Business operating debts · Page 3 of 3

Selected findings from library records with scoped primary-source review.

Research reference · Consumer guides and topic map

Plain-English guides on this topic

Canada BIA Division I proposal unclaimed dividend search and individual creditor claims

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E199V-C002–C003 already covers statutory remittance, the entitlement mechanism for the proper dividend on the remitted list, the CAD 30 fee per dividend, business documentation and discretion to request more proof or to refuse insufficient claims. E200N adopts incremental OSB search and individual documentation procedure and cites the Division I landing page for applicability. No calculation is necessary. The official instructions and official form are published procedural material. Paper-mail instructions do not establish the availability or exclusivity of an electronic route, processing turnaround, or the outcome of an application. No claimant record was queried. The database coverage date describes public search coverage and does not establish a claim cutoff. The supporting procedure concerns the listed unclaimed dividend and does not resolve ownership of undistributed funds or eligibility for a particular claimant. The wider R029 assignment remains open. Scope is OSB search and an individual creditor’s documentation and paper submission in Division I. April 1, 1994 is public database coverage for OSB receipts and does not establish a claim cutoff. The declaration-based substitute for database address proof is discretionary. Follow the representative instructions and form together for authority documentation. Cheque and optional direct deposit refer to disbursement and are separate from the previously covered filing fee. Preserve holds on electronic availability or exclusivity, timing, ownership of undistributed funds and claimant-specific eligibility or decision. No claimant record was queried.

Canada BIA Division I creditor payment dispute after proposal funding

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

Screened R029 scoped reviews and task findings and the claim, coverage and expansion indexes for 1482241, 31-2303814, Hussaini, the amount, and the dividend provisions. E199N and E199R cover performance certification and Form 46. E199V covers retained balances and unclaimed dividends, E198W covers expense taxation and accounts, E196N covers proof disallowance appeals under section 135, E195I covers default and annulment, E200F covers trustee directions under section 34 and E200J covers trustee release and discharge. E200R adds a specific funded-proposal payment dispute and signed distribution order, and the statutory dividend withholding route as a qualified comparator. Hold any assertion that the 2022 payment order followed issuance of a section 65.3 certificate. Tenth Report paragraphs 18 and 35 put addressing the remaining claims and proposed distributions before certification. The record does not verify the date of full debtor performance, the issued statutory certificate, actual payment or clearance for each creditor, or filing of Schedule A and effective discharge. Hold the procedure and effect of an actual post-certification or post-discharge payment dispute pending the issued certificate, court orders, proposal terms, payment records and authority on remedy, limitations and reopening. The court authorized an unopposed motion in this file. Hold generalization of the file-specific fund, approval timetable, payment amounts, or release. Hold whether subsection 148(2) or (3) applies in a particular Division I file, including the proposal terms, inspector authority and direction, timing, and court orders. No such application was verified in the 1482241 Ontario Limited order. The public motion record and Tenth Report establish the proposal terms, funds held in the proceeding and the requested sequence. The signed order and endorsement establish unopposed authorization on February 7, 2022. Independently summed all six gross order entries to $307,421.32. Preserve holds on actual section 65.3 certification or its date, receipt of payments, filing of Schedule A and effective trustee discharge, and remedies for an actual post-certification or post-discharge dispute. Section 148 is a qualified statutory comparator via section 66(1), with its use in this file and applicability in other files held.

  • Under BIA subsection 60(2), proposal money is paid to the trustee, which distributes it to creditors after paying the proper fees and expenses. Subsection 60(4) applies the section 147 levy to these distributions. In 1482241 Ontario Limited, amended proposal paragraph 6.1(b) tied performance of the debtor’s obligation to payment of the proposal proceeds to the trustee and separately provided for trustee distributions on proven claims. Paragraphs 6.4 and 6.6 gave the ordinary creditor payment formula and preserved the specified default fund until the required payments were made, even if a certificate had issued. This is a file-specific illustration of why evidence of debtor funding alone does not establish an individual creditor’s payment.

    FullText.html · laws.justice.gc.ca 1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-1482 · www.crowe.com

  • In 1482241 Ontario Limited, the Tenth Report described a court-guided process for resolving disputes over creditor claims and reported that counsel held the sale proceeds. The trustee requested authority to pay six remaining claims in full. On February 7, 2022, Justice Conway recorded that the motion was unopposed and that debtor’s counsel lacked instructions to oppose full payment. Paragraphs 8–10 of the signed order authorized paying the six listed amounts from sale proceeds less the applicable levy, allowed payment of the levy, and directed distribution of the remaining proceeds to debtor’s counsel after the authorized payments. The listed claims totaled $307,421.32 before levy. The endorsement and order establish unopposed payment authorization and no contested determination of the six claims on their merits.

    1482241-ontario-limited--dist-and- · www.crowe.com 1482241-ontario-limited--endt-in-t · www.crowe.com 1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-1482 · www.crowe.com

  • In this file, the Tenth Report identified addressing the disputed claims as the final step before certifying full performance and proposed completing the distributions before filing the proposal completion certificate. BIA section 65.3 provides for a prescribed certificate to the debtor and official receiver when the proposal is fully performed. Paragraph 11 of the February 7 order made the trustee’s discharge conditional on the authorized payments and filing a separate Schedule A Discharge Certificate with the court. The public record therefore supports a payment dispute after trustee receipt of sale proceeds used to fund the proposal. It does not establish that the dispute arose after actual section 65.3 certification or that the authorized amounts were ultimately received.

    FullText.html · laws.justice.gc.ca 1482241-ontario-limited--dist-and- · www.crowe.com 1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-1482 · www.crowe.com

  • BIA subsection 148(2) requires sufficient funds to be retained for a claim whose validity remains undetermined, to cover payment if it is admitted. Subsection 148(3) bars an action for a dividend against the trustee and permits a court order for payment and potentially personal interest and costs on a creditor’s application when the trustee has refused or failed to pay after inspectors directed payment. Section 66(1) imports other BIA provisions into Division I only insofar as applicable and with necessary modifications. The 1482241 Ontario Limited payment authorization does not establish that this particular statutory route was invoked or that it is available in every proposal.

    FullText.html · laws.justice.gc.ca 1482241-ontario-limited--dist-and- · www.crowe.com

Canada BIA Division I levy on trustee distributions

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E200R addresses a payment dispute after proposal funding and records a 2022 order allowing deduction of the applicable levy. E199V addresses proposal completion accounts and reporting the levy. E198W addresses expense taxation. The E200V increment addresses the statutory cash and noncash trigger, deduction, rule tiers and maximum, specified statutory costs, and the OSB source-deductions position. File-specific in-kind valuation, rounding, method of satisfying the levy and any actual remittance remain open. The Nabis report documents a contemplated treatment. Check the operative proposal, approval order, trustee calculations, and disbursement records for a specific file. An official Directive 10R PDF was identified on the OSB index but the browser returned zero numbered text lines and screenshot cache misses. The accessible unofficial HTML discusses the trustee’s capacity, agency/receivership/mandatary roles and BIA subsection 128(3) redemptions. The candidate leaves proposed application of those exceptions to Division I distributions open pending official text and verified applicable authority. The OSB note’s limited-funds branch is expressly for summary administrations. Its no-proven-creditors discussion is explanatory context. No special no-creditor, insufficient-funds, staged-payment allocation or bankruptcy-conversion calculation is established here. Check the applicable regime and administration records before applying the general example to those settings. Verification used the displayed Justice Laws Act and Rules consolidations through 2026-10-19. No overarching Canada, R029, or publication disposition follows. Verified Rule 123 lines 30–49 in the original Justice Laws return and a fresh official result. The review-sealed derivative normalizes the rewritten-result URL header only; all numbered lines are identical. Independently recomputed the CAD 2.4 million example: 50,000 plus 12,500 plus zero equals 62,500; net 2,337,500; the 10% gross allocation is 240,000 less 6,250, leaving 233,750. OSB source-deductions guidance is attributed regulatory interpretation and Nabis is a file-specific proposal trustee report. Preserve holds on actual in-kind valuation, rounding, method or remittance, Directive 10R exceptions, no-creditor or limited funds and staged or conversion calculations.

  • Under BIA subsection 60(2), proposal money goes to the trustee and the trustee distributes it to creditors after paying proper fees and expenses. Subsection 60(3) covers proposal distributions of promissory notes and other evidence of obligations by or on behalf of the debtor and, for corporate debtors, shares of the corporation, using the subsection (2) process as nearly as possible. Subsection 60(4) applies section 147 to trustee distributions under both subsections.

    section-60.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • BIA subsection 147(1) imposes the supervision levy on payments the trustee makes by dividend or otherwise on account of creditors’ claims, including Crown creditor claims for taxes or other amounts. The levy goes to the Superintendent for deposit with the Receiver General. Under subsection 147(2) the trustee allocates the levy proportionately across payments and deducts it before making them.

    section-147.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • General Rule 123(2) applies 5% to the first CAD 1,000,000 of eligible payments, 1.25% to the next CAD 1,000,000 and 0% marginally above CAD 2,000,000. The rate schedule yields a maximum levy of CAD 62,500. Rules 123(1) and (3) contain separate general and summary-administration schedules.

    section-123.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Section 147(1) expressly excludes the costs specified by BIA subsection 70(2). That subsection concerns one qualifying legal bill, including the executing officer and land registration fees, payable to the creditor who first attached by garnishment or first filed the specified process against property of the bankrupt. Whether a cost qualifies turns on the statutory category and the proceeding.

    section-147.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-70.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • In its August 2020 position paper, OSB states that the levy does not apply when the Crown is paid amounts deemed held in trust for unremitted source deductions under the specified provisions of the Income Tax Act, Canada Pension Plan or Employment Insurance Act. OSB also says amounts paid under those deemed trusts are left out of the levy calculation. Its paper describes equivalent treatment for similar provincial provisions under BIA subsection 67(3), subject to verifying the particular provision.

    levy-unremitted-source-deductions- · ised-isde.canada.ca

  • OSB also treats amounts paid to the federal Crown on an Income Tax Act subsection 224(1.2) demand for a creditor’s unremitted source deductions as property claims outside the levy. OSB explains that the six-month full-payment requirement in BIA subsection 60(1.1), subject to Crown consent, governs the timing of recovery and leaves the classification of that property claim intact. This is the regulator’s published interpretation of those fact patterns.

    levy-unremitted-source-deductions- · ised-isde.canada.ca section-60.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • In its report to creditors for Nabis Holdings Inc., the proposal trustee said that new secured notes, new common shares and other proposal payments would attract the levy, which the report described as payable in the same form of consideration as the distributions. This documents the treatment proposed in that file.

    report-to-creditors.pdf · cdncases.alixpartners.com

  • Assume one CAD 2,400,000 aggregate pool of ordinary levy-bearing cash payments before the levy, after proper trustee fees and expenses, with no excluded payments and all amounts determined at once. The bands produce CAD 50,000, CAD 12,500 and CAD 0, respectively. Deducting the CAD 62,500 levy leaves CAD 2,337,500. A creditor allocated 10% of the gross eligible pool would receive CAD 240,000 minus CAD 6,250, or CAD 233,750. Amounts are exact to the cent.

    section-147.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-60.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-123.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada BIA Division I proposal levy remittance and reporting

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E200V covers statutory charge, deduction and recipient, proposal rates, exclusions, Crown property, in-kind illustration and a worked example. E199V-C001 already records Form 12 levy accounting generally, and E199V-C002 covers BIA section 154 remittances. E200Z adds RA1 and reconciliation mechanics, electronic advice and receipt limitations, an actual Division I category in the regulator's example of outstanding balances, a conditional final-remittance clock, and precise Form 12 levy fields. E199N/E200J address completion and discharge milestones, E198W expense taxation and E200R disputed payment and a case-specific levy deduction. The 45-day period is OSB operating guidance keyed to filing a listed notice. The identified Division I sample has a blank due-date field, with no explanation. Form 15 and Form 58 are listed as other triggers in the general guidance. Hold a universal Division I deadline, an OSB due date for an individual estate, any deadline for interim or staged remittance, any deemed-discharge or special-order route, an extension or sanction, and any post-default conversion crossover. Do not start the clock with Form 46, the proposal's full-performance date, the dividend notice mailing date or the date of the discharge order on this evidence. The documented cheque path and electronic submission of advice establish different administrative actions. Hold a current electronic funds settlement channel for the levy, whether cheque is exclusive, a file's actual payment or OSB posting, any treatment of adjustments or disputed balances, and exact accounting or valuation of in-kind remittance. The historical e-filing screenshots are examples. File-specific receipt should be established from estate-matched accounts and available payment and OSB acknowledgement or receipt records. The presence of creditor-class fields on Form 12 supplies the reporting layout. Taxability, whether a payment bears the levy, and whether a creditor class participates depend on the governing law and proposal. This increment grants no wider R029, Canada or publication disposition. OSB operating guidance provides 45 calendar days from filing a listed notice with OSB, inclusive of the objection period. In Division I, apply the Form 11 statement only where Form 11 applies and has been filed; its separate 15-day final-dividend timing runs from mailing. The Division I example’s published amount due less amount received matches its outstanding amount and its due-date cell is blank, with no explanation. Preserve holds on any universal or individual deadline, interim or staged remittance, special order or deemed discharge application, extension, sanction and conversion. Electronic advice acknowledgement evidences submission for review and does not establish settlement or estate receipt. Preserve payment-channel, valuation and accounting holds.

  • The OSB's published cheque process uses Form RA1 for the levy and a cheque payable to the Receiver General for Canada. The advice accompanies the payment. Select Levy as the sole remittance type on that form and list the cheques. Registration fees and the levy use separate advice forms. OSB designates Form RA2 for unclaimed dividends.

    remittance-advice-form-ra1 · ised-isde.canada.ca remittance-advice-forms · ised-isde.canada.ca

  • RA1 asks for the trustee and licence number and identifies each amount by cheque number, OSB district and estate number, estate name and administration type. If one cheque covers multiple estates, the estate entries for that cheque must subtotal to the cheque amount. The cheque amounts must add to the total remittance entered on the form.

    remittance-advice-form-ra1 · ised-isde.canada.ca

  • OSB describes electronic submission of remittance advice from the trustee's practice-management software. Its e-filing manual directs the filer to upload a REMADV XML file and record its reference number. Format validation precedes OSB review and the sample acknowledgement says pending review. The acknowledgement confirms transmission of the advice. The manual separately describes the cheques sent to OSB.

    remittance-advice-forms · ised-isde.canada.ca e-filing-manual_2024-02-en.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca

  • The OSB e-filing manual shows estate-level remittance type, amount due, amount received, amount outstanding and the due-date field. The statement can support preparation of RA1. The published sample explicitly displays a Division I levy with amount due, a partial amount received, a remaining balance and an empty due-date field. This is an illustration of reporting, with no stated reason for the blank date.

    e-filing-manual_2024-02-en.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca

  • OSB's remittance guidance gives the trustee 45 calendar days from filing Form 11, 15 or 58 with OSB to pay the levy, including the objection period within those 45 days. In Division I, the BIA's other provisions apply insofar as applicable and with the modifications the circumstances require. Where Form 11 applies and is filed, the agency guidance uses its OSB filing date as the levy-payment trigger. Form 11 separately contains a 15-day final-dividend notice after mailing and accompanies the taxed final statement and dividend sheet.

    remittance-advice-forms · ised-isde.canada.ca section-152.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca form-11-notice-final-dividend-and- · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • The post-2009 Form 12 for proceedings other than summary administrations and consumer proposals presents the section 147 levy payable at item 26. Items 27–29 show dividends with levy deducted for secured, preferred and unsecured categories, with separate interim and final lines for unsecured creditors. These are reporting fields. Establishing actual receipt requires payment evidence for the specific estate.

    form-12-statement-receipts-and-dis · ised-isde.canada.ca e-filing-manual_2024-02-en.pdf · ised-isde.canada.ca

Canada BIA Division I interim dividend documentation and limits

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

Exact prior screen. E200Z covers RA1, electronic remittance advice, OSB outstanding levy fields, conditional final remittance timing and Form 12 ledger lines. E200V covers rates and levy mechanics. E199V and E200N cover retained funds and unclaimed dividends at closeout. E194M handles general distribution duties. E196N covers proof disallowance and its appeal. E198O covers file access, E198W final taxation, and E200R the February 2022 distribution order and subsections 148(2)–(3) as qualified comparators. The incremental scope here is sections 149–150, notice evidence, the OSB interim sheet metadata and the distinct 2019 draft and entered order. Apply sections 149–150 and Rules 6 and 112 only where applicable under subsection 66(1) and with required modifications. Hold file-specific eligibility, whether or when notice was validly sent or received, the calculation of a calendar deadline, any stay or extension, proof and adjudication dates, available cash, the appropriate amount for reserves, tax priority, and whether a particular creditor has a remedy. Obtain the approved proposal, claims and service record, applicable tax provisions, inspector directions and court orders. The subsection 149(3) filing alternative and subsection 149(4) declaration restriction use different triggers. The OSB designates Dividend Sheet as a separate electronic document. The direct VTSdocs target returned a cache miss and a www variant was inaccessible. The OSB alternative VTS_2006-07 schema documentation is usable for its displayed field definitions only. Hold current production acceptance, required filing frequency, filing deadline, notice recipients, and any universally prescribed interim form. The e-filing manual lookup failed because the document exceeded the tool limit. Hold interim levy remittance deadline and method as in E200Z, along with applying Directive 5R8 to a non-bankrupt Division I proposal while the identified wording is held in abeyance. The published appendix contains the entered June 2019 order after the trustee's case-index link returned a cache miss. Case identity follows the full caption and court/estate number 31-2303814. The OCR of the order's recital displays 1482240 while the caption and case index identify 1482241. Hold proof of actual creditor payment and reconciliation, any later order or amendment, and any direct finding that sections 148–150 were applied. The case is a documentation example confined to the June order. This candidate supplies no wider R029, Canada or publication disposition. Rules 6 and 112 use review-sealed copies with only official result URL headers normalized. Section 149 exclusion, extension and tax-return clocks remain distinct from eligible late proof under section 150. Rule 112 concerns sufficient notice of admission from receipt of a dividend notice. The historical vendor-testing schema establishes displayed fields only. The June 6, 2019 entered Conway order in 31-2303814 authorizes CAD 2.2 million to the company plus approved fees and retains the remainder. The cover and file number resolve the inconsistent recital OCR. Preserve holds on actual dividend payment, later orders, case application of sections 148–150, production filing requirements and remittance.

  • Where BIA subsection 149(1) applies to a Division I proposal through subsection 66(1), the trustee may send notice after the first creditors’ meeting to persons with known claims they have yet to prove. The notice gives 30 days after sending to prove the claim before the trustee proceeds to declare a dividend or final dividend without taking it into account. Rule 6 gives default delivery methods where the Act and Rules supply no other method, and requires the trustee to keep an affidavit or other proof that the notice was given or sent.

    section-149.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-6.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Where section 149 applies in Division I, subsection (2) excludes a notified claim from all dividends when proof misses the stated time and any court extension. The court may extend time on proof of merits and a satisfactory explanation for delay. Timely notice from a taxing authority that it intends to file when quantified extends its filing time to three months or longer if the court allows. Subsection (3) gives claims under listed enactments an alternative three-month filing period measured from filing of the relevant return or other evidence, or from when that material comes to the responsible minister’s attention. Where subsection (4) applies, declaration of any dividend must wait three months after the trustee files all required returns unless the trustee keeps sufficient funds for possible subsection (3) claims.

    section-149.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • When section 150 applies and the claim remains eligible, proof after declaration entitles the creditor to any missed dividends from money then held by the trustee before it is used for future dividends. Earlier distributions can be disturbed on grounds of missed participation only on terms the court orders. Check whether subsection 149(2) has already excluded the claim before assessing a late-proof request.

    section-149.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-150.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Where applicable to a Division I proposal, Rule 112 makes a dividend notice received by the creditor sufficient notice of admission of the claim. That rule concerns evidence of admission. The subsection 149(1) notice concerns a claim that has yet to be proved. A dividend notice establishes admission under Rule 112, while proof of funds transfer requires the applicable payment record.

    section-149.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca page-5.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The OSB separately lists a Dividend Sheet in its form schema index. Its published vendor-testing documentation recognizes Interim as a submission type and includes unsecured creditor details for the claim, interim payment, gross dividend, levy and net dividend. These fields describe the electronic document. The documentation provides no universal interim filing schedule or independent authority to distribute.

    schemaIndex.html · ised-isde.canada.ca DividendSheet.html · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • In the 1482241 Ontario Limited proposal, the trustee’s Eighth Report describes a draft schedule for paying undisputed creditors while setting funds aside for disputed claims in full and for future professional costs. The June 6, 2019 Conway order entered in the same court file authorized a $2.2 million distribution to the debtor and payment of approved professional fees, with the remaining sale proceeds held in trust pending a further order. Accordingly this record shows a proposed interim creditor dividend and a separate order governing what the trustee could then release.

    1482241-ontario-limited--8rpt-of-t · www.crowe.com 1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-the- · www.crowe.com

Canada BIA Division I court-ordered disputed-claim reserves and proof deadlines

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

E201D-C001–C003 cover BIA sections 149–150, Rule 6 proof of sending, statutory exclusion and tax reserves, and eligible late proof following declaration. E201D-C004–C006 cover Rule 112 admission notice, OSB interim sheet fields, and the May proposal and June 6, 2019 Conway order. E201D expressly holds later orders. E200R-C001–C004 cover the February 7, 2022 distribution order, performance and discharge limits, and subsections 148(2)–(3) as qualified comparators. E201I’s incremental claims concern the December schedule, December contested-claim process, July signed reserve direction, and the distinct operation of the proposal’s proof notice provision in the record. Screened R029 reviews and task material, the claim and coverage indexes and expansion queue for Adjudication Process Order, December 2019 response/forfeiture, July 27/Allevio, and the distinctive reserve amounts. E196N covers section 135 proof disallowance and appeal. E194M covers general distribution duties, E199V/E200N retained funds and unclaimed dividends at closeout, E198W fee taxation, E200V/E200Z levy terms and remittance, and E200F court directions. The July order supplies direct case-specific proof of the holdback under that order. The packet holds any generalization or finding that a particular statutory section compelled it. Hold actual transfer, receipt, collection and segregation of funds, the amount retained for any individual unresolved claim, the calculation supporting the $236,000 and its levy, and universal application of a full-face reserve. The order supplies case-specific authority and does not cite BIA subsection 148(2). Hold the actual booked reserve, bank balances, whether either subtotal was corrected, the effect of later settlements and the final accounting. The paragraph 24 schedule is a trustee proposal. The July 2020 signed order is the independently identified holdback direction. Hold particular service or response dates, creditor-specific forfeiture and any later scheduling orders. The Allevio appeal appears in the scheduling clause. Hold any application of the response-forfeiture clause to that appellant or to a person outside the order’s covered creditors. The Appendix C transcription anomalously reads ‘has been filed or proved’ in the description of recipients. Hold the exact recipient wording pending image verification and avoid treating it as proof of any mailing. Hold notice content and sending, implementation and calendar dates, any extensions or exceptions, actual claim treatment under BIA sections 149–150 and whether a late claimant recovered. The general late-proof rule is addressed in E201D. Verified signed December 6, 2019 Pattillo and July 27, 2020 Conway order captures and distinct deadlines and scope. The seven Ninth Report paragraph 10 entries total CAD 319,775.01, which is CAD 0.18 less than paragraph 24. Substitution reconciles to CAD 157,808.05, while the printed subtotal gives CAD 157,807.87. These are reconciliations of proposed figures only. Preserve holds on actual reserves, transfer, levy calculation, specific service or forfeiture, statutory application and the anomalous article 4.3 recipient wording. The proof notice trigger is separate from responding to claim objections.

  • In the proposal of 1482241 Ontario Limited, the signed July 27, 2020 consent order of Justice Conway directed the Proposal Trustee to retain in trust the full amounts of the remaining contested claims pending further court order. Separate paragraphs directed releases of $200,000 in trust to Allevio’s lawyers and $6,500 to Daiken’s lawyers. A separate $236,000 release was directed to the debtor’s lawyers, with the order describing it by reference to the uncontested portions and the levy. Paragraph 7 preserved the proposal terms and the parties’ obligations.

    1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-1482 · www.crowe.com

  • The Ninth Report’s December interim schedule allocated separate lines for undisputed creditors, disputed creditors, the Allevio claim, professional fees, a $350,000 return to the debtor and a remaining estate holdback. Allevio’s entire $486,050.06 asserted claim appears in the proposed schedule, although the report describes a $201,903.98 partial disallowance under appeal. The disputed-creditor subtotal printed in paragraph 24 differs by $0.18 from paragraph 10. The seven entries in paragraph 10 sum to $319,775.01, which reconciles to the displayed $157,808.05 residual.

    1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-1482 · www.crowe.com 1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-the- · www.crowe.com

  • In the same proceeding, the signed December 6, 2019 Pattillo order approved the Ninth Report paragraph 17 procedure for disputed claims and scheduled a January 17, 2020 attendance. Paragraph 17 called for the debtor to notify the disputed creditors of its position by December 13, 2019 and for those creditors to respond by January 6, 2020 to preserve their claims. It also contemplated case scheduling for the objections, including the Allevio appeal. The order separately authorized specified distributions and later amounts agreed in writing by the trustee, debtor and applicable creditor.

    1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-1482 · www.crowe.com 1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-the- · www.crowe.com

  • Article 4.3 of the amended proposal filed in the same case calls for a BIA section 149 notice promptly after the implementation date. It ties the proof deadline to 30 days after mailing, specifies a final dividend and states that the bar is subject to subsections 149(2)–(4). Article 4.1 requires proof for voting or distribution. The article 4.3 proof deadline and the Pattillo order’s deadline to respond to the debtor’s objection use separate triggers and address different stages of a claim.

    1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-1482 · www.crowe.com 1482241-ontario-limited-mr-of-the- · www.crowe.com

Canada BIA Division I disputed-claim holdbacks and payment triggers

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

The standing-spool E201L reservation calls for a distinct statutory claims reserve or payment pending appeal beyond E201I. Screened R029 findings, claims, prior candidates and exact case-name, file-number, and provisional-execution terms. E201I covers the Toronto proceeding’s July 2020 full-amount trust order, December 2019 trustee schedule and procedure, and proposal proof notice. E201D covers §§149–150 and notice/late proofs. E200R-C004 already records §§66(1) and 148(2)–(3), E196N records §135 proof adjudication and appeal, and E197M-C003 records §195. E200F-C004 uses the same Guo report for subsection 34(1) directions and requested sale/funds relief. E201L adds the Malone’s approved proposal’s distribution-based holdback, release deadline and unstayed sanction condition, and the Guo trustee’s historical linkage of the proposal reserve to funds for proven claims plus its contemporaneous report of an adjourned disallowance appeal. Hold direct standalone subsection 148(2) application in a Division I adjudication to a proof already disallowed but pending court appeal, its application in either cited proceeding, and any general appeal-triggered statutory payment rule. The two records support authority under their proposal terms and the trustee’s explicitly attributed account. Section 149 tax reserves and late-proved claims are outside this increment. The sources do not document a creditor-level reserve transaction, payment receipt, actual chronology of a further appellate stay, or a general threshold for finality. The wider R029 task, Canada coverage and publication remain open. Verified the May 14, 2021 Justice Walker order in B-210092 approving the April 13 further amended Malone’s proposal and incorporating Schedule B. The section 3.3 reserve is the distributable amount if proven, and the ten-day timer runs from determination to the extent proven. Sections 5.1(d) and 5.2 govern the unstayed sanction condition. Guo is attributed to the May 2021 trustee report. Preserve holds on direct section 148(2) application to an appealed disallowance, whether this statute was applied to either case, creditor-level transactions, appellate chronology and general finality.

  • Justice Walker’s entered order approved the April 13, 2021 further amended proposal for Malone’s Social Lounge and Taphouse Inc. Schedule B §3.3 withheld distribution on a disputed unsecured claim until and to the extent it became a Proven Claim through agreement or the claims process. Pending resolution by agreement or court order, the trustee was required to keep the amount payable under the proposal if the disputed claim were proven. It then had 10 days from the determination to distribute the appropriate payment to the extent proven. The proposal directs that withheld amounts for claims that do not become Proven Claims be dealt with in accordance with the BIA.

    Entered%20Order%20Approving%20Prop · cfcanada.fticonsulting.com

  • The Guo Law Corporation proposal trustee reported in May 2021 that counsel had advised it of funds sufficient to pay the proven unsecured claims in full. The trustee reported that the proposal required a reserve for disputed claims out of distributions, so those funds could not pay the proven claims in full without an amendment or resolution of the disputes. The same report identified one disputed claim, Sun’s, as disallowed and appealed, with the appeal generally adjourned by agreement and no further resolution activity reported to that point.

    Third%20Report%20Final%20with%20Ex · cfcanada.fticonsulting.com

  • The entered Malone’s order makes the proposal effective as of its Implementation Date. Schedule B §§5.1(d) and 5.2 require a granted, unstayed sanction order as a nonwaivable condition. Section 195 of the BIA addresses proceedings under an appealed court order or judgment, subject to provisional execution and the Court of Appeal’s or its judge’s power to vary or cancel the stay or provisional execution order. This supplies a separate implementation question from the §3.3 holdback during adjudication of an individual proof.

    Entered%20Order%20Approving%20Prop · cfcanada.fticonsulting.com FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • Where it applies through BIA subsection 66(1), subsection 148(2) measures the trustee’s reserve by what is sufficient to provide for payment if the claim of undetermined validity is admitted. In the approved Malone’s proposal, §3.3 supplies a case-specific measure and a release trigger, and §7.2 uses the BIA claims procedure. BIA subsection 135(4) addresses finality of a trustee determination or disallowance and the recipient’s appeal to the court. Its text supplies no reserve calculation, no distribution date and no direction that filing that appeal itself authorizes payment.

    Entered%20Order%20Approving%20Prop · cfcanada.fticonsulting.com section-135.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-148.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

Canada Division I proposal redetermination of a decisive non-arm’s-length creditor vote

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

Prior screen of R029 adopted findings, reviews, claim and coverage indexes, and active queue found E194A-C006 covers section 54(3) and the trustee’s own vote. E194A-C004 and C012 cover the two limbs and chair disputes. E198F-C005 covers section 51(3) appeal and section 115.1 orders. E198J addresses proxies, notice, and the casting-vote limit. E199A-C003 concerns Down Under’s sole related creditor and alternative requested relief. E191E-C006 covers section 4 in the CCAA avoidance context and E190K-C004 covers CCAA related-creditor voting. No prior R029 finding on Finetex, 2019 ONSC 5793, or the subsection 109(6) redetermination procedure was found. Contextual overlapping propositions are carried only to explain the distinct application. Hold how the enacted lookback endpoint is adapted to a proposal with no date of bankruptcy, a general test for reincluding a vote, exact timeliness in Finetex and the express disposal of the cross-motion. MNP’s numbered endorsement return contains paragraphs 1–5 only and its order PDF yielded zero numbered lines. No independent case analysis rests on snippets or a secondary summary. Verified the reconvened August 29, 2019 minutes, responsive cross-motion and October 7 Justice Penny endorsement. Independent tally: three of four is 75%; CAD 2,149.17 divided by CAD 3,551,299.17 is about 0.06051785%, rounding to 0.06%; excluding the negative vote leaves 100% in both displayed measures. Both tables omit eleven deemed votes. Preserve the enacted subsection 109(6) period and conditional subsection 66(1) application; hold adapting the endpoint to a non-bankrupt proposal, timeliness, a general reinclusion test and express disposal of the cross-motion.

  • A related creditor’s ability to cast a vote against a Division I proposal under subsection 54(3) does not guarantee that the ballot stays in the tally. Under subsection 109(6), the chair must exclude a non-arm’s-length creditor’s vote and redetermine the result if the chair considers that vote outcome-determinative and the statutory period is met. As enacted, that period starts one year before the initial bankruptcy event and ends on the date of bankruptcy. Subsection 66(1) applies other provisions to Division I insofar as applicable, with necessary modifications. Directive 22R4 lists a non-arm’s-length creditor as permitted to vote on a proposal subject to redetermination. The Finetex minutes document actual application under Division I.

    section-109.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-54.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-66.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca motion-record-returnable-september · mnpdebt.ca directive-no-22r4-proofs-claim-pro · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • For the voting screen, apply the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act’s relationship tests, including specified family relationships, entity control and common control. Related persons are deemed not to deal at arm’s length while related. For persons outside those relationships, arm’s-length dealing at a particular time is a question of fact. In Finetex, the chair applied the statutory relationship and deeming rules to the debtor’s 100% shareholder.

    section-4.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca motion-record-returnable-september · mnpdebt.ca

  • The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy’s current Directive 22R4 instructions for paragraph 7 say claimants must indicate whether they are related to the debtor under section 4 or dealt with the debtor in a non-arm’s-length manner. Paragraph 8 calls for a list of all payments or credits received or granted for the three months before the initial bankruptcy event, or the twelve months preceding that event for claimant and debtor not dealing at arm’s length. The directive identifies bankruptcy or proposal in these instructions.

    directive-no-22r4-proofs-claim-pro · www.ised-isde.canada.ca

  • The August 29, 2019 minutes of FT EnE Canada’s reconvened meeting show three votes in favour worth C$2,149.17 and one against worth C$3,549,150, admitted for voting only and marked objected to. As tallied, the affirmative side had 75% in number and 0.06% in value. The chair excluded the parent’s decisive negative vote under subsection 109(6), citing its 100% ownership and the section 4 deeming rule. The redetermined tally was three in favour and zero against, 100% by number and value. The minutes say both tables exclude the eleven creditors deemed proven and in favour under section 3.4 of the amended proposal.

    section-54.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca motion-record-returnable-september · mnpdebt.ca

  • Subsection 109(6) makes the chair’s redetermined result operative unless, on application within ten days after the day of that redetermination, the court considers inclusion appropriate and determines another outcome. Finetex’s cross-motion sought inclusion of its negative vote. Justice Penny’s October 7, 2019 endorsement records the exclusion, the parent’s opposition to court approval and its objection to the proposed director release. The endorsement states that the motion to approve the proposal was granted.

    section-109.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca endorsement-of-justice-penny-appro · mnpdebt.ca responding-record-moving-party-fin · mnpdebt.ca

  • In the FT EnE Canada record, the chair recommended a temporary adjournment over unsettled amendments and the meeting passed the motion. When the meeting reconvened, the company presented an amended proposal following negotiations. The minutes say the amendments did not resolve all of the parent creditor’s concerns. The parent maintained its opposition and later sought to have its vote included in the tally.

    endorsement-of-justice-penny-appro · mnpdebt.ca motion-record-returnable-september · mnpdebt.ca responding-record-moving-party-fin · mnpdebt.ca

Canada Division I proposal vote disqualification for improper purpose

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

The reported disposition concerns the voting order. The entered order, subsequent vote tally, proposal approval and distributions remain unverified. The court removed the vote under section 115.1. Hold any general ruling that subsection 187(9) alone supplies the same remedy in every Division I vote challenge. Hold any bright-line rule based on a particular demand, a voting percentage, disagreement with an appraisal or low expected recovery. Hold how courts outside British Columbia would apply the decision on other facts. The appellate reasons preserve the underlying registrar decision, but the separately located applicant book presents an incomplete registrar reproduction in the numbered return. Do not claim verification of the signed or entered order. Exact filing deadlines, notice requirements, post-appeal history and later treatment are outside this scoped evidence. Verified court-authored October 20, 2017 oral appellate reasons, 2017 BCSC 1970, Vancouver docket B160890, reproduced in the filed book of authorities. These reasons identify the August 25 registrar order indexed at 2017 BCSC 1503 and record dismissal with costs. A standalone court-hosted version and signed or entered order were not retrieved. Keep section 115.1 as the case power and subsection 187(9) as the origin of threshold wording. Preserve holds on later vote, approval, payment, filing procedure and application outside the case facts.

  • In West Coast Logistics, District Registrar Nielsen disqualified Prudential, the debtor’s largest unsecured creditor and a creditor with enough debt to block acceptance, from voting on a Division I proposal. The order was made under section 115.1. Justice Milman dismissed Prudential’s appeal with costs to West Coast Logistics.

    book-of-authorities-of-concord-re- · cdncases.alixpartners.com section-115.1.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • In West Coast Logistics, the substantial-injustice threshold was part of the test for disqualifying a proposal creditor for abuse of process or tortious or near-tortious conduct. The appellate reasons explain that a creditor with a blocking vote could cause substantial injustice by engineering an unnecessary bankruptcy for an improper purpose. The threshold takes its wording from subsection 187(9), which separately protects proceedings in bankruptcy from invalidation for a formal defect or irregularity unless the court finds substantial injustice caused by it that no court order can remedy.

    book-of-authorities-of-concord-re- · cdncases.alixpartners.com section-187.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • The appellate reasons recognized honest belief in better recovery in bankruptcy and bargaining for greater concessions as legitimate explanations in the case. In context, the registrar was entitled to infer an improper purpose from the overall evidence, including the creditor’s earlier withdrawn demand for direct customer billing, subsequent customer contacts and the weakness of its commercial explanation in light of the trustee’s assessment. The appellate court accepted that the registrar could infer a plan to obtain the debtor’s business or customers by forcing bankruptcy.

    book-of-authorities-of-concord-re- · cdncases.alixpartners.com

  • Justice Milman explained that buying into an estate after proceedings begin may be important evidence of an abuse but is not an essential element. The Court rejected the argument that Prudential’s status as an existing creditor made it legally incapable of abusing the proposal process.

    book-of-authorities-of-concord-re- · cdncases.alixpartners.com

Canada BIA Division I creditor notices and publication after proposal refusal

Library record saved 2026-11-15

Research scope and limits

Hold whether and how subsection 102(4) operates when a bankruptcy creditors’ meeting was called forthwith under paragraph 57(c)(i). Section 57 deems that meeting called under section 102, and literal advance publication timing presents a fit question. No exemption or corrective procedure is inferred. Hold the precise publication-medium and regional approval rules in the operative Directive 23. Its indexed original PDF yielded zero numbered lines and the screenshot attempt reported a cache miss. The HTML itself designates the PDF as controlling. Draft Directive 23R is evidence of proposal and status only. Hold the operative PDF wording of Forms 38, 39, 41 and 42. The OSB forms index supports the form identifications. The public HTML for Forms 39 and 42 describes their instructions as rendered. Any difference in the operative PDF and any particular trustee appointment date, quorum, certificate issuance date, requisite publication, court order, remedy or actual deadline remain unverified. Verified Rule 94 with a review-sealed copy whose rewritten-result URL header alone is normalized. Keep creditor refusal immediate quorum branch distinct from no quorum and court refusal branches. Certificate-triggered meeting notice, appointment-triggered bankruptcy notice and the publication rule have distinct triggers. Preserve the unresolved application of advance publication to a forthwith meeting, controlling form PDFs and Directive 23 PDF, and case-specific dates, notices and remedies. Draft 23R and the annual report establish proposal status only.

Canada Division I proposal creditor objections at the court approval hearing

Library record saved 2026-11-16

Research scope and limits

Exact R029 adopted findings and claim/coverage JSON were screened for hearing objections, written or formal objection, subsection 59(1), Rule 3, Rule 13 and the three case names. E195U-C001 already covers subsection 59(1) participation, E197M-C001 covers opposition in a secured-class challenge, and E194M-C013 and E194Y-C003 cover section 58 notice, report and timing. E194A-C014 and E195U cover substantive approval gates. E197A-C002 applies Rule 3 in contract assignment. E201P and E201T concern vote redetermination and irregularity, E196N proof adjudication and E195I-C006 and E198W trustee-discharge objections and fee. This pass adds the limited present-day motion rule distinction, historical representation decision and the distinct court-stage handling in Wandler and National Traffic. Hold a universal written objection requirement or exemption, form, creditor-side deadline, service list, standing of disputed or unproven claimants, late-filing relief, costs, case-specific docket and court orders. Subsection 58(b)’s proved-claim notice list and 15-day trustee notice requirement are distinct from the creditor’s response. McNamara applies historical law. Wandler and National Traffic show the court’s conduct on those records. Rules 3, 11 and 13 original captures verified. The two review-sealed copies normalize URL headers only. Rule 13 applies to the moving party. McNamara applies historical Rule 4 in its circumstances. Wandler concerns approval-stage performance security. National Traffic relies on the February 24 endorsement recording approval effective February 20, 2025. The release explanation is attributed to trustee counsel. Preserve holds on universal written objections, timing, service, standing and case-specific procedure.

  • Section 59(1) requires the approval court to hear a creditor opposing or dissenting. General Rule 3 applies the court’s ordinary procedure to gaps, to the extent consistent with the Act and General Rules. Under Rule 11 an application ordinarily proceeds by motion unless the court orders otherwise, and Rule 13’s one-day filing provision addresses the party making a motion, subject to an exigency order. Those provisions supply different procedural rules for hearing opposition and making an application.

    section-59.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca FullText.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca section-3.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca

  • In Re McNamara, paragraph 3, Saunders J. considered counsel’s approval-hearing submissions for creditors where at least one creditor in each estate was entitled to object. The judge held that the ordinary-procedure provision then cited did not compel a prior written objection in the circumstances. Counsel represented several objectors, and the judge did not need to establish that all were eligible.

    10_Brief%20of%20MicroPlanet%20file · www.insolvencies.deloitte.ca

  • In Re Wandler, CRA’s negative vote and proxy did not reach the trustee in time for the creditors’ meeting. The proposal carried at the meeting. CRA subsequently opposed court approval on the ground of inadequate performance security under subsection 59(3). The court held that creditor approval alone did not justify lowering the required performance security and dismissed the approval application.

    section-59.html · laws-lois.justice.gc.ca bench-brief-application-approval-o · mnpdebt.ca

  • In Re National Traffic Safety Management Inc., the sole creditor that did not vote in favour appeared to object to the amended proposal after meeting acceptance. The court’s endorsement records the trustee counsel’s explanation that the approval and releases would preserve possible claims against the alleged perpetrators of the fraud raised by the creditor. The court approved the amended proposal.

    NATIONAL-TRAFFIC-SAFETY-MANAGEMENT · cases.tdbadvisory.ca