde.canada.ca directive-no-8r6-coming-force-sept · ised-isde.canada.ca B.pdf · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The official combined Form 46 cites BIA sections 65.3 and 66.38 and asks the signer to select the applicable capacity. For a Division I proposal, the signer selects the trustee branch. The form uses the Form 1 title and includes the signer's name, the proposal identified in that branch, the official receiver filing date, the amendment date where applicable, the effective date of full performance, and a separate place, date and signature for the certificate. The administrator branch is for a consumer proposal.

    Formulaire46.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca formulaire-46-certificat-dexecutio · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal completion accounts and retained balances

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

Prior accepted work supplies the Form 46 trigger and separation from trustee discharge (E199N-C001–C002), and the post-default, account-approval, taxation and objection procedures (E194U-C003, E195I-C003–C006, E198W). This pass adds account-detail classification, statutory remittance and later recovery. The wider R029 assignment remains open. Hold which General Rules exemption, if any, applies to a specific amount, and any proposal-specific return, disputed claim reserve, statutory trust, assignment, merged bankruptcy account, local filing practice, bank-account closing date or court-authorized retention. Inspect the accepted proposal, trust and payment terms, relevant rule text and any orders before resolving ownership or timing. No general entitlement to refund or continued trustee custody is inferred from Form 12. Directive 18 HTML is on the current OSB index but expressly subordinates itself to the directive PDF. The PDF was opened with zero readable numbered lines and screenshot retries timed out. Paragraph 4’s suggested ordinary-bankruptcy cheque-clearing window and paragraph 6–7 materiality/interest guidance are not adopted as Division I deadlines or thresholds. Retrieve and compare the official PDF and establish application to Division I before using them. Rule 65’s three-month mechanics expressly use the summary-bankruptcy path (Rules 62, 64–65). Rule 98 expressly addresses consumer proposals. Hold an independent Division I bank-closing deadline and any actual date on which Directive 5R8 was activated for proposals or notices of intention. Current OSB index lists 5R8, and the 5R9 item located on the official site is a draft. The official BIA consolidation viewed is current to 2026-10-19. Rule 61 view is current to 2026-10-19 and Rule 136.1 view to 2026-09-30. The HTML versions of the two Rules contain numbered lines plus a tool-generated normalized-URL presentation. The source files preserve those returns, with the authenticated redirect target recorded separately. OSB guidance is agency practice. Hold direct use of subsection 41(11) for a particular completed, non-bankrupt Division I file pending the underlying proposal, order or proposal-specific authority. The statute grants a discretionary court appointment on its terms, not authority for informal retention. Sections 151–154 and 41 are read in Division I only where applicable with modifications. Form 12 entries do not determine refund entitlement, ownership or reserves. Remittance and recovery remain distinct, including the $30 per-dividend fee. Directive 5R8 holds the specified wording in abeyance until further notice. No activating notice was authenticated. Treat the reference to a signed notice as an evidence boundary and not a requirement imposed by the directive. Directive 18 operative PDF text and a general Division I bank-closing deadline remain unverified.

Canada BIA Division I proposal trust account oversight

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

Hold whether particular funds qualify as estate trust funds and how statutory controls apply to pre-filing payments, an NOI-only file, third-party funds, retainers, third-party beneficial claims or mixed-purpose funds. Obtain the payment and trust terms, file stage and any orders. Hold particular withdrawals, scope of expenses incidental to administration, effect of a proposal-specific restriction, alternative payment methods, deposit institution eligibility or approval, continuing security amounts and any recovery rights until file-specific authority and evidence are obtained. The reservation excludes Directive 5R8 application and E199V’s completion accounting or remittance. No current funds-handling or bank technology requirement is inferred from the historic MacLeod example. Exact prior screen checked E194M trustee duties, E194U-C001/C003/C005 inspector appointment, checks and directions, E195Q court property control, E196G-C003–C005 supervisory and conservatory measures, E198O-C001/C002 records and creditor accounting, and E199V-C001–C005 closeout, remittance, recovery and abeyance. These prior findings provide context. This candidate adds section 25 controls, Rule 48 and paragraph 5(3)(c). Section 25 and Rule 48 apply to Division I within section 66(1). MacLeod is a historical OSB administrative decision on two identified files and an admitted segregation error. Consumer consolidation and closing remittance are distinct. Trust terms, permission, insurer coverage and surety are file-specific. The Rule 48 review copy preserves numbering and normalizes the verified redirect wrapper.

  • BIA subsection 25(1) requires a trustee acting under the Act to deposit all funds received for an estate without delay in a separate bank trust account for each estate. In a Division I proposal, section 66(1) applies the general Act provisions insofar as applicable and with needed modifications. Subsection 25(3) bars using the trustee’s personal bank account for funds received while acting under the Act. Subsection 66.26(2) gives a separate, conditional consolidation authority for consumer proposals. The 2008 MacLeod administrative decision records two Division I files handled in a consumer proposal consolidated account as contrary to subsection 25(1), with the trustee admitting administrative error. Use that decision for the narrow segregation illustration, with its historical facts.

    allen-w-macleod-donald-macleod-and · ised-isde.canada.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.26.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Under BIA subsection 25(1.1), deposits at a Canadian non-bank deposit-taking institution must be protected by deposit insurance or guarantee under provincial or federal legislation. Subsection 25(1.2) allows funds already situated outside Canada to be deposited in a bank-like institution in that country if the Superintendent authorizes it. These are statutory conditions for estate funds to which section 25 applies through section 66(1).

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Under BIA subsection 25(1.3), where applicable to the proposal under subsection 66(1), the trustee needs written permission from the inspectors or the court on application to withdraw estate trust funds, except for dividends and charges incidental to estate administration. Section 56 makes inspectors optional and their powers subject to the proposal terms. Subsection 25(2) prescribes an estate-account cheque or a method specified by Superintendent directive. Check the proposal, appointment and authority for the particular withdrawal, especially where no inspectors were appointed.

    FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-56.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • General Rule 48 requires trustees holding money or property in trust to hold it in accordance with the governing law, regulations and trust terms and administer it with due care subject to those requirements. Under BIA paragraph 5(3)(c), where otherwise unprovided for, the Superintendent requires continuing guaranty bonds or suretyships to secure due accounting for property received and faithful administration of assigned estates. The Superintendent determines and may vary the amount and may enforce the security for creditors’ benefit. The bond or surety and any potential enforcement in a specific Division I file require verification.

    section-5.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal trustee security

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

Prior exact scope screened. E198T-C005–C007 already covers appointment, substitution, acceptance and turnover. E195M-C004 covers security and adjustment in the ordinary bankruptcy arising after annulment and the summary administration exception. E194U-C003 covers the inspectors’ inquiry into adequacy. E199Z-C004 covers continuing security under paragraph 5(3)(c) and Rule 48 due care. E199A-C001 covers security tendered with the debtor’s proposal. Those propositions are context. The new scope is the qualified appointment-security rule within Division I and subsection 16(2)’s collective court-directed enforcement route. Hold whether security was required, furnished or adjusted in a particular file, including an NOI-only file or where the appointment or transition stage is disputed. Obtain the appointment or resolution, official receiver record, instrument and any court order. Hold scope, loss, standing details, limitation periods, procedural filing and recovery. OSB lists Directive 21R on estate security. The agency HTML refers to setting security at filing of an assignment where the amount can be determined and says the PDF prevails. The linked PDF returned a cache miss. Leave applicability and any directive thresholds in a particular Division I proposal open. The Division I application of BIA section 16 is conditional on section 66(1), including modifications required by the circumstances. Section 14 supports replacement by special resolution without resolving whether the security provision applies to a particular appointment. Section 16(2) describes court-directed enforcement by a succeeding trustee or one creditor on behalf of all. No specific instrument, amount, right to personal recovery or consumer-proposal rule is established.

  • Where BIA subsection 16(1) applies to a Division I proposal through subsection 66(1), a duly appointed trustee gives security as soon as appointed. It may be furnished in cash or by bond or suretyship of a guaranty company satisfactory to the official receiver. It secures proper accounting for, payment and transfer of property received as trustee and faithful performance of the trustee’s duties. Section 14 expressly contemplates a replacement for a trustee named in a proposal. For a replacement, check the operative appointment, the security on file and the applicability of subsection 16(1) in the case.

    section-14.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-16.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Where BIA subsection 16(2) applies through subsection 66(1), the trustee gives the security to the official receiver for creditors generally. The official receiver may increase or reduce it. A succeeding trustee or one creditor acting for all may enforce it by direction of the court. Verify the instrument and any direction before concluding that a claimant can recover in a specific file.

    section-16.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal trustee applications for court directions

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

The evidence establishes the federal statute and a proposal trustee’s invocation of it in a particular post-approval proceeding. A resulting written order granting the identified requests remains unverified. The applicable proposal terms, local filing or service requirements, additional notice recipients and actual relief require matter-specific verification. Division II and CCAA proceedings are outside this coverage. Division I only, subject to section 66(1) applicability and necessary modifications. Section 34(3) calls for sending hearing-day and time notice to the Superintendent’s division office. Section 34(2) has a separate reporting trigger. The Guo third report evidences the applicant’s request in one particular B.C. Supreme Court proceeding, with separate original numbered captures of the context and requested orders. Preserve the hold on disposition, any resulting written order, matter-specific procedure and notice, and actual relief. Division II and CCAA are outside scope.

  • Under BIA subsection 34(1), a trustee may ask the court for directions on a matter affecting administration of a bankrupt’s estate. The court gives in writing whatever directions, if any, it considers proper in the circumstances. Subsection 66(1) is the statutory link to Division I proposals. It applies the Act’s provisions other than Part III, Division II only so far as applicable and with the modifications required by the circumstances. A trustee’s use of subsection 34(1) in a Division I matter is therefore subject to that applicability limit.

    section-34.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • For an application made under subsection 34(1), subsection 34(3) requires the trustee to tell the Superintendent’s division office the hearing day and time. Subsection 34(2) separately concerns estates unfinished three years after bankruptcy and a report to the court if the Superintendent requests one. The directions application in subsection 34(1) has no corresponding three-year trigger.

    section-34.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 37 addresses a different application. A bankrupt, creditor or other person aggrieved by a trustee’s act or decision may apply to the court, which may confirm, reverse or modify the act or decision and make a just order. Subsection 66(1) supplies the same applicability and necessary-modification qualifications when considering that provision in Division I.

    section-37.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • In the Guo Law Corporation proposal, the trustee’s May 17, 2021 report identified its application as one for advice and directions under subsection 34(1). The report followed court approval of the proposal and described stalled administration. Its requested relief included authority to conduct property sales subject to later court approval and directions releasing funds held by counsel. These are the applicant’s requests in that proceeding.

    Third%20Report%20Final%20with%20Ex · cfcanada.fticonsulting.com

Canada BIA Division I proposal trustee discharge and release

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

Prior R029 findings screened. E198W covers account taxation, objections and discharge procedure. E199N already separates full-performance certification from discharge and explains section 62 claim scope. E194I and E195I cover the proposal stay and post-default paths. E199V-C004 covers subsections 41(10)–(11) on incidental administration and possible court appointment for remaining bankruptcy assets, subject to subsection 66(1). E196G-C005 covers the underlying disciplinary powers. E200C-C001–C002 covers furnishing and court-directed enforcement of trustee security. E199E covers third-party releases. The present claims add the qualified subsection 41(7)–(9) effects and limits. Hold a particular release or revocation. Obtain the court’s discharge order, proposal and relevant directions, the trustee’s role in the disputed act, and decision-specific authority before resolving alleged non-fraud breaches of trust, negligence, independent-capacity or post-discharge conduct, leave, procedure, limitation periods or the effect on a pending suit. Subsection 41(7)’s operative text refers to fraud. Its marginal note mentions breach of trust without creating a separate blanket exception. Hold the effect of a discharge on an accrued or pending claim under a particular cash security, bond or suretyship, including any conditions, prior enforcement direction or security rights following revocation. Inspect the instrument and orders for the file. OSB Form 10 is an application for an order. BIA subsection 41(9) ties release to the discharge under section 41. A statutory power to require restitution to the estate under paragraph 14.01(1)(f) leaves any individual civil remedy to its own authority. Hold outcomes in specific disciplinary files and any inference that release of trustee security alters debtor collateral or third-party guarantees. Division I use of section 41 is conditioned on subsection 66(1). The operative subsection 41(7) refers to results of fraud. The marginal note does not establish a general breach-of-trust exception. Preserve the distinction among discharge liability release, revocation grounds, regulatory proceedings, restitution to the estate, and release of subsection 16(1) security. Form 10 is an application for a discharge order and corresponding release. Preserve holds on specific release or revocation, private action outcomes or procedure, and accrued or pending security rights and effects of revocation. The approved proposal’s creditor claim effects remain separate.