The question behind the example
On a fictional $10,000 enrolled balance settled for $6,000, a 20% fee on enrolled debt is $2,000. A 20% fee on the $4,000 reduction is $800. These are different fee bases. The arithmetic does not establish whether either fee is permitted.
Read the relevant rules and next steps
How to calculate settlement costs when some debts remain unpaid
Measure all the debts you enrolled. Add payments to creditors, provider and account fees, and the current amount still due on unresolved accounts. Keep separately any funds you still own, possible tax and any uncertain payoff amounts.
Scope and exceptions
Use the enrollment balances as a baseline when evaluating a program’s savings claims. For your decision today, compare only the costs you would still face under each option, using the same starting date and balances. Treat the updated balance as an estimate of what you could owe today and revise it when you have a verified payoff. Canceled debt can be taxable unless an exception or exclusion applies.
What to ask before hiring a debt settlement company
Ask for a written estimate that shows which accounts the company plans to handle, what you could pay in total, when any fee is earned, and what happens if a creditor refuses. Compare that with direct negotiation and a debt management plan.
Scope and exceptions
The Telemarketing Sales Rule can cover outbound sales calls and covered inbound calls made in response to advertisements. Its scope and exemptions depend on the seller, communications and transaction. State rules may separately govern registration, fee limits, disclosures and cancellation rights. When a covered service resolves enrolled debts individually, federal rules generally require the fee to be proportional to the enrolled debt or a consistent percentage of savings, depending on the fee model.
Primary sources
These are the primary sources cited by the linked guides. Read each guide’s specific scope before applying a rule.
- CFPB · How unsettled accounts can offset savings
- FTC · Savings claims, enrollment balances and fees
- IRS · Publication 4681 and tax treatment of canceled debts
- Federal regulation · 16 CFR § 310.4(a)(5)
- CFPB · Counseling, settlement and consolidation compared
- eCFR · 16 CFR 310.4 debt-relief fee and account rules