Research notes

How to read debt-relief success rates and research results

Sources checked November 16, 20262 min readPrint

Short answer

Ask who was counted, which debts were included, what counted as success and whether fees and unresolved debt were measured. A settled account and a completed household plan are different units of analysis.

Write down the denominator

For any success percentage, ask whether the starting group includes everyone who enrolled, only people still active, or only people who completed. Ask how many people left and how their debts were treated. Record the study dates and follow-up period beside the percentage.

Know what credit-record research can measure

CFPB’s July 2020 study used credit-record data for 2007–2019. It identified creditor-reported settlements and some counseling activity. Those records did not distinguish a direct settlement from one handled by a settlement company, and generally did not show the actual amount paid to settle.

Separate money measures

For an offer or study, distinguish enrolled balance, later balance, amount paid to creditors, provider fees and unpaid debts. The study’s recorded balance before settlement cannot simply be used as the consumer’s payment amount. Use the full-cost worksheet when comparing your own scenario.

Record what the evidence leaves unanswered

A study can describe observed outcomes without showing that the program caused them. Check the comparison group and missing records. Ask whether the result applies to your debt type, creditor and financial position. Keep an unsupported provider promise outside your estimate.

Questions to ask about a debt-relief success claim
Claim presentedInformation to request
Percent of people helpedEveryone enrolled, including withdrawals, and the follow-up period
Debt reducedStarting balances, fees, actual creditor payments and unresolved balances
Program successWhether the measure is one account, a household or the whole program
Better than alternativesThe comparison group and what other explanations were tested

Rules, exceptions and limits

Research-reading guidance, with a specifically dated CFPB example. The 2020 report excludes debt-buyer-furnished accounts and describes reporting limitations. This page supplies no current provider success ranking or estimate of your likelihood of settlement.

Sources

  1. CFPB — debt settlement and counseling study, July 2020

Sources checked November 16, 2026

Tell us what you owe. We’ll help you find the way through.

It takes about two minutes. Free to ask, no credit check, no obligation.

Get my options